148a reply and objection

the assessee was partner in partnership firm which was engaged in ploting/land devloping. A property was purchased by firm due the owing power of attorney reported on the assessee pan by the registrar office. it was shown as stock in trade in firms bs for the year. there was 12 partner and pruchase consideration was or 1.20 cr a.y 14-15.
what will be better either to reply with the fact or take objection for being below 50lkh for each partner. how to proceed....
Replies (9)
Quick Summary
This discussion concerns a Section 148A notice issued to partners of a land developing firm regarding a property purchased by the firm. The property was registered under an assessee's PAN due to a power of attorney and shown as stock-in-trade. The core question is whether to object to the notice because each partner's share is below the ₹50 lakh threshold, or to reply with the facts, explaining the property belongs to the firm and the PAN was used due to partnership. The advice leans towards replying with facts, as a Section 148A(b) notice is a show-cause notice and challenging it directly is not advisable.

Reply with fact
@ Ajeet Singh ,

Are partners received 148A or partnership firm?
Partner
Were the partners filed ITR ?
148A issued only if return not filed.
Partners are regular filers, notice issued to partners

A section 148A(b) notice is a show cause notice and no challenge lies against that notice even if there are not adequate reasons mentioned in the notice. The correct approach is to file your response under Section 148A(c) and await the order under Section 148A(d). With the order under Section 148A(d), a Section 148 notice will be issued. You may then file a writ petition challenging the notice and order.

@ Rashmi ,

Will your answer change now ?
Then reply with the facts that assets belong to partnership firm and same is reported in firm returns.

PAN of assessee was used only because he is partner in the firm

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register