I dont know is it too late to discuss it or not. But, seriously till now I dont understand the reason for so much restrictions on doing any other course along with C.A. I am an article trainee and have completeled 2.5 years of my training honestly. Alongwith my training I am also doing M.Com. (in 1st Year) by regular mode and the fact is that I havent took any permission from the Institute. Becaues I know that over 95% chances are that I wouldnt get the permission. Because my college neither finish before 9.30 AM nor begin after 6.00 PM, as any college of India. (Now this clause is a big joke, because none of the college in India atleast in my knowledge do that or would do that. Then, whats the meaning of this clause.) The reasons why I am doing M.Com. regular is that I cant play wiyh my future. If I dont become a C.A., then what I would be. A guy who has wasted his 2 years after doing B.Com. Even clearing PCC is not sufficient, because PCC/IPCC/ATC has no recognition for job. The only thing you can do is to work as an audit staff of any C.A. So, if ICAI cant guarantee my future, how it can restrict me or anyone else to assure his future. Who are they to restrict my education? I know its not only me, but thousands of students who are suffering from the same thing. Now how I am managing my regular course with my training is purely my headache. Its none of their job. Do they suspect there members? I know many students, who are doing nothing and taking dummy as well. But, thats ok with Institute. Now, if we bother their contention, that students may skip training for classes: See I dont think that a student is going to skip training for college classes, if he seriously wants to do training. Right? Now, if a student want to go on dummy, he would go, it doesnt matter is he doing anything else or not? If ICAI thought that, timings may conflict, then what the heck this is??????? If one can manage them both at the same time then where is the problem. As I earlier said, if a student want to go on dummy, he would go, it doesnt matter is he doing anything else or not? Now if a student cant manage, then he would obviously resort correspondence or other means. Now a question from the EC of the ICAI: THERE ARE MANY MEMBERS IN THE EC AND MANY BIG NAMES IN THE INDUSTRY WHO HAVE DONE MULTIPLE COURSES LIKE CA,CS,CWA,M.COM.,PHD AND MANY MORE. IF YOU BELEIVE THAT WE CANT DO THIS FOR ALL YOUR STUPID REASONS, THEN HOW THEY HAD DONE IT??? AND YES IF THEY HAD DONE IT ONE BY ONE, THEN JUST ESTIMATE THE TIME PERIOD OF DOING ALL THESE COURSES ONE BY ONE.
Menu
WHATS THE REASON AND WHY ?????
Replies (38)
Hi Abhisek, you are correct.. I done my B.com in correspondence bcz of all this nonsense.. ICAI has to take some action on this..
Yes abhishek, i totally agree wid u....
Asking for Permission to do another course wid CA is completely illogical.....
After all, who wud hv d guts to risk his career by doing the lengthiest course on earth i.e.CA....
ya i've suffered frm d same problem,then finally got d conclusion to do my B.com in correspondence 
Thats what I want to say. But the thing is that we are CONVICT of all this nonsense and thats the deadline. In our life we get this career making time only once. We do a course only once. If we do my all courses in correspondence and in the end fail to do C.A. THEN IF ICAI IS GOING TO RETURN THE VERY PRECIOUS TIME OF OUR LIFE OR WOULD WE JUST GO FOR A JOB STATING I AM A GUY WHO HAS DONE CORRESPONDENCE COURSES BUT IS ALSO BEEN A CA STUDENT AND HAVE COMPLETED MY TRAINING, DO YOU HAVE ANY JOB FOR ME. DOES IT WORTH ANYTHING. NOOOO.................. AND THEN, IF WE ARE TRYING TO SECURE OUR FUTURE THEN A BUNCH OF PEOPLE KNOWN AS EC OF ICAI ARE TRYING TO RESTRICT US. WTF??????? THEY DONT HAVE ANY F**KING RIGHT TO DECIDE ABOUT US THE THINGS LIKE THIS.
WHY SHOULD WE GO FOR CORRESPONDENCE WHEN WE CAN DO REGULAR.
Are we there slaves or what to follow even their unjustified rules?
I AGREE.............ITS ALL ABOUT OUR SO CALLED EX-PRESIDENT KI NATAKBAJI
Why don't you write to National human rights commission about this in a formal manner?
S agree wit all. Our education is our rights. Y shld there b permission frm the inst, to study wat v decide to study. Also, only one course permitted during articles is beyond Line of Control.
Ya, u are absolutely right , many of the students of ICAI has left out CA , just because of this restriction. One who drop one or two time in any year, gets very depressed for the better future and lastly opt to go through other regular courses but still after wasting so much time…... But one who go with the both (CA & other regular courses) can even be secure /satisfied even after dropped out one or two time in CA course. I hope u all are getting what I mean to say……..
i too agree with u all, stuk here like hell & no way to peep out.
Hey abhishek,
You are right about multiple qualification of some of the members, that they wont get if they ar doing only one course at at time..... But you would be knowing that you can only hold COP from one institute and ICAI will allow you to hold COP only if u adhere to ICAI regulations.
ITS TRUE THAT ICAI REGULATIONS ARE NOT AT ALL STUDENT FRIENDLY IN THIS MATTER.... thats cos they want all of us to be only a pure chartered accountant and a good chartered accountant by doing pucca articleship and all....(But they dont wanna correct answer papers like that)
DO SOME NATAK YOURSELF MEANWHILE
My advice to you is that you just file one form 112 with ICAI saying its private study and you have not got any documents from university... or they will delay your enrolment as member of ICAI.... or do something ugly like cancel period of your articles when you finally apply to be a member.. :O
Keep a covering letter, containing phrases like
"LOT OF DELAY, WHAT TO DO, I AM IN TROUBLE WITH UNIVERSITY, THEY ARE NOT GIVING ME MY REGISTRATION LETTER, I AM FOLLOWING IT WITH SO MUCH TENSION, BETWEEN MY ARTICLESHIP...."
Form 112 is placed carefully in a corner and no one looks it up beyond whether there is something to support what you have said, and ur principal's sign... I have sent 2 form 112 for my B Com by private study (Original Private study only hehe) and not a single reply or letter has come from them to me or my principal, i am only having photocopy of the form and registered AD...
Even college students' university certificate does not contain name of the college yaar.. Institute will never know...
OR YOU COULD TELL ICAI WHEN THEY ASK YOU BEFORE ENROLMENT, THAT YOU DID ONLY B.COM... "What is M.COM?"
But you be confident and write CA, you will get for sure.. all the best
Yes, thats really true,
asking for permission like these is a waste
Yes, thats really true,
asking for permission like these is a waste
Recent Threads
- Filling ITR after death
- Which ITR for STCG and professional income
- Does ca inter have negative marking
- Best CA Inter classes
- Sale of Private Limited Company
- Is PPF interest Taxabl;e in NEW tax regime??
- Income Tax filing returns
- Pan Card - Change of record
- IND AS 116 / IFRS 16: The standard that changed th
- Closure of first level step down subsidiary in Mau
Related Threads
CAclubindia
