Query on Buy Back of shares

Dear Experts

Can the buy back price of an equity share in an unlisted company be more than or less than fair value of the share ? 

Or it has to be at exactly the fair value.

Regards,

Replies (3)
Quick Summary
An unlisted company has the flexibility to buy back its equity shares at a price that is either higher or lower than the determined fair value. While the Companies Act, 2013, does not mandate buybacks to be at exact fair value, the price must be commercially justifiable and supported by a valuation report. The Income-tax Act also applies buyback tax based on the buyback price versus the issue price, irrespective of the fair value, though a valuation report is crucial to defend the pricing and avoid potential tax issues for shareholders.

YES — an unlisted company can buy back shares at a price higher or lower than the fair value.
There is no requirement under the Companies Act that buy-back must be done at exactly fair value.

However:

  • The buyback price must be justifiable,

  • Supported by a valuation report, and

  • Must not be prejudicial to shareholders or creditors.


Applicable Law / Notification / Circular

Company Law

  • Section 68, Companies Act, 2013 – Buy-back of securities

  • Rule 17, Companies (Share Capital and Debentures) Rules, 2014

Income-tax

  • Section 115QA, Income-tax Act, 1961 – Buy-back tax on unlisted shares

  • Section 56(2)(x) read with Rule 11UA – Taxation of receipt of shares for inadequate/excess consideration (relevance for shareholders)


Short Practical Answer

πŸ‘‰ Yes, the buy-back price can be more than or less than the fair value.
There is no legal requirement under the Companies Act or Income-tax Act that buy-back must be at exactly fair value.

However:

  • Commercial justification and

  • Tax consequences
    must be carefully evaluated.


Detailed Explanation

1️⃣ Under the Companies Act, 2013

  • Section 68 does not prescribe fair value pricing for buy-back.

  • Buy-back price is a commercial decision of the company, subject to:

    • Articles of Association permitting buy-back

    • Shareholder approval (special resolution if >10%)

    • Solvency declaration

    • Buy-back limits (25% of paid-up capital + free reserves)

πŸ“Œ Result:
βœ… Buy-back price can be higher or lower than FV from a company law perspective.


2️⃣ Under Income-tax Act – Company Level Tax

πŸ”Ή Section 115QA (Unlisted Companies)

  • Company pays buy-back tax @ 20% + surcharge + cess

  • Tax base =
    Buy-back price – Issue price of shares

πŸ“Œ Important:

  • Fair value is irrelevant for computing buy-back tax.

  • Higher buy-back price ⇒ higher 115QA tax for the company.

  • Shareholder’s receipt is exempt u/s 10(34A).

βœ” Even if buy-back price > FV or < FV, 115QA applies.


3️⃣ Income-tax Impact on Shareholder (Section 56(2)(x))

This is where fair value becomes practically relevant.

⚠ If Buy-back Price is LESS than Fair Value

  • Shareholder is transferring shares to the company for inadequate consideration.

  • However, 56(2)(x) does NOT tax the seller.

  • It taxes the recipient — here, the company.

But:

  • Since the company is already taxed u/s 115QA, courts and practice generally treat 56(2)(x) as not applicable in buy-back scenarios.

πŸ‘‰ Still, valuation report is strongly recommended to defend pricing.


⚠ If Buy-back Price is MORE than Fair Value

  • No additional tax on shareholder (receipt is exempt).

  • No 56(2)(x) exposure.

  • Only consequence is higher buy-back tax u/s 115QA.


Practical Summary Table

Buy-back Price vs FV Legally Allowed? Tax Risk
Exactly at FV βœ… Yes Minimal
More than FV βœ… Yes Higher 115QA tax
Less than FV βœ… Yes Valuation justification needed

Caveats & When Human Review Is Needed

  • If buy-back is selective, or between related parties

  • If pricing appears to be profit distribution / tax avoidance

  • If company has recent share issues at different valuations

  • During assessment or scrutiny proceedings


Action Plan

  1. Obtain a Rule 11UA / merchant banker valuation report (strongly advisable).

  2. Document commercial rationale for pricing.

  3. Compute 115QA tax impact before finalizing price.

  4. Ensure Companies Act compliances (Section 68 + Rules).

A buyback price need not be exactly equal to the share’s fair value. Under the Companies Act, 2013, the price is generally set through the applicable approval process and the company’s offer; the Act does not prescribe that it must match fair value. For an unlisted company, however, valuation and tax rules may affect the transaction, so the price should be assessed against the relevant provisions and the company’s articles and approvals.

For tax purposes, a price above or below fair value can have consequences depending on the parties and circumstances; the applicable valuation rule may use a prescribed method rather than a general notion of fair value. The company’s status, shareholder type, transaction route and tax year are relevant to that analysis.

A buyback workflow should therefore check corporate approvals, pricing support and tax treatment together. Manual review across these records is difficult, while automation can reduce repetitive work and leave professional judgment in control. At Jir AI, our 2,000+ AI agents and 650+ integrations streamline GST, ITR, TDS, TCS and other compliance workflows, helping reduce manual workload by up to 70%. WhatsApp us to explore a workflow suited to your practice: https://wa.me/message/3HVOZ7HIY4ESC1

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  

Company
28 October 2026
Assistant Director/ Associate Director-Finance & Accounting

Krea University

Chennai

CA

View Details
Company
12 November 2026
Tax Product Specialist

BharatX.ai

Gurgaon

B.Com

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 16 November 2026
Audit Executives

Loonker Godawat And Company

Bengaluru

B.Com

View Details
Company
Featured ARTICLESHIP 31 October 2026
CA Articleship

apricus india

Navi Mumbai

CA Inter

View Details
Company
19 October 2026
Accountant

Jari Saree Center

New Delhi

Others

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 22 October 2026
Articleship intern

Srinath Manikanta

Hyderabad

CA Inter

View Details
Company
13 November 2026
Chartered Accountant - Fresher

Neeraj Bhagat & Co

New Delhi

CA

View Details
Company
Featured 17 November 2026
Chartered Accountant

M/s. A V C & Co.

New Delhi

CA

View Details