Tax at special rate on  income of new manufacturing domestic companies u/s 115BAB. 

Section 115BAB of the Income Tax Act offers a special tax rate for new manufacturing domestic companies, subject to certain conditions. Here's an overview of the implications if a company doesn't fully meet the requirements, and the consequences of applying for the special rate under these circumstances:

### **1. Understanding Section 115BAB**

**Eligibility Criteria for Section 115BAB:**
1. **Incorporation:** The company must be incorporated on or after October 1, 2019, and before October 1, 2023.
2. **Manufacturing Activity:** The company must be engaged in the manufacturing or production of goods.
3. **Investment in New Plant and Machinery:** At least 75% of the total investment in plant and machinery should be in new assets. Up to 20% of the plant and machinery can be used or second-hand.

### **2. Consequences of Non-Compliance with Machinery Requirement**

**Scenario:** The company has purchased 35% second-hand machinery, exceeding the permissible limit of 20%.

**Consequences of Filing Form 10-ID Despite Non-Compliance:**
- **Disallowance of Tax Benefit:** If the company files Form 10-ID claiming the special tax rate under Section 115BAB but fails to meet the machinery requirement, the benefit under Section 115BAB will be disallowed. This means the company will be taxed at the regular corporate tax rates.
- **Penalties or Notices:** The tax authorities may issue a notice for non-compliance if it’s discovered during scrutiny or audit that the machinery requirement has not been met. This could lead to additional assessments or penalties.

### **3. Verification of Machinery Condition**

**How the Department Verifies Compliance:**
- **Inspection and Documentation:** The tax authorities may verify the nature of the plant and machinery through inspection or examination of documents such as purchase invoices, installation certificates, and other relevant records.
- **Supporting Documents:** The company should maintain proper documentation proving the purchase and installation of new machinery, and any relevant correspondence related to the machinery procurement.

### **4. Pros and Cons of Opting for Section 115BAB**

**Pros:**
- **Reduced Tax Rate:** Section 115BAB offers a lower tax rate of 15% (plus applicable surcharge and cess) on the income of qualifying companies, compared to the standard corporate tax rates.
- **Tax Incentive:** It provides an attractive tax incentive to encourage new manufacturing investments.

**Cons:**
- **Strict Compliance Requirements:** The conditions to qualify for Section 115BAB are strict, including the requirement for new machinery and limited use of second-hand machinery.
- **Potential for Disqualification:** If the conditions are not fully met, the tax benefits under Section 115BAB will be forfeited, and the company will be taxed at higher rates. Additionally, there could be implications for non-compliance and potential penalties.

### **Recommendations:**

1. **Consult a Tax Professional:** Before filing Form 10-ID, consult a tax advisor to ensure all conditions are met and to understand the implications of non-compliance.
2. **Consider Alternatives:** If the machinery requirement cannot be met, consider opting for the regular tax regime or other available tax benefits that align with the company’s circumstances.
3. **Maintain Proper Records:** Ensure all documentation related to machinery purchases and their condition is accurate and up-to-date, to facilitate verification and compliance.

By addressing these points, the company can make an informed decision about applying for the special rate under Section 115BAB and ensure compliance with the applicable tax regulations.