Assets partly used for business; How to claim fair proportionate depreciation in ITR-3? (Section 38)

Efiling 484 views 4 replies

In a sole proprietorship business scenario where some of the fixed-assets (like computers, servers/routers, smartphone, etc.) are sometimes used for personal purposes, in addition to their intended business purposes; as per Section 38(2), Income-tax Act, it allows a fair proportionate part of depreciation calculated based on estimated business-usage of the fixed-assets that are not exclusively used for business purposes.

When we look at the depreciation schedules of the ITR-3 form (Schedule DPM and Schedule DOA, to be precise), we do not see any option to mention a proportionate depreciation.

Mathematically my understanding is:

If an asset, say a new workstation computer, was put to use since April 1 of the previous year, and had a cost of ₹50,000, and the rate of depreciation allowable as per Income-tax is %40. We put this amount as additions in the Schedule DPM and the form automatically calculates the depreciation for us.
Depreciation = 40% of ₹50,000 = ₹20,000

Keeping all above parameters same, with estimated business-use of 30%, and we can calculate the fair proportionate part of depreciation as below.
Depreciation = 30% of (40% of ₹50,000) = ₹6,000

Now obviously, if we reduce the cost of asset by 30% (basis its estimated business usage), and then we put the amount in the Schedule DPM, it will result in the same amount of depreciation.
Adjusted cost of asset = 30% of ₹50,000 = ₹15,000
Depreciation = 40% of ₹15,000 = ₹6,000

I would like to know if this type of adjustment to the cost of asset, basis its estimated business usage percentage, is a generally accepted accounting practice for income-tax purposes.

PS:
I do not have a commerce background. Thanks in advance for any helpful input.

Replies (4)
This type of adjustment is logical but rarely followed.
Such an adjustment is not a generally accepted accounting practice for income tax purposes

I forgot to mention this earlier, back when I posted the original question. I overlooked the provision to enter proportionate depreciation at that time.

For the record, Schedule DPM and Schedule DOA include a provision to enter Depreciation disallowed under Section 38(2) of the Income Tax Act. This implies that we can determine the fair proportion attributable to personal use and then claim the balance as allowable business depreciation, with the disallowed portion specifically reported under Section 38(2) in Schedule DPM and Schedule DOA.

Yes — the correct place to show proportionate usage is in:

  • Schedule DPM → Column: “Depreciation disallowed u/s 38(2)”

  • Schedule DOA (if intangible assets / others apply)

There is no need to manipulate or reduce the cost of the asset to ₹15,000.
The law expects the cost to remain intact, and only depreciation to be restricted.

 


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register