LIVE GST Certification Course by CA Arun Chhajer begins 21st April. Register Now!!

Problem with the CA field !

Mr.C.A (ipcc) (173 Points)

25 June 2013

.i've completed my graduation and . i dream to be a c.a one day but everybody is against me saysing that " C.a is illegal filed , . they says that " ca increase the profit by

hiding the tax of company or by showing false Tax to the Government........ i believe if i Hide tax of Government is as same as Stealing the Money Of the Poor People .as Government provide food to the poor people

i heard expert says this and that " but what you will comment on this subject " the subject to pay tax for Food for poor people ...... and do you think is there any way out ??????????????????

if not than WE are the real culprit who hide the tax of so called big companies stealing the food of Poor PEOPLE ...... CULPRIT OR Corruptionist ?

Reply
Follow
Share

7 Replies

Ganeshbabu K (Audit and Tax Advisory) (48559 Points)
Replied 25 June 2013

1)every one will comment..it is very easy and at free of cost.

who have commented on you dont know or not seen corporate world

Ask them

how much TAX they have paid, do they paid honestly to govt. or they suppressed any tax..ever they met any chartered accountant,

Answers to above questions will be Negative

CA SURENDRA KUMAR RAKHECHA (Practising CA at Surat) (26258 Points)
Replied 26 June 2013

When the whole country is deeply involved in corruption.......may it be government, politicians, financial institutions, police, tax authorities, businessmen, professionals-Medical, Engineering or else...including law practitioners,CAs/CS/CMA....then for the most honest persons...only one field remains :

EDUCATION ..!

But unfortunately; this is also the MOST CORRUPT.

If it were good; it might "produce" good citizens

and

all the problems could be solved.

2 Like

amit shaw (student) (104 Points)
Replied 26 June 2013

If u are thinking that CA are cheaters, then definitely be a CA and change the thoughts of the people by being honest taxpayer. Why being irritated with a problem??? Nothings gonna change if you can't make it. Be a part of solution not problems.

sadashiv Rupchand Gaikwad (Proprietor) (521 Points)
Replied 26 June 2013

Perhaps you got wrong information.CA is most effortable degree. No any one can sell his maral for few moneys

Sundar (Articled Assistant) (85 Points)
Replied 26 June 2013

Dont forget income to the revenue depatment of our goverment thurough CA's assessment.

CA's are just complying the laws and not making it. so it is their best of the profession and not being corruption. Dear!

J.M.SELVARAJ (student) (48 Points)
Replied 27 June 2013

Thought it is a kind of profession, not being effective law compliances in practical. Therefore, CA's are within the corruption purview and back tract to the country's economy in practical manner. Dear!

bujjulu (e-TDS + IT return filer Hyderabad) (718 Points)
Replied 27 June 2013

IGNORE THE POINT OF CORRUPTION.

to claim 'professional" in the society how many can answer the ?s posed by the society with a common sense.

As a citizen to recognise CAs as professionals with my common sense I pose the following ?.

For example By some Govt. Departments the TDS deducted is paid through mere book adjustment entry.

Now when these govt . Departments receive any notice for defaults / short deductions / late payment How will they pay is it by book adjustment entry OR the person responsible for deducting TDS (at the time of deducting TDS / at the time of receiving notice)

Service Tax should not be included while calculating the TDS on rent .

Now how many CAs know the journal entry for this (of course I also do not know) .

When the ?s posed by the society with their common sense are un-answered you can hardly gain respect as a professional of CA but only as a specialist of doing something with the professional qualification of CA.