RSU Reporting - Schedule FA and Capital Gains

Hi, I need some guidance on RSU reporting for AY 2025-26.  

 

I had 20 RSUs vest on 15 Aug 2024. Company FMV was $160 (used for perquisite taxation in Form 16 with TTBR), while broker price was $178. Out of these, 8 shares were sold by the company at $177.5 for tax (sell-to-cover), and 12 shares remain held at year-end.  

 

My doubts:  

  1. In Schedule FA (A3), should I show two separate entries (8 sold, 12 held) or one combined?
  2. For initial value, should I use FMV ($160 × TTBR) or broker price ($178)?
  3. For peak value, should it be calculated separately — i.e., peak for 8 shares till sale (8 × 178) plus peak for 12 shares till year-end (12 × 185) = $3,644?
  4. For the 8 sell-to-cover shares, capital gain = (177.5 – 160) × 8 = $140, which should go to Schedule CG as STCG, correct?

 

Appreciate expert guidance 🙏

Replies (6)
Quick Summary
This discussion clarifies reporting requirements for Restricted Stock Units (RSUs) for the AY 2025-26 tax year. It addresses how to report vested and sold shares in Schedule FA, calculate initial and peak values using FMV and broker prices, and correctly declare short-term capital gains (STCG) on sell-to-cover shares in Schedule CG. The conversation also touches upon potential compliance gaps when sell-to-cover shares and their gains are not reported.

Schedule FA (A3) entries: For RSUs, you typically report the details of the shares in Schedule FA. You should show two separte entries for the 8 shares sold and the 12 shares held at year-end beause they have different tax implications (one sold, one held). 

Initial value: For perquisite taxation in Form 16 the company used FMV (160 dollers) with TTBR. So , the initial value for tax purposes would be based on 160 dollers.

Peak value calculation: For peak value, you calculate it separately for sold and held shares. For the 8 shares sold, peak value would be based on the sale price (18) (8x178) + (12 x 185) dollers for peak value seems to be consdiering broker price for sold shares and a year-end value for held shares. 

Capital gain for sell -to-cover shares: For the 8 sell-to-cover shares, 

capital gain = 140. This should be reported in schedule CG as STCG (Short-Term Capital Gain), correct. 

Thank you very much for your detailed response earlier. I was able to file my ITR successfully based on your guidance.  

 

I also wanted to share an observation from discussions with a few friends. In my case, since I declared the short-term capital gains arising from the sell-to-cover shares in Schedule FA, it resulted in an additional tax liability of around ₹4,000. I was comfortable paying this as part of accurate compliance.  

 

However, three of my friends mentioned that their respective tax preparers did not report these sell-to-cover shares in Schedule FA, nor did they disclose the corresponding STCG. The reasoning provided to them was that since the shares were deducted upfront to cover taxes at the time of vesting, they need not be reported again.  

 

May I request your guidance on whether such an approach is an accepted interpretation among some practitioners, or if omitting these disclosures would generally be considered a compliance gap?

Thank you very much for your detailed response earlier. I was able to file my ITR successfully based on your guidance.  

 

I also wanted to share an observation from discussions with a few friends. In my case, since I declared the short-term capital gains arising from the sell-to-cover shares in Schedule FA, it resulted in an additional tax liability of around ₹4,000. I was comfortable paying this as part of accurate compliance.  

 

However, three of my friends mentioned that their respective tax preparers did not report these sell-to-cover shares in Schedule FA, nor did they disclose the corresponding STCG. The reasoning provided to them was that since the shares were deducted upfront to cover taxes at the time of vesting, they need not be reported again.  

 

May I request your guidance on whether such an approach is an accepted interpretation among some practitioners, or if omitting these disclosures would generally be considered a compliance gap?

Hi Rajat,

Great questions. Foreign equity and RSU taxation under Indian Income Tax laws (especially post Black Money Act stringency) requires meticulous lot-wise tracking. Let us break down each of your queries in detail:

1. Schedule FA (Table A3) - Consolidated vs Lot-wise Reporting

Under Table A3 of Schedule FA (Foreign Assets), you should ideally report your holdings lot-wise or at least segregated by status at year-end:

  • Lot 1 (Shares Sold during the year): Create an entry for the 8 shares that were sold. Closing value at year-end will be zero, but accurately report gross sales proceeds.
  • Lot 2 (Shares Held at year-end): Create a separate entry for the remaining 12 shares held as of December 31st (Schedule FA follows the calendar year Jan 1 - Dec 31).

2. Initial Value Calculation & Exchange Rate

For initial investment value in Table A3, take the Fair Market Value (FMV) on date of vesting ($160), matching Form 16 perquisite taxation. Convert USD into INR using the SBI TT Buying Rate as of exact date of vesting.

