LIVE GST Certification Course by CA Arun Chhajer begins 27th April. Register Now!!

Query

(Guest)

What will the result in this case assume- Mr. X got following marks in nov 11 attemppt Accounts-50 ,audit -78(exempted in may11), law-52, cafm-40, tax-40, itsm-40... total of group 1 is 102 n group 2 is 120..ques is will he be considered as pass or not?

Reply
Follow
Share

16 Replies

kishore (STUDENT(IPCC)) (867 Points)
Replied 20 March 2012

Accounts-50 ,audit -78(exempted in may11), law-52, cafm-40, tax-40, itsm-40... total of group 1 is 102 n group 2 is

1st grp total: 180

2nd grp: 120

tot 300

result pASS

CS RAJESH C.CHOUDHARY (ASSISTANT MANAGER) (14607 Points)
Replied 20 March 2012

your query is not clear ...

Where is the marks of Advance acounting ???

And which course you are talking about ???

IPCC or PCC???? Or Final????

Do mention every data properly...

CA Suraj Lakhotia (IndigoLearn) (4898 Points)
Replied 20 March 2012

Assuming the marks are that of PCC -

Group I (Aggregate) - 180

Group II (Aggregate) - 120

Total - 300

Pass in both groups.

1 Like

(Guest)

@ rajesh my query is very much clear...u have not use ur common sense n @ suraj sir thanks for reply.

(Guest)

Thanks kishore for reply.

Gaurav (ca student) (748 Points)
Replied 20 March 2012

Originally posted by : CA Suraj Lakhotia
	Assuming the marks are that of PCC - Group I (Aggregate) - 180 Group II (Aggregate) - 120 Total - 300 Pass in both groups.

agreed......

Chandan Kumar (Strategy Analyst) (384 Points)
Replied 20 March 2012

A candidate who has appeared in all the papers of a group and secured 60% or more marks in one or more papers and has failed in one or more papers of the group shall be given the benefit of carrying the same marks in the paper or papers in which he obtained 60% or more marks to the subsequent examination.

This method works on the premise that the paper in which you are exempted has been alloted the same marks in the subsequent examinations also. Therefore it amounts to having appeared in all the papers including the exempted one. Therefore the rule of 40% minimum in each paper and 50% aggregate should be applied accordingly to all the papers by including the marks obtained in the exempted paper in the earlier examination as the marks obtained in the current examination.

Ans to ur query - Pass

CS RAJESH C.CHOUDHARY (ASSISTANT MANAGER) (14607 Points)
Replied 20 March 2012

Originally posted by : Celiena goel
	@ rajesh my query is very much clear...u have not use ur common sense n @ suraj sir thanks for reply.	ok

Roshan A (Chartered Accountant) (458 Points)
Replied 20 March 2012

The aggregate of grp I should be 200 & grp II should be 150,which is not the case above so i think its Fail

mouli ganguly (student) (21 Points)
Replied 20 March 2012

Urgent Opening: with IL&FS Transportation

Location : Mumbai

Job Descriptttion

Position

Position Report To

Department

: Assistant Manager

: Senior Manager

: Corporate Finance and Accounts

Brief Descriptttion:

1. Education Qualification: CA (completed)

2. Experience: More than 3 to 7 yrs of experience (post qualification and article-ship)

3. Job Responsibility: To take charge of ITNL (corporate) for accounting, compliance

(statutory/tax/internal) and MIS

4. Knowledge and Specific Skills (Mandatory Skills Required/Must have):

o Preparation of Accounts as per applicable GAP

o Ensuring statutory compliance like TDS, service tax etc

o Preparation of monthly MIS / Other information from Senior Manager

o Coordination and completion of Statutory/tax/internal audit within timelines

o Approval/Posting of Journals in ERP

o Review of GL accounts on regular basis

5. Position & Salary:

Will depend on the candidate technical knowledge and ability and will be decided as per

feedback given by Interview Panel.(8lacs)

revert with cv

CS Aditya Agrawal (PCS) (110 Points)
Replied 20 March 2012

for goup I ( individually) -- your minimum requirement was : Aggregat 100 and minimum 40 in each paper ( exempted paper's marks never count)

for goup II ( individually) -- your minimum requirement was : Aggregat 150 and minimum 40 in each paper.

for Both goup -- your minimum requirement was : Aggregat 250 and minimum 40 in each paper ( exempted paper's marks never count).

Result is Group -I PASS

Group - II FAIL

(Guest)

congrats to Mr X...

(Guest)

Originally posted by : CS Aditya Agrawal
	for goup I ( individually) -- your minimum requirement was : Aggregat 100 and minimum 40 in each paper ( exempted paper's marks never count) for goup II ( individually) -- your minimum requirement was : Aggregat 150 and minimum 40 in each paper. for Both goup -- your minimum requirement was : Aggregat 250 and minimum 40 in each paper ( exempted paper's marks never count). Result is Group -I PASS Group - II FAIL

r u sure? Except you everyone says he is consider passed.

CA Srikanth Yadav (Chartered Accountant) (3162 Points)
Replied 20 March 2012

Originally posted by : CS Aditya Agrawal
	exempted paper's marks never count

Dear Sir,

In Chartered Accountancy Examinations, exempted papers should also be taken into account for the purpose of aggregate percentage (Yes, I don't know about Company Secretary).

You may refer second point in 2nd question in this link (which is also provided below) :https://220.227.161.86/24309announ14197.pdf .

He shall be declared to have passed in that group/unit if he secures at one sitting aminimum of 40% marks in each of the papers of that group/unit and a minimum of50% of the total marks of all the papers of that group/unit including the paper/s inwhich he had secured a minimum of 60% marks in the earlier examination.

1 Like