Central Excise: Remand of adjudication on technical grounds is not exoneration; prosecution under Section 9 continues - SC


Quick Summary
The Supreme Court has ruled that a remand of an excise adjudication case on technical grounds does not equate to exoneration for the accused. The court found that even if an initial order was set aside due to procedural issues, it did not negate the evidence supporting the criminal complaint. Therefore, criminal prosecution under the Central Excise Act can proceed, as the adjudication being unsettled does not render the allegations 'groundless'.

Court :
Supreme Court of India

Brief :
After a search revealed alleged clandestine manufacture and removal of excisable goods, a company, a group company and a director faced prosecution under Sections 9 and 9AA of the Central Excise Act, 1944. They sought discharge, arguing that the departmental adjudication order on which the complaint rested had been set aside by the High Court. The Supreme Court held that a direction for fresh adjudication on technical or procedural grounds, without considering the merits, is not equivalent to exoneration on merits, so the allegations did not become groundless. The complaint prima facie disclosed an offence. The trial court and High Court orders refusing discharge were upheld and the appeal dismissed.

Citation :
Criminal Appeal No. 268/2017 dated July 24, 2025

2025 INSC 901Criminal Appeal No. 268 of 2017

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 268 OF 2017

M/S RIMJHIM ISPAT

LIMITED AND OTHERS … APPELLANT(S)

VERSUS

UNION OF INDIA & ANOTHER … RESPONDENT(S)

J U D G M E N T

AUGUSTINE GEORGE MASIH, J.

1. The present Criminal Appeal is moved against concurrent findings of dismissal of discharge application by the Special Chief Judicial

Magistrate at Kanpur Nagar, Uttar Pradesh

(hereinafter, “Trial Court”) and the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad (hereinafter, “High

Court”) as moved by M/s Rimjhim Ispat

Limited, M/s Juhi Alloys Limited, and Shri

Yogesh Aggarwal (hereinafter, “Appellants”) in the criminal proceedings that were initiated

Criminal Appeal No. 268 of 2017 against it under Section 9 and 9AA of the

Central Excise Act, 1944 (hereinafter, “CEA

1944”).

2. Against the Judgment dated 05.02.2016 passed by the High Court (hereinafter,

“Impugned Judgment”), the strength of the argument for discharge application, as raised by the Appellants has primarily been the quashing of departmental proceedings initiated by the Respondent No.2 herein

(hereinafter, “Respondent-Department”)

against the Appellant by the High Court in Writ

Tax No.771 of 2015 on similar grounds, the criminal proceedings are, not sustainable against the Appellants.

3. The factual matrix, as selectively presented by the Appellants, reveals that on 22.11.2007, a search was conducted at the premises, offices and factories, of Appellant No.1, unearthing serious irregularities that culminated in the initiation of proceedings via two separate Show

Cause Notices (hereinafter, “SCNs”). The first,

Criminal Appeal No. 268 of 2017 dated 16.05.2008 (hereinafter, “First SCN”), alleged clandestine manufacture and illicit removal of excisable goods. The second, dated

06.03.2009 (hereinafter, “Second SCN”), attributed direct and vicarious liability to the

Director(s) of Appellant No.1 (specifically,

Appellant No.3) and M/s Juhi Alloys Limited, being Appellant No.2 herein, for such unlawful removal of excisable goods during the

Financial Year 2006-07, along with evasion of excise duty, interest, and penal consequences.

4. While the proceedings under the First SCN were dropped by the Additional Commissioner of Central Excise at Kanpur, the seized goods were released vide Order dated 14.07.2009.

The said decision was subsequently affirmed by the Commissioner (Appeals) on 18.01.2010, and this outcome appears to have emboldened the Appellants, who overlooked the serious and distinct liabilities arising under the Second

SCN.

Criminal Appeal No. 268 of 2017

5. In relation to the Second SCN, the

Commissioner of Central Excise at Kanpur, vide Order dated 31.03.2011, upheld a substantial demand amounting to INR

6,68,94,028/- (Rupees Six Crores Sixty-Eight

Lakhs Ninety-Four Thousand and Twenty-Eight only) along with interest against Appellants No.1 and 2, and further imposed a penalty of INR 25,00,000/- (Rupees Twenty-Five Lakhs only) upon Appellant No. 03 under Section 11AC of the CEA 1944, indicative of the gravity of their violations.

