Congrats Sir, But do  u think that this list is right... if yes... can i  know the basis of selection ??

What is right? i didnt get your point?

Thanks is counted as and when the opposite person thanks on other persons reply either in forum or in expert so its automatcically generated and even the admin does not interfere in it as its counted by the system on its own.........

so where is the problme dear????????

i too thought the same... but u can check on my id sir...

I joined CA Club on 1st nov. and til now its 214 thanks... and for this month of dec i got 15

so total thanks for nov 199

Then why my name is not here

kher anyways leave it... thanks is not a matter of concern for me... bus aise hi i really dont know this that this is also done by admin... i thought its systematically done ....

All the best sir.. keep helping us...!!!

ok, in this case our respected admin only can ans this as they have all the technical knowledge for the same.

so my request is you send a pm with the details to them and ask them to rectify the list if your claim is correct in thier view.

na yaar... admin ji meri sunte hi nahi kabhi.. as i had also asked him to approve my application as expert.. because was an expert here in past and also on 41th position in overall list... but ab admin ji h... chalo jaisi unki marji.. after all its his kingdom

No , never leave it, even though thanks does not matter but still what is wrong is wrong and must be rectified if its mistake.

Yes we dont work here for thanks but it feels nice when somebody thanks you for your efforts to help them.

Hey Admin, Can i know according to what rules u declares top five thanks holder for the month. because i had got near about 190-200 thanks in month of nov and m not in any position... why so...

This msg was sent on 3rd december 2014..

Now what else i can do... nothing na....

Fully agreed with you that we dont work her for thanks... seriously i have answers of 50 % querries asked in expert section but unable to answer... isliye i didnt came here regularly these days

Congrats and thanks to all the five of you :)

We all are very grateful for your contribution!