who is really Top in top 30 Members

Acc. to me, C.A Amit Daga is the best and deserved first position because he got a really awesome knowledge,qualification and he is really practicle...If you ask any thing he will be give you very much practical reply and give you practicle suggestionas well as he is very good motivator.

Once i had words with him around 6 months back and i was totally fustrated with ca because  i was not able to cleared my inter since 3 attempts and i was decided to leave the ca because i am not able to find what mistake i am doing and where i am lacking Onthat time i send my problem to him and he told me ok you will be call me and intially he was asking abt me and talking with me in general and start knowing abt me and after that he told me my problem and suggest me that how to solved it and motivate me...and i got a result and  now i am in the final and in the previous three attempt i was never got 300 marks but  this time i got 402.

So, according to me C.A Amit Daga is the best without any doubt

Wats your opinion,

CA CHAITANYA  without any ques what so ever

Sweet, i second ur opinion....CA. Amit Daga, or Amit bhaiya as i call him..... is a really helpful person. He also had motivated me whn i was feeling low. & his approach is totally cool & bindaas kind of...i owe a lot to him.

CA. Dashrat Maheshwari is another gem of a person. truly a gr8 inspiration for all. The way he has struggled and achieved success in life is truly admirable...and Maheshwari Sir has always helped me a lot.

CAclubindia wouldnt hv been the same without Ms. Aisha's regular valuable contributions.

The above 3 are my picks. But the concept of best amongst Top30 is somewhat restrictive, as i would have liked to name many more people who dont feature in the list but are all at par.

I too second your opinion..!!

With hats off..!!

I too second your opinion..!!

With hats off..!!

it's a good idea.

but i would like to add on something here.

It's well known that whoever is in the top 30 has done something but might not be special. As we get points in many areas & different experts are good in different areas. Everbody on this site is helpful in different ways. 

It is very difficult to  judge a person that who is the best becz this is not a platform to know who is the best .

it is a platform to help others & get help from others, and to share knowledge & experience.

there are lot of person out here who are providing help for a long time .

Therefore ranking of members must not be personalized so that dignity can be maintained of our profession &  particulary of this forum.

 me too agree wid u...i m also in top members but wid struggules....but due to inactivity i m out of the list

Jitendar and Ravi, even i want to say this things only but in the diff way.Just due to points we cant judge who is the best and who is really good.Its just a matter of time .same message if u give 2 times u will be get double point.

Ranking should be depend upon the knowledge attitute and presentation of the person.

If we are saying he is the best, It does not mean others are not good. A student who got rank 1 in the class people says he is the best because he got highest marks but other who got other ranks like 2 3 4 or 5, they are also good but there is a bit diff between them.

Again thinking of people is vary from one person to another person.Like i bel sachin  is the best in cricket may be some people think e is not and some people think he sould retire. Every body has his own opinion
So, this is just a form where we can share our thoughts how we are benefited and why we think he is the best

As i said Amit Daga is the best supported by Jeet. Because once you will be talk to him you will be find why i said this.He dont have any kind of attitute cool and bindas kind of fellow who can read any body mind very easily and help him in the proper and reasonable way,which will be help them in there future

Like ravi said he was also one of the top member but with struggules now he is not there becuase he is inactive but it does not mean he is not good.

My idea behind this forum why not we give our opinion according to us who is best and why

If you think i am wrong i am extremely very very sorry, But i think i am right.

I do agree that only points should not be the only criteria to rate Top 30 members.

If you feel neccesity to give ratings to Members than i would suggest you to contact Admin and tell tham to provide us with rating button. is not it???

It will give chance to rate not only Top 30 members but also all CAClubindia members.

Atlast i repeat jitenders words:

" It is very difficult to  judge a person that who is the best becz this is not a platform to know who is the best. it is a platform to help others & get help from others, and to share knowledge & experience."

Finally i would not support to give rating to Members but i would support to give Rating to Massages/ Posts. It will not only save our time but also increase the productivity.

The discussion is going on the basis of points allotted to members for different activities and uploads in the site.

Experts are given separate ranks for their replies. So if some one want to evaluate one's rank with his replies to the queries, he should refer ranking of experts.

Please rectify me, if I am incorrect.

User should be able to give their personal rating and on that basis it should be convertable in points to decide who is the best .

if users start giving rank & rank the experts according to their personal ranking then this will involve behavioural aspect as well as personal judgement which is always subjective and which is not good for this particular platform.

ya i agreed with you guys

As Mr. Prakash said we gave separate rating.

Firstly i said rating patter should be diff for students there should be diff top 30 and for qualififed members there will be diff rankings..but again its difficult to judge with the point basis because you find people say ok. thanks etc lots of words and post a comment and get a points

O.P.Sir, as you said expert comment over there you find it lots of people repeat same messages. or some people give same mesaage so many times.. some people give vague answer which is not reliable.. so from expert point of view again ranking is not correct

Ravees as you said we decide for the points just think ur self is it possible ..we are indians yar hum tang khichne mai bel rakhte hai(haha wont mind yar just kidding)

As jitendar said user ranking is also not good

Thatswhy i made this form and share our thoughts and personal view who is best according to us.

Ok lets give top rank according to us and later on we will be sum up and we can decide who is really best

In that top 3 even those fellows who are not in the top 30 can come and every thing depend on there contribution on the basis of good files good replies etc

Hope now you guys will be happy with this suggestion

My top 3 is

1.C.A Amit Daga

2.C.A Dashrath Maheswari

3. Amit Sharma or Ravi Satpal (tie according to me)

Dear Friends,

In my opinion Kapil Sir is best among all of us...No doubt that Daga Ji is in line with him...

Thanks to all for the affections depicted to me but we should not judge that who are the top experts as our motive is to provide help, support, information, solution and a environment to CA profession and students of this profession as well.

Me as a member and expert on this portal suggest not to provide "user ranking system' instead there should be 'content ranking system' and repetative content should not get any points even repetative files should be deleted from the data base and only first uploaded file may be kept for the ranking.

Thanking to all,

**DM