6. The Appellants sought relief before the

Customs Excise and Service Tax Appellate

Tribunal at New Delhi (hereinafter, “CESTAT”), which, while setting aside the said order on procedural grounds vide Order dated

25.02.2013, rather than addressing the merits of the findings, remanded the matter for de novo consideration, inter alia, observing that joint confirmation of duty against separate legal entities was impermissible, and liability was required to be assessed individually.

Criminal Appeal No. 268 of 2017

7. Exploiting the CESTAT’s procedural indulgence, the Appellants then proceeded to contest the initiation of criminal proceedings by the Respondent-Department. These proceedings stemmed from the Sanction Order dated 03.05.2013 by Directorate General of

Central Intelligence (hereinafter, “DGCEI”) for prosecuting the Appellants under Sections 9 and 9AA of the CEA 1944, a sanction that was said to be based on the Commissioner’s findings dated 31.03.2011, which the

Appellants allege was relied upon through suppression of the CESTAT’s remand order by the very same Commissioner.

8. An inquiry letter dated 07.10.2013 was issued by the concerned Assistant Commissioner seeking clarification regarding the validity of the Sanction Order dated 03.05.2013, particularly given that it was premised on a now-set-aside adjudication order.

Nevertheless, the Commissioner reiterated his direction to proceed with prosecution,

Criminal Appeal No. 268 of 2017 persisting in his stand despite the procedural setback.

9. Consequently, Complaint Case No. 841 of 2014 was instituted before the Trial Court under

Sections 9 and 9AA of the CEA 1944

(hereinafter, “Complaint”), and summons were issued against the Appellants on 02.05.2014, signalling the commencement of criminal proceedings based on the evidence then available.

10. In response, the Appellants sought to stall the criminal trial by invoking the jurisdiction of the

High Court under Section 482 of the Code of

Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter, “CrPC

1973”), through Criminal Misc. 482

Application No. 31300 of 2014. The High

Court, while granting interim protection, refused to quash the proceedings outright and directed the Appellants to avail the remedy of discharge before the Trial Court vide Order dated 21.08.2014.

Criminal Appeal No. 268 of 2017

11. Following this direction, the Appellants moved a discharge application under Section 245(2) of

CrPC 1973 before the Trial Court. The matter was heard on 24.08.2015 and listed for orders on 01.09.2015, with the Appellants attempting to shield themselves from prosecution based on technicalities.

12. Meanwhile, the re-adjudication pursuant to the Order dated 25.02.2013 of the CESTAT, culminated in a fresh Order dated 28.08.2015 by the Commissioner of Central Excise at

Kanpur, again recording adverse findings against the Appellants, including reimposition of demands and penalties. This order was duly submitted as an addendum in the pending

Complaint.

13. A writ petition being Writ Tax No. 771 of 2015 was thereafter filed by the Appellants challenging this second adjudication. It was only after the Trial Court rejected the discharge applications, the High Court vide Judgment dated 17.11.2015 intervened in the writ, not

Criminal Appeal No. 268 of 2017 due to any exoneration on the merits of the claim put forth on the part of the Appellants, but primarily due to procedural lapses and conduct attributable to the Commissioner of

Central Excise at Kanpur. The High Court set aside the Order dated 28.08.2015 and directed the matter to be re-adjudicated afresh this time by the Commissioner at Lucknow, instead of

Kanpur.

14. During the pendency of the above writ petition, as stated above, the Trial Court dismissed the discharge application of the Appellants vide

Order dated 09.10.2015, holding that adjudication and prosecution were independent processes and that the Appellants had not yet been absolved of the underlying liabilities in the departmental proceedings.

15. Dissatisfied with the rejection of their discharge plea, the Appellants preferred

Criminal Revision No. 4581 of 2015 before the

High Court, seeking to overturn the Order dated 09.10.2015 of the Trial Court. This

Criminal Appeal No. 268 of 2017 approach to the High Court again reflected the

Appellants’ repeated attempts to evade prosecution without securing a clean slate on merits from the Respondent-Department.

16. The High Court, while passing the Impugned

Judgment, relied on decision of this Court in

Radheshyam Kejriwal v. State of West

Bengal and Another1 to reiterate the findings of the Trial Court. It went on to observe that the objection(s) to taking of Order dated

28.08.2015 on record have no force as there exists prima facie evidence against the

Appellants to proceed with the concerned

Complaint. It is not for the Trial Court to determine whether matter will lead to conviction or not, rather only material on record is to be analyzed to determine sufficiency of a prima facie case while issuing the summons. Therefore, observing that the adjudication is still not settled in favour of the

Appellants and that there is a prima facie case against the Appellants, the Criminal Revision

1 (2011) 3 SCC 581

Criminal Appeal No. 268 of 2017

No. 4581 of 2015 was dismissed by the learned

Single Judge of the High Court vide judgment dated 05.02.2016.

17. Challenging the said Impugned Judgment, the

Appellants moved this Court vide Special Leave

Petition (Criminal) No. 2583 of 2016 for which leave was granted, leading to the instant

Criminal Appeal.

18. Assailing the Impugned Judgment, it is argued by the learned Senior Advocate on behalf of the

Appellants that the basis of the Complaint was solely the sanction granted on the strength of the Order dated 31.03.2011, which had been set aside already, making it non-maintainable.

Even the Order dated 28.08.2015, which was passed behind the back of the Appellants, was also set aside with harsh observations against the Commissioner of Central Excise at Kanpur.

This fact was ignored by both the Trial Court and the High Court while considering their discharge application, and revision petition respectively.

Criminal Appeal No. 268 of 2017

19. It is further brought on record that the subsequent order passed by the Commissioner of Central Excise at Lucknow vide Order dated

31.03.2017 was also conditionally stayed by the High Court in Writ Tax No. 370 of 2017 vide

Order dated 31.05.2017. Collectively, it is argued that there is a violation of Article 21 for dealing the instant case in contravention or violation of the procedure established by law.

20. Taking exception to the approach adopted by the Trial Court, learned Senior Counsel contends that the Trial Court failed to maintain the mandatory distinction in approach while dealing with an application for discharge under

Section 245(1) of CrPC 1973 and that under

245(2) of CrPC 1973. For this, he submits that, as is the case for Section 245(1) of CrPC 1973, the Trial Court considered and relied upon evidence that emerged subsequent to filing of the Complaint. Reference is also made to the observation vis-à-vis Section 8 of the CEA

1944, wherein, allegedly, the non-existent

Criminal Appeal No. 268 of 2017 application by the Appellants was relied upon by the Trial Court. Instead, it is the case of the

Appellants that only the contents of the

Complaint and the application for discharge should have been considered. To substantiate the aforesaid claim, reliance is placed on the aspect of this legal distinction as elaborated by this Court in Ajoy Kumar Ghose v. State of

Jharkhand and Another2.

21. Moving on to the approach of the High Court, he assailed the non-appreciation of fact that no order existed which could be made the basis of the prosecution against the Appellants. Even the Order dated 28.08.2015 had already been quashed by the Division Bench of the High

Court. Even further, the learned Single Judge did not take note of the erroneous approach as adopted by the Trial Court while dealing with the application for discharge. Had it been so done, the Appellants would have been successful in their application for discharge, as the Complaint would have been recorded as

2 (2009) 14 SCC 115

Criminal Appeal No. 268 of 2017

“groundless”, as was defined in State of Tamil

Nadu v. R. Soundirarasu and Others3.

22. Having said that, the learned Senior Advocate, placing reliance on Ram Prakash Chadha v.

State of Uttar Pradesh4, further asserts that owing to no legal evidence, the charge would be groundless and thereafter compelling the

Appellants to face the trial is contrary to the procedure established by law as envisaged under Article 21 of the Constitution of India,

1950. He further asserts that having lost the case before the CESTAT, the Respondent-Department had only acted in vindication against the Appellants and has not followed the principles of natural justice, which would, held in the decision of this Court in A.R.

Antulay v. R.S. Nayak and Another5, render the act or proceedings a nullity.

23. Finally, in his attempt to distinguish the decision in Radheyshyam Kejriwal (supra),

3 (2023) 6 SCC 768

4 (2024) 10 SCC 651

5 (1988) 2 SCC 602

Criminal Appeal No. 268 of 2017 learned Senior Counsel submits that unlike in this case, the dispute involved in the said case was under the Foreign Exchange Regulations

Act, 1973, which cannot be equated to CEA

1944. Moreover, the criminal prosecution and the adjudication proceedings were initiated almost simultaneously, with independent specific averments of facts. Even the application for discharge was not filed under

Section 245(2) of CrPC 1973. Furthermore, while the adjudication proceedings were not held as binding on the criminal proceedings, herein, the entire Complaint is based on a non-existent Order as it stood quashed by the High Court.

24. On the basis of the above submissions, prayer has, thus, been made for allowing the appeal by setting aside the Impugned Judgment and allowing the application for discharge of the

Appellant.

25. The learned Additional Solicitor General

(hereinafter, “ASG”) appearing on behalf of the

Criminal Appeal No. 268 of 2017

Union of India, has primarily placed reliance on the observations made in the decision of this Court in Radheyshyam Kejriwal (supra)

to assert the legality of having parallel and continuation of adjudication proceedings and criminal proceedings against the Appellants.

Reference was also made to the decision in Air

Customs Officer IGI, New Delhi v. Pramod

Kumar Dhamija6 wherein the aforesaid decision was relied upon to observe that when exoneration in the adjudication proceedings was not based on merits or that the accused was not yet found to be innocent, the concerned High Court had committed an error in accepting the prayer for quashing of the proceedings.

26. Further reliance is placed on the contents of the Complaint to assert and reiterate the liability of the Appellants. While denying the assertions made by the Appellants, the learned

ASG denies that the proceedings were vindictive, there is no independent basis for the

6 (2016) 4 SCC 153

Criminal Appeal No. 268 of 2017

Complainant, or there was suppression of facts by the Commissioner of Central Excise at

Kanpur as contended by the Appellants. He further contends that there is no prescribed time limit for launching of prosecution.

Accordingly, the learned ASG has prayed for dismissal of the instant Criminal Appeal, holding the Impugned Judgment as good in law.

27. We have perused the pleadings, materials and documents on record, including the Complaint as also the submissions rendered before us by the parties.

28. Considering the contentions of the Appellant on the aspect of reliance on a non-existent

Order dated 31.03.2011, on it having been set aside, even assuming the said contention to be so, it is clear from the materials on record that investigation and the Complaint are still in sustenance against the Appellants. The contents of the Complaint reveal that there is no reliance placed on the now-set aside Order

Criminal Appeal No. 268 of 2017 dated 31.03.2011 rather it was only referred as an addendum to complete the sequence of facts of the case of the Respondent-Department. The irregularities which came to light on search and the contents of the investigation report, are sufficient to observe and opine prima facie on the existence of allegations as mentioned in the complaint against the Appellants, at the time of the consideration made by the Trial

Court justifying the passing of the summoning order.

29. Even the contention on the conditional stay of the Order dated 31.03.2017 passed by the

Commissioner of Central Excise at Lucknow by the High Court in Writ Tax No. 370 of 2017 does not come to the assistance of the

Appellants. The above Order dated 31.08.2017 has been passed on merits by the

Commissioner of Central Excise at Lucknow in pursuance to and in compliance with the directions issued by the High Court vide Order dated 31.05.2017. Further, stay thereof, was subject to the payment of the liability imposed

Criminal Appeal No. 268 of 2017 on the Appellants by impugned order in the pending writ and submission of surety on the penalty imposed.

30. The Order dated 31.03.2017, impugned in the aforesaid writ has been passed on merits, and that too not by the concerned Commissioner of

Central Excise at Kanpur, against whom there were allegations of vindication, but by that of

Lucknow. Further, stay thereof, was still subject to the payment of the liability imposed by the Commissioner of Central Excise at

Lucknow on the Appellants and submission of surety on the penalty imposed.

31. Collectively, in the light of aforesaid perusal of the relevant orders, a reference to

Radheyshyam Kejriwal (supra) reveals that, as in the present case, there is no bar on parallel proceedings, with one being by the

Respondent-Department and the other being criminal in nature, under the CEA 1944.

Further, the attempt of the Appellants to distinguish the said decision, is primarily

Criminal Appeal No. 268 of 2017 reliant on the observation that the Complaint was solely based on the Order dated

31.03.2011, which, at the time had been set-aside. However, a direction for de novo proceedings on technical or procedural grounds cannot be assumed to be in equivalence to having been set-aside on merits, when it was specifically mentioned that the merits have not been considered. Hence, we are inclined to accept and adopt the decision in

Pramod Kumar Dhamija (supra) as referred by the learned ASG.

