WOW YOU GOT OFFER R JUST ASKING..MY VIEW DT IS BEST...

DT

ITS MY FAV

SIR PLEASE TELL ME THE SCOPE OF BOTH AND WHICH ONE IS BETTER.IN TERMS OF MONETARY AND KNOWLEDGE

Dude go for DT as E & Y is best in Direct Taxation. I work in a big4 and so i know that E & Y is best in Direct Taxes.

I would tell to prefer IDT in Ernst &Young when U become Manager Your Pay would be  say  Rs 1,50,000 p.m  and it is very intersting than Direct Tax is my opinion.Two of my Friends are Working as Managers in Ernst &Young based at Chennai

Opinion is differing better take a call after careful evaluvation in the Forum.Anyway let me congragulate you for getting the same in Big4

Sanyam opt the one in which you have interest. How can anybody else suggest you which one to choose. This is your own decision. Choose the 1 in which you have inerest. Both have good options.

SANJAY SIR I AM GETTING CONFUSED....ACTUALLY I HAVE INTERST IN BOTH..SO I THOUGHT TO TAKE ADVICE OF EXPERTS....!!!

Mr Sanjay Gupta fully endorse Your views I myself find that in  CA Club Forums Direct Tax Queries are answered immediately but when it comes to Indirect Taxes many Questions remains unanswered .The thing is clear we have very few experts here to answer .Madhukar N Hiregange is the one who often answers since being an expert

This is my opinion you may condradict  it too

You will have to decide in which field you have more interest and then decide. Generally as mentioned by Sivaram there is more consultants on Direct Taxes side whereas there are less in Indirect Taxes side. So if you want to make ur carrer in Indirect Taxes then go for it.

thaks sivaram sir and aditya sir.......!!!

Originally posted by : sivaram
	Mr Sanjay Gupta fully endorse Your views I myself find that in  CA Club Forums Direct Tax Queries are answered immediately but when it comes to Indirect Taxes many Questions remains unanswered .The thing is clear we have very few experts here to answer .Madhukar N Hiregange is the one who often answers since being an expert This is my opinion you may condradict  it too

Correct Sivram Ji...I dont have much expertise in Indirect Tax as mentioned in my expert profile. In replying query only book knowledge is not sufficient you also need some practical experience.

yaaaar as per my opinion u shud go for IDT bcoz there is less professionals in idt if we compare it wid dt......

and rest all depends on ur knowledge, ur interest etc...

and Congratz dude for getting this grt offer..........

You will have to decide in which field you have more interest and then decide. Generally as mentioned by Sivaram there is more consultants on Direct Taxes side whereas there are less in Indirect Taxes side. So if you want to make ur carrer in Indirect Taxes then go for it.. I have Mr. Bhupender Agarwal, who is working as a team leader in EY Hyderabad in Indirect Taxes & he personally feels that its good to be in that area.

Hi SANYAM ARORA

I think you should go for Indirect Tax bcoz our indian gov. earn 60% of total revenue from indirect tax. it is wