See my certified copy of ca final cost (may-12)

CA Ashish Pathak (Employed at Cipla Ltd.) (2779 Points)

24 November 2012  

Hello Friends and Respected Seniors,

I applied for the certified copy of Advanced Management Accounting (Paper-5) of CA Final May-2012 attempt. Though I cleared my 2nd group but I am very unsatisfied with my marks in this paper. I got mere 40 when I expected atleast 55 in it.

On receiving my certified copy, I am shocked to see that in one of the question (i.e Q-3(a))  which carried 8 marks I have been awarded though my answer is same as that solved by Padhuka Publications. Though my answer is different from the suggested answers published by ICAI but I am sure my solution is also one of the alternative answer to the said question and I deserve 8 out of 8 for this question. I am attaching the scanned copy of the certified copy here.

It's my earnest request to experts and teachers to verify my answer and let me know if I am wrong. 

Thanking You