32. Reiterating further, the contention of the

Appellants that the allegations for the purpose of criminal complaint, were therefore, not rendered “groundless” as has been contented on behalf of Appellants through reliance on decision in R. Soundirarsu (supra), is again, on the assumption and contention that the

Order dated 31.03.2011 or even the concerned subsequent Order dated 28.08.2015 was on merits. We are, therefore, in the light of our aforesaid observations, unable to appreciate

Criminal Appeal No. 268 of 2017 the submissions to this effect. Even the decision of this Court in Videocon Industries

Limited and Another v. State of

Maharashtra and Others7 reiterated the merit of criminal proceedings when the orders on the civil side, proceedings by the

Respondent-Department in the instant case, were passed on merits and not on technical foundation.

33. Moving on to the contentions raised and rendered on behalf of the Appellants on jurisprudence of discharge and the reliance thereof placed on Ajoy Kumar Ghose (supra)

are misconceived and outside the scope of adjudication in the present case as the said objections were never raised before the courts below. Despite the same, even placing reliance on the decisions of this Court, which have determined or reiterated the jurisprudence on law of discharge, such as the Vishnu Kumar

Shukla and Another v. State of Uttar

7 (2016) 12 SCC 315

Criminal Appeal No. 268 of 2017

Pradesh and Another8 and State of Tamil

Nadu v. N. Suresh Rajan and Others9 have been complied with while considering the case of the Appellants as the contents of the

Complaint prima facie makes out an offence under the statute for which it had been preferred.

34. Ergo, having perused the alleged conduct and the orders passed by the concerned authorities and the Courts below, the authorities relied upon by the Appellants are unable to substantiate their claim in the present facts and circumstances.

35. We are in favour of the submissions made by the learned ASG and accordingly, are not inclined to interfere with the Impugned

Judgment.

36. Hence, the instant Criminal Appeal is dismissed and the Impugned Judgment dated

05.02.2016 passed by the High Court of

8 (2023) 15 SCC 502

9 (2014) 11 SCC 709

Criminal Appeal No. 268 of 2017

Judicature at Allahabad is good in law, calling for no interference by this Court.

37. Any observations made hereinabove are for the purpose of disposal of this case only and shall have no bearing, whatsoever, on the merits of the proceedings before any court.

38. Pending applications, if any, also stand disposed of.

…...……………………………….CJI.

[ B.R. GAVAI ]

..……………………………………..J.

[ AUGUSTINE GEORGE MASIH ]

NEW DELHI;

JULY 24, 2025.

FAQ :

The case concerned whether a company could be discharged from criminal proceedings under the Central Excise Act when its departmental adjudication proceedings were remanded for re-adjudication on technical grounds, rather than being decided on their merits.

No, the Supreme Court dismissed the appeal, ruling that a remand of adjudication on technical grounds does not amount to exoneration and that criminal prosecution can continue.

Yes, the court held that if the setting aside of an adjudication order is due to procedural or technical reasons and not on merits, and if there is prima facie evidence, criminal proceedings can continue.

Adjudication proceedings are administrative processes to determine duty liabilities and penalties, while criminal prosecution is a separate legal process to punish offences under the Act. The Supreme Court affirmed that these can run in parallel.

No, the court clarified that a remand for de novo proceedings on technical grounds does not mean the allegations are 'groundless' for the purpose of criminal prosecution.

 



Judgement posted by

Guest

Comments




CCI Pro



Company
10 November 2026
Direct Tax Manager

CAAQ CONSULTANCY PVT LTD

New Delhi

CA Final

View Details
Company
16 November 2026
Assistant Article

ZAK & Co. Chartered Accountants

Bengaluru

CA Inter

View Details
Company
20 November 2026
Article

S & N CO

Mumbai

CA Inter

View Details
Company
16 November 2026
Indirect Tax Associate

Sekhri Kanodia & Associates

Mumbai

B.Com

View Details
Company
30 October 2026
Asst Manager Accounts

Goodwin Pumps India Pvt Ltd

Chengalpattu

CA Inter

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 14 November 2026
Article Assistant

Jitendra Agarwal & Associates

Bengaluru

CA Inter

View Details
Company
24 October 2026
CA Industrial Trainee

Fytomax Nutrition Private Limited

Aurangabad

CA Inter

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 28 October 2026
Article assistants

Shyam S Gupta and Company

New Delhi

CA Inter

View Details