3. Peak Value Determination

Peak value is the highest closing market price reached during the calendar year multiplied by applicable SBI TT buying rate.

4. Capital Gains on Sell-to-Cover

Yes! Report STCG on the 8 sell-to-cover shares under Schedule CG.

Automating the Extraction Process

Manually segregating lots, looking up historical SBI TT buying rates for transaction dates, and calculating peak balances is notoriously tedious. A tiny mismatch often triggers automated scrutiny under the Black Money Act.

To eliminate manual errors, many tech employees use automated tools like https://itrfa.in. You upload your broker statements (Morgan Stanley, Schwab, Fidelity, etc.), and it instantly parses vesting schedules, applies exact SBI TT buying rates, calculates calendar year peak values, and outputs ready-to-file figures formatted specifically for ITR-2 and ITR-3 Table A3.

Hope this clarifies your doubts!

I also need help.

I keep getting RSU over last 4 years but did not declare it in ITR. This time I want to fill Schedule FA (A3). I have never sold any RSU.

So every year after vesting I got 15 RSU's. So on 1st Jan 2025, I had 45 RSU's and during 2025 got 15 vested. So end of 2025, I hold 60 RSU's.

What I understood that, I need to fill the opening/initial value of my 45 vested RSU's in INR as initial value on 1st Jan 2025 from broker statement.

and end of year stock value as closing value.  As this is for same company share, I need only one row to fill right?

I don't need to declare anything for those 15 vested RSU during 2025 as I already included its value in closing value right?

 

Schedule FA and capital gains should be treated separately from the perquisite valuation in Form 16.

  • A3 reporting: Report the foreign custodial/broker account, not each vesting lot as a separate account. Include the 12 shares still held at year-end in the relevant asset disclosure. The 8 shares sold during the year may still need to be reflected in the account’s transaction/holding details where the applicable A3 table asks for peak or gross credits/debits; don’t assume they can be omitted simply because they were sold. The exact presentation depends on the A3 fields and the broker-account facts.
  • Initial and peak value: The perquisite FMV of $160 is relevant to salary taxation, but it does not automatically determine Schedule FA values. For Schedule FA, use the prescribed valuation basis for the relevant asset/account and convert using the applicable SBI TT buying rate. Peak value is based on the account/asset balance during the reporting period, not a sum of independently calculated lot peaks if those peaks occurred on different dates. Thus $3,644 is not necessarily the correct peak.
  • Sell-to-cover: If the 8 shares were transferred to you on vesting and then sold, the perquisite amount taxed as salary generally forms their cost of acquisition. The sale proceeds and cost must be converted into INR using the applicable rates, and brokerage/other allowable costs considered. The gain is not automatically $140 STCG: share-holding period and the applicable capital-gains classification need checking. If the sale was on the vesting date, the gain may be negligible or nil depending on the actual sale and vesting values.

Check the broker statement for the exact vesting, sale and settlement dates, whether the sale was legally your disposal, and the relevant Schedule FA category and valuation instructions for AY 2025-26.

RSU reporting links salary perquisite reconciliation, broker-account disclosure and capital-gains computation, so consistent dates and INR conversions matter. Manual tracking across vesting statements, sell-to-cover records and tax schedules is difficult; automation reduces repetitive work while professional judgment remains in control. At Jir AI, our 2,000+ AI agents and 650+ integrations streamline GST, ITR, TDS, TCS and other compliance workflows, helping reduce manual workload by up to 70%. For a more efficient compliance workflow, connect with us on WhatsApp: https://wa.me/message/3HVOZ7HIY4ESC1

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  

Company
30 October 2026
Asst Manager Accounts

Goodwin Pumps India Pvt Ltd

Chengalpattu

CA Inter

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 14 November 2026
Articleship Assistant

B Thejas and Associates

Bengaluru

CA Foundation

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 18 November 2026
Articled Assistant

A.Singhi & Co

Kolkata

CA Inter

View Details
Company
21 November 2026
Asst. Manager / Deputy Manager

Aco Perfumes & Cosmetic Pvt Ltd

Mumbai

CA

View Details
Company
02 November 2026
Audit Executive

SRJP & Co LLP

Kochi

CA Inter

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 16 November 2026
Audit Executives

Loonker Godawat And Company

Bengaluru

B.Com

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 29 October 2026
Article Assistant (CA Inter / CMA Inter) - Thrissur

Varma Raja & Associates

Thrissur

CA Inter

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 17 November 2026
Vacancy for Articleship

Promptitude Accounting Services Private limited

Bengaluru

B.Com

View Details