I had purchased some goods from a registered dealer from delhi. He sent the goods to me (kolkata) through an unregistered GTA. If i have to pay GST under RCM, will it be treated as Inter State or Intra State?
Menu
Rcm on gta
Replies (10)
Since you are a registered person, Place of supply is your registered place of business that is West Bengal and Location of Supplier of service is Dehli, Hence it is an Inter State Supply. (Refer section 12(8) of IGST Act)
As per Section 12(8) Transportation of Goods : If recipient is registered than location of such person, otherwise location at which such goods are handed over for their transportation
Hence in your case the POS will be Kolkata & CGST /SGST will Applicable
Hence in your case the POS will be Kolkata & CGST /SGST will Applicable
Mr.Pankaj POS is Kolkata but Location of supplier is not, if it has to be intra state supply POS and location of supplier must be same. Since that is not the case here it is an Inter State Supply.
if you don't agree with my view, further argument is appreciated.
if you don't agree with my view, further argument is appreciated.
Inter State supply by an unregistered person is restricted in GST. How will this be applicable?
A person making inter State has to get registered, if he has not registered that is his head ache, but since you receiving GTA service from unregistered person you have pay under RCM.
MR. AKARSH PRINCE "THAT IS NOT HIS HEAD ACHE" BY SAYING THIS WE CANNOT CHANGE THE LAW.
IAM NOT SAYING THAT CGST/SGST WILL APPLICABLE, ITS IN LAW ..... SO BETTER PLZ GO THROUGH SECTION 12(8) IGST ACT .
MR. LALIT
AS PER 5/2017 CT ,DT.19/6/2017
GTA ARE NOT REQUIRED TO OBTAIN REGISTRATION UNLESS HIS SERVICES ARE UNDER RCM
Location of supplier is Delhi, POS is Kolkata and Location of recipient is Kolkata... IGST should be applicable as per Section 7(3) of IGST Act, isn't it? Just like if the GTA was registered.
Mr. Lalit
Section 7 of IGST deals in determination of Nature of Supply. .and Not deals in POS .
There is specifically mention the POS in case of transportation of Goods in Section 12(8) of IGST Act
Note .: GTA .is Unregistered
Kindly refer the Sections carefully
Mr.Pankaj why have you held up with only place of supply, to determine whether a supply is inter State or intra state we have to refer provisions of section 7(3) along with section 12. Please read it again.
Recent Threads
- Regarding berthing of vesse
- Schedule FA reporting - peak value and cash MMF
- Partnership firm with foreign national person
- Audit required
- Deemed Withdrawal of ASMT-13 Orders & Adjustme
- Need advise with HRA claim
- Schedule AL limit for FY 2024-25
- Can a person use ITR 1 when she has CG of Rs.250/
- Choice of ITR Form
- DTAA with US - Interest & Dividend
Related Threads
CAclubindia
