LIVE GST Certification Course by CA Arun Chhajer begins 21st April. Register Now!!

Ca failed student committed suicide

rohit (student) (360 Points)

17 August 2012

Friends, Am very sad to share news that a student in West godavari district , ANdhra pradesh has committed a suicide after having known that he failed in ipcc results which were recently announced.

He was a son of a farmer and was terribly disappointed for his failure and hanged himself.

Resource :- EEnadu Newspaper dated 17/08/2012.

I know that Failure is not easy to take. But it is not the end of Everything. Try and try until u Succeed. And apart from CA , there are many other courses and opportunities in life. Just a failure in an exam is not the end of Life.

I express my deep sorrow feelings for him. May his soul rest in peace.

Reply
Follow
Share

20 Replies

SINGARAYANI (BANKER) (200 Points)
Replied 17 August 2012

May his soul rest in peace.

CA Sanjay Bag (CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT) (3340 Points)
Replied 17 August 2012

Yes, now he really failed. My friends life of full of opportunies so go for it. Do not forget we all doing or pursuing CA so that we can live a better life ( not only in the sense of money) but if you last your life then what does it is really mean? even I have gonethrough this situation for several times but I come back. At the end of the road I question myself if I really loved my course how can I leave this world without completing it. However, if there is any haven please God give my friend some peace.

Forum D Saiya (Employee) (212 Points)
Replied 17 August 2012

May his soul rest in peace

vasudevan (.) (376 Points)
Replied 17 August 2012

Originally posted by : Sanjay Bag
	Yes, now he really failed. My friends life of full of opportunies so go for it. Do not forget we all doing or pursuing CA so that we can live a better life ( not only in the sense of money) but if you last your life then what does it is really mean? even I have gonethrough this situation for several times but I come back. At the end of the road I question myself if I really loved my course how can I leave this world without completing it. However, if there is any haven please God give my friend some peace.

Mamta Singh (Article assitenance ) (73 Points)
Replied 17 August 2012

I have also given 5 attempts but i didn't cleared even in any subject & committing suicide is not a solution...........

v have other options also........

S Jananikrishna (Learner) (218 Points)
Replied 17 August 2012

Death is not the full stop..even there is a life after that for a soul...

TRY TRY TRY AGAIN UNTIL U SUCCEED..................................

Haran (Practice) (382 Points)
Replied 17 August 2012

such a sad news to the ca community-now we can't do anything to bringhim back to life,but can prevent others from taking such a drastic step,for that even friends in auditfirms,seniors etc should motivate eachothers instead of cricticising the juniors or peron who fail in the exams,those who are not in the office or doing selfstudy,do meet other friends and share your problems withothers instead of keeping it to self,many people are there in many offices who after clearing their exams think they are superior to others,even till now any of us behaved rudely with others,we can change now as ca or for that matter any course is not superior to human life,we may not become ca but that is not the end of the day or world,by not becoming a ca may be we did not meet our expectations of our self and others but in the end life is more important,quit ca but not life,ca is not the only course or pinnacle of a course,not all have same patience or aptitude for doing it,we can work hard and if it is not happening,then just leave the rest and move on,world may say anything quitter,looser or anything,but our life is more precious,one can do manythings even without ca or for that matter anyeducation,work hard but not at the expense of health for to prove to anyone,study,relax,and if it is going to come(results) so be it....never ever any ca student or for that matter any student should end his life.

please friends share all your problems in cci or anyother site but talk,don't hide your feelings.

1 Like

CA. MANOJKUMAR SONI (CA) (145 Points)
Replied 17 August 2012

Very dispairing news, may his soul rest in peace and the almighty GOD bless his family members with all strenghts. SUICIDE should not be the way to express dispairity for any FAILURE. Failure should be taken as an Opportunity to find our mistakes that caused such failure and to be more positive in our efforts to defeat such failure in all our next attempts in every field and aspects of our life, because " LIFE IS A VERY PRECIOUS GIFT FROM GOD. "

CA Monika Khandelwal (Accountant) (21 Points)
Replied 17 August 2012

may his soul rest in peace......

dear friends, ups & down come in our life but to end your life..its not a solution...even,we should face & fight them.......

puja agarwal (STUDENT) (49 Points)
Replied 17 August 2012

suicide is not d ultimate solution . it like it end up of everthing nd d ultimate defat, it not d solution it a stupid activity nd may say that i1 is proving themself cowars by doing see. i just believe that everything achivment is possible not matter what circumstances u r going through what u have to posses is strong determination

LCS AJAY IYER (Sr Executive: Taxation) (41 Points)
Replied 17 August 2012

I failed in PCC 5 times and got through the 6th time... (May-11) , one thing we have to realise that failure moulds us into a stronger and mentally harder person , i know that the words "FAIL" on the day of result depresses us we feel like dying and all sorts of things, but one thing think about the effect on your parents... and faling does not mean you are a looser the day you quit you are a looser. .....

how long can ICAI stop us from passing... i know many friendsof mine who failed in CA exams but all are sucessful in their lives and they have completed CA too. if dying was a solution to our problems then there would be no human beings on this earth ...

one last line to say before i sign off :- "When you are pushed to the end of the rope , tie a knot and hang on dont let go, who knows someone will lend a hand"

1 Like

CA Ashish Pathak (Employed at Cipla Ltd.) (2779 Points)
Replied 17 August 2012

Suicide was not the solution rather it has further enhanced the problems of his parents. He passed away but his parents will neither be able to live nor die.... No festival will be like festival for his parents now. Academic failure can never conclude your failure in life. I do believe the paper correction system of ICAI is not at all reliable. There are many who deserve but fails. But we cant really help it. At times we just have to accept the things the way they are and move on. But suicide was never a solution to this. This is really upsetting news. May the good God bless his soul and give strength to his parents to accept this loss. Rest in peace.

1 Like

CA Sanjay Bag (CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT) (3340 Points)
Replied 17 August 2012

Bhai, even one of our all time greatest player Sachin have to have wait for a long time for his frist ODI century nad also century of centuries. So, we have to accept this failure.

ananya (know thyself) (930 Points)
Replied 17 August 2012

i can't believe this...an ipcc failed student did this..i mean there were so many options before him...anyway i dnt have any sympathy for this guy...my heart goes out to his parents...i fail to understand y people don't think about their parents before taking such a drastic step...