WHAT A MANIPULATION IN CA FINAL RESULT OF EXAM NOV,2015 !!!!!!!

3898 views 16 replies

GROUP-1

REGION

NO. OF STUDENTS PASSED

PASSED %

CENTRAL

2024

28%

EASTERN

549

7%

NORTH

1402

19%

OVERSEAS

43

1%

SOUTH

1180

16%

WEST

2126

29%

Grand Total

7324

100%

GROUP-2

REGION

NO. OF STUDENTS PASSED

PASSED %

CENTRAL

1685

25%

EASTERN

454

7%

NORTH

1371

21%

OVERSEAS

50

1%

SOUTH

966

15%

WEST

2118

32%

Grand Total

6644

100%

 

BOTH GROUP

REGION

NO. OF STUDENTS PASSED

PASSED %

CENTRAL

555

22.75%

EASTERN

214

8.77%

NORTH

343

14.06%

OVERSEAS

7

0.29%

SOUTH

397

16.27%

WEST

924

37.87%

Grand Total

2440

100%

PASSED GROUP

Result - Region wise Notifications (ICAI Website)

ICAI Press Release (ICAI Website)

Difference

No. of Students Passed

No. of Students Passed

Gr-1

7324

9084

1760

Gr-11

6644

9764

3120

Both Group

2440

2440

0

Grand Total

16408

21288

4880

 

  • Can anyone explain about the illogical % of result in particular Eastern Region only

  • Can anyone explain about the difference on Nos.of passed Students between ICAI Press release and Region/Centre wise result uploaded by ICAI in their Website

Disclaimer: The Analysis based on information taken from ICAI website

You can also checked the same from ICAI website as no liability will be taken by the author for any mistakes.

https://resource.cdn.icai.org/40775prc30584b.pdf

https://www.icai.org/new_post.H T M L?post_id=12300&c_id=219

Replies (16)

Does anyone has access to information on how many people appeared v/s passed.

 

This analysis is just regional distribution, may be East region had less population in terms of appearance.

Regional performance in terms of passout against appearance will give more clear picture (i.e. to identify which region/centre you should write from).

 

are you belong from eastern region 

Definitely illogical result of icai But what you posted do not give all views... Where can we get regions wise or centre wise results ...of students individually

Dear Ankita,

Pls follow the link for Regionwise & Centre wise Students result

https://www.icai.org/new_post.H T M L?post_id=12300&c_id=219

 

Dear Mr. sandeep kumawat 

I think you know that ICAI do not disclose regionwise appeared nos.of Students and results as they want to hide their manipulation on result. 

Further,for your information that each & every time a large numbers of Students appeared in IPCC & Final exam as West Bengal, Odisha,North East States, Andaman & Nicobar.

You can check from your any eastern region friends

 

Requesting to all CA students, pls put your views in this crucial matter

Just few hours before IPCC result has been declared for exam Nov,2015. It is very shocking that again result is unexpected inrespect of Failed Students in Eastern Region.

Any one have answer for unjustified result in Eastern Region only ??????????

It is quite shocking that business persons like Biswanath Jana is commenting on ICAI results. { does anybody know who he is- pl send details]

The regional imbalances in makrs is not possible due to all India mix of papers whether in english or Hindi as understood.

Maybe the need to consider reasons:

1. Not preparing a schedule for studies

2. Not revising early + enough

3. Selective studies

4. ......pl see vidoe on how to excel in examination on utube.

Anybody having a doubt may apply for xerox copy and find out why exactly one is not doing well.

Respected Mr. Madhukar N Hiregange.

It is also very shocking sir !!! you are a Charterd Accountant but you dont know the ICAI Regulation 39.

Can u pls explain that if I am consider of all above points as u said and ICAI apply their regulation 39 i.e.

"The Council may, in its discretion, revise the marks obtained by all candidates or a section of candidates in any particular paper or papers or in the aggregate in such manner as may be considered necessary, for maintaining the standards of pass percentage provided in these Regulations. " 

then I am able to Pass CA ???????

Further,  If u believe that regional disparity is not possible then what is the meaning for  

"a section of candidates", "maintaining the standards of pass percentage" under regulation 39. said by ICAI ??? 

For your reference related to Manipulation in Paper pls see the attached file

Yes I agree......Does our Country which have population of 121 Crores can have this much % of CA. And what is the probability of those who failed will pass in future..

I completely agree with Madhukar. Without proper information making allegations is not right !

Dear Mr. CA H R Shenoy,

I think you are not properly read the Post where all information received from ICAI Portal. Further, you have any explanation about ICAI Regulation 39 ?????

Dear madhukar sir

Im an IPCC student. I saw the xerox/certified copy of my cafm answer book. They have awarded 0 and 2 marks for two practical questions for which I deserve to get more marks. I dont understand why they have given me such low marks. And I'll not get an answer because of regulation 39 (2) and 39 (4). I dont want to blame the institute or the examiner. Just hard luck for me and preparing for May 2016. Since you quoted about xerox/certified copy im sending this. No offences.


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register