President's commets on Pass percentage

Final 3113 views 12 replies

So the results are out and only 3 out of 100 students are happy. Students are not able to even react on what has suddenly happened? Our Respected (pun intended) President of ICAI was asked by Times of India (which has carried a report today on results) about the pass percentage. Below is the link of the same:

https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/mumbai/Only-3-1-of-CA-final-exam-students-pass/articleshow/28864341.cms

Well if only the shock over seeing the results and pass percent was not enough, waking up in the morning after a dreadful night to get this piece of article was another shocker.

It is a fact that the one scores marks on the basis of efforts taken by them. But what message is he trying to give? Does he mean that only 3 out of 100 students have written properly in the exams, done their articleship seriously and understood the subjects. Well! Quite an achievment.

But why does'nt he reflect on the fact that sheer drop in pass percentage is definately questionable. The score of 1st Rank student (which has gone down considerably) itself answers some of the question. President's comments that this kind of results were common in 80's and 90's is simply unacceptable. 

While regardless of results, everyone (even failed students) do have immense respect for this profession and more imprtantly it's care taker i.e ICAI and its council, only thing one can assume is that when everyone is moving ahead in 21st century, CA students are being pushed back to 80's and 90's, well before the time when they were not even born.

Replies (12)
Yes, I totally agree with you....I couldn't go to sleep without taking sleeping pills last night (two of them mind you!) I think the current president of ICAI has grossly undermined the student's ability and probably has no sense whatsoever about how progressive this education should be and not the other way round!
it is easy to comment by those qualified ca by saying icai rocks ...good results....etc but just imagine those who put there heart and soul but still couldn't clear because of intentional reduction in pass % ge and the worst part is we are crying , blaming, scolding , etc but icai treating us like street dogs , let them bark we don't mind we are doing right so we are like completely helpless.

sad it is 

if the institute thinks that overdependence on private coaching is leading to low results(mentioned in the article) then why don't they give us the correct guidance to do the exams the way we can get the best results? Why doesn't the ICAI itself runs Coaching to give the correct guidance to its students. So that we can write the exams in a way the Institute expects.

Also I find this hard to believe that the performance of the students drops down from 10% passing to 3% in six months! I dont agree to this observation, its not logical at all.

Again, questions are not from the study material,they are BASED on it. Notice the difference

If practical oriented approach is required then every student of iCAI should be given an opportunity to work with the best of the best Firms in India, so that small town students can have the same exposure as the Metro City students, because the success rate there is significantly higher.

And last of all, a little compassion should be shown towards the students who are sacrificing so much to sit the same exam over a span of years( so many years in fact that the Indian Govt election has arrived but still the students are at the same stage there were during the last election)

Think about what I wrote.

Don'"t feel dejected.Things may not be tbe same always.Let us try to achieve the lost glory by showing outstanding results next time.

Dear Participants!!

I am in practice and is doing CA final.  I am 45+ and is in very active practice and God's Grace I am having 150+ clinets and Why I am telling the thing is I am very popular with Income Tax Asst, Appeals etc., besides I am appearing for Service Tax also and is having good working knowldge on these both subject..  But my marks is 31 & 42 respetively.,, I am writing more relevant and is very serious in completing the CA and hence I more cation in using the wordings and style of presentation etc..  If ICAI wants only good working knowledge Why I failed with this poor marks... 

I am rendering justice to all my clients years to gether and they are with me as clients , and if I dont know the Act and proceeedings, I must be failed in my practice too  but I am running the show in very decent manner in my city..

 

Now tell me where the problem lies, So ICAI is not correct the exam papers properly and just like that reduce the marks etc.  and we the students are just help less as no Association/syndicate amoung CA student and our Crying is waste and wrong ICAI is always supreme 

If those 3 can pass then y cant you....

Sorry Mr Jain..Your comment is Rubbish
Originally posted by : CA Saurabh Jain
If those 3 can pass then y cant you....

C.A Saurabh Jain, while your comments are most welcomed, it shows sheer arrogance and nothing else. You coud have conveyed your message much differently.

So very true pratik ..

Originally posted by : CA Saurabh Jain
If those 3 can pass then y cant you....

actually saurabh, i can tell you why only those 3 could pass... and i am going to quote the reason that icai authorities gave me.

i flunked my may '13 attempt by mere 4 marks.. i scored 36 in DT and 196 overall... i got my certified copy of DT and took it to the subject expert in icai; one Ms. Subramaniam, addl. director. she discussed my entire answer sheet for about 1-1.5 hour. and after that 1.5 hr, the conclusion she arrived on both utterly shocked and disappointed me. this was what she could conclude (precisely in her words): "...i can observe a lot of examiner's discretion in your case. this is just BAD LUCK".

perhaps this is what the other 7 who couldn't clear lack...LUCK, of all the things!! because perhaps icai leaves its students' careers on luck... who knows, it may even be doing an 'eni-mini-miny-moe' to choose the lucky 3!!

Hey guys leave the matter... Icai can do any thing, we cant do. What we can do is give your best this time. Concentrate on may 2014. Dont be disturb ur self.. All the best


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register