LIVE GST Certification Course by CA Arun Chhajer begins 27th April. Register Now!!

What is better to do with ca

CA Piyush (CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT - PRACTICE) (361 Points)

26 February 2013

I AM DOING C.A. I WANT TO KNOW WHAT WILL BE BETTER FOR ME TO DO WITH C.A. ? IS IT C.W.A OR C.S. ? PLZ GIVE ME DETAIL IF THEIR IS ANY EXEMPTIONS.

CAN I DO C.W.A DURING ARTICLESHIP ?

Reply
Follow
Share

19 Replies

Neha sharma (-) (1257 Points)
Replied 26 February 2013

focus on knowledge rather than degree

1 Like

CA Bhargav Nathwani (CA in Practice) (8307 Points)
Replied 27 February 2013

In CS , Foundation Exams are exempted for CA-CPT Passed students so you can apply therow Direct entry in CS.

PALASH (Nothing) (2000 Points)
Replied 27 February 2013

DEAR PIYUSH,

AS FAR AS YOUR QUERY IS CONCERNED, I THINK, YOU ARE VERY IMMATURED PERSON, BECAUSE ,

AS YOU BELONGS TO OUR NATION'S MOST PRESTIGIOUS PROFESSION , ALWAYS REMEMBER THAT AT PRESENT

" YOU ARE IN AN ONGOING BATTLEFIED NOT IN A FOOTBALL / CRICKET PLAYGROUND

WHERE

YOU CAN CHOOSE EITHER TO PLAY CRICKET / FOOTBALL & NO ONE IN THE WORLD CAN WIN A BATTLE WITH THESE KIND OF MENTALITY " .

Both the Prosessions CS & CMA are great, and it genarally depends on your Capability whether you can maintain one more professional course ( CS/CWA ) along with CA or not AND During Articleship training , yes, you can go for an another Course by giving Details in Form 112 to ICAI.

At Last I want to say one thing that " IF YOU WANT TO BE A CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT , THEN IN THAT CASE , YOU HAVE TO BE DIFFERENT FROM OTHERS "

CHANGE YOUR MENTALITY & CHANGE YOUR THINKINGS........

Thanking you,

PALASH RAKSHIT....

palashraksh*t82 @ gmail.com

1 Like

CA Bharat Hirde (SAP Functional Consultant) (134 Points)
Replied 27 February 2013

So well said Neha...! Bro you should focus more on Knowledge. Clearing CA itself is a hurricane task. But if you feel you have the courage, knowledge and perseverance to do some other degree, then you should surely go for CS or CWA. Both are equally fine. I have seen people doing all three courses simultaneously and excel in life. You can do the courses simultaneously. But you have to consult with your CA whether he will allow you leave while giving CWA or CS exam. Most CA's don't. The course structure of the three programs is not so different, but it will require tremendous hardwork. So think wisely. All the best.

1 Like

CA Piyush (CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT - PRACTICE) (361 Points)
Replied 27 February 2013

THANK U ALL FOR YOUR WISE REPLIES BUT ACCORDING TO ME I CAN DO TWO COURSE AT A TIME . SPECIALLY I AM INTERESTING IN UTILISING MY ARTICLESHIP TIME PERIOD.

MY QUESTION IS STILL LITTLE UNANSWERED - THAT IF THERE IS ANY EXEMPTION IN CWA OR CS AFTER DOING IPCC OF CA ?

IF I WANT TO DO ANY AMONG CWA OR CS . THEN WHICH IS BETTER AND WHY ?

Fall Out Boy (Article Trainee) (83 Points)
Replied 27 February 2013

Originally posted by : PALASH RAKSHIT(CA,CWA)
	DEAR PIYUSH, AS FAR AS YOUR QUERY IS CONCERNED, I THINK, YOU ARE VERY IMMATURED PERSON, BECAUSE , AS YOU BELONGS TO OUR NATION'S MOST PRESTIGIOUS PROFESSION , ALWAYS REMEMBER THAT AT PRESENT " YOU ARE IN AN ONGOING BATTLEFIED NOT IN A FOOTBALL / CRICKET PLAYGROUND WHERE YOU CAN CHOOSE EITHER TO PLAY CRICKET / FOOTBALL & NO ONE IN THE WORLD CAN WIN A BATTLE WITH THESE KIND OF MENTALITY " . Both the Prosessions CS & CMA are great, and it genarally depends on your Capability whether you can maintain one more professional course ( CS/CWA ) along with CA or not AND During Articleship training , yes, you can go for an another Course by giving Details in Form 112 to ICAI. At Last I want to say one thing that " IF YOU WANT TO BE A CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT , THEN IN THAT CASE , YOU HAVE TO BE DIFFERENT FROM OTHERS " CHANGE YOUR MENTALITY & CHANGE YOUR THINKINGS........ Thanking you, PALASH RAKSHIT.... palashraksh*t82 @ gmail.com

Mr. Palash have you ever played a football or a cricket match, you are talking about the battlefield. Cricket & Football are the greatest battlefields ever you can't even imagine about the determination and dedication needed in those activities. You all commerce streamers have a disgusting mentality. CA is the hardest profession, No one messes with CA's, CA's are better than MBA's.....It SUCKS

   I think you are the most embarrased person in yourself. If you are commenting a boy who was just asking about the better course than why you have put CA and CWA in your own identity.

   Grow up man stop criticizing others, realize the fact and first of all brush up your grammar.

   I'm agreed with Neha but if you have the capability then do it what you wanna do. Stop asking these morons.

1 Like

Fall Out Boy (Article Trainee) (83 Points)
Replied 27 February 2013

Hello Piyush,

I would like to suggest you about how to utilizing the time-period during your internship.

Well, I would never suggest you to opt for CS or CWA because these courses are not complementary to CA, instead you should try for PGDM in finance via Distance Education from IMT-CDL Ghaziabad. IMT is one of the most prestigious MBA institutions in India.

Simultaneously, you should make good use of the internet in accumulating vast knowledge about the field of Finance. Get yourself registered on COURSERA website produced by the students of STANFORD UNIVERSITY. This platform provides you the opportunity to join the best courses of your taste that are been taught by the great professors of great UNIVERSITIES. absolutely FREEEEEEEEEE.

You can earn a Statement of Accomplishment or Distinction if you successfully pass the course as per the given guidelines.

You should also get yourself registered on DARE 2 WIN website and take part in various national competitions, it will add up to your CV.

Regards,

Ankit Kumar Rastogi

6 Like

PALASH (Nothing) (2000 Points)
Replied 27 February 2013

Mr.Ankit Rastogi,

First of All I would like say, that " I WILL STAND OF MY COMMITMENT " and If you

defend Mr Piyush , then in that case Both of you are in the Same category, Because Mr PIYUSH 's

Query IS

" WHAT WILL BE BETTER FOR ME TO DO WITH CHARTERED PROFESSION ?? "

WHAT IS THESE ?????? Why don't you understand that , THE QUERY, HE TOLD , IS

COMPLETELTY BASELESS ? THE QUESTION IS BASELESS? Because his future depends on his

own capability , not for other's choice, It means , If he has the capability , then he must go for CMA/

CS, OTHERWISE NOT. Why don't you understand that Mr Piyush belongs to Chartered Profession , and

I can't expect these kind of BASELESS QUERY FROM HIM ...

SO, THE ONLY THING WHICH I WANT THAT IS " A CHANGE (OF HIS MENTALITY) , NOT REVENGE ".

THANKING YOU,

PALASH RAKSHIT.

1 Like

CA Piyush (CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT - PRACTICE) (361 Points)
Replied 27 February 2013

Mr. PALASH RAKSHIT I APPRICIATE YOUR REPLY BUT YOUR IS TOO ROUGH. IF SOMEONE IS ASKING YOU ANYTHING THEN WITHOUT KNOWING IN DETAIL YOU SHOULD NOT SHOW THAT U R GENIOUS AND ANOTHER PERSON IS STUPID.

I SAID THAT I M DOING C.A. IF I DO SOMETHING IN ADDITION (IF I M CAPABLE OF IT) THEN I DON'T THINK THAT THERE IS ANY NON-SENSE. I JUST ASKED WHAT SHOULD I DO IN ADDITION WHICH WILL BOOST MY CAREER AS WELL AS KNOWLEDGE. I THINK THAT I SHALL TELL U (NOT DUE TO OVER CONFIDENCE ) THAT I PASSED 10th WITH 9.6 CGPA AND TOP THE B.H.E.L SCHOOLS IN 12th PASSED FOUNDATION OF ICWA AND CPT (WITH DISTINCTION) IN FIRST ATTEMPT.

Mr. ANKIT THANKS FOR KIND REPLY PROVIDING ME INFO. AS U TELL I COME TO KNOW THAT DARE TO WIN IS GAMING SITE. PLEASE TELL ME IF THERE ANY SITE WHERE I CAN GIVE ONLINE TESTS FOR PRACTICE OF IPCC

THANK U ALL

S.GANESAN (AUDIT MANAGER) (110 Points)
Replied 27 February 2013

Do CA with CS.

Because it is most wanted in the Industry, if you are in India.

Or Otherwise (if u want to work in Abroad) u can do whatever course you want to do.

1 Like

Fall Out Boy (Article Trainee) (83 Points)
Replied 27 February 2013

Hello Piyush,

If u wanna pepare for IPCC then don't rely on online tests. IPCC needs a lot of labour practically and theoretically. You should spend your time while doing the practial problems and grasping the concept.

I think you are doing IPCC and ICWA Inter so, first of all you must prepare a fundamental base of this profession. If you are also persuing Graduation, I think you must be and probably in first or second year then I would like to recommend you to prepare for R.B.I's Young Scholars Scheme if ,you get selected then you will get an opportunity to work within the RBI on projects/assignments subject to a minimum of 2 months and a maximum of three calender months. You will receive a monthly stipend of Rs. 7500 / - . You will also be provided accomodation if needed. Try googeling about RBI internship this will definately boost your career. I did the same during my first year of graduation.

One thing I would also like to suggest you, never follow the trend be yourself what you are, your starting salary package will speak out itself.

Young Scholars Award Scheme

1 Like

PALASH (Nothing) (2000 Points)
Replied 27 February 2013

Mr Ankit Rastogi,

Sorry, but I have to say that Each & Every time you are Wrong & " Again You are Wrong " , because already , I have done both CA & ICWA ( INTERMEDIATE ) earlier With More than 56% marks.........Do you Understand .... AND

I would like to give a VITAL advice that " Concentrate on Your Study as well as ON your articleship Training, rather than focus on any other Irrelevant Matters .

Thanking You,

PALASH RAKSHIT.

1 Like

Ajay Balasubramanian (ACA) (114 Points)
Replied 28 February 2013

"I think you are the most embarrased person in yourself. If you are commenting a boy who was just asking about the better course than why you have put CA and CWA in your own identity. Grow up man stop criticizing others, realize the fact and first of all brush up your grammar."

hahaha good observation ankit rastogi ... even i feel ankit is right and the least palash can do is advice the young talented boy who has every right to dream and move forward to acheive it...

My recommendation is go for CS dude...CA and CS has a very good profile wen u step into the world ...

1 Like

Ganesh - ACA, LCS (-) (183 Points)
Replied 01 March 2013

Piyush... CA + CS is very good... plus thr hv been some sweeping changes in CWA course... (i happd to know only 2 days back)...

1 in cwa articleship has been increased to 3 yrs now...

2 in cwa articleship has been made compulsory now.. the new rule says that u hv to complete about 6 mths of articleship to be eligible to appear in CWA Final exam... (it means that the concept of Grad.CWA is gone now)

3 so CS is the only course left now which can be taken up & done side-by-side of CA... (in CS articleship is optional... & if u pass cs final but dont go for articleship, u can still become a Licentiate CS - like me)

syllabus of both the courses has changed a lot in jan 2013... so to sum up u can go for CS, LLB or any diploma in finance,etc. (i think CS LLB is d best)

atb.. do well :)

1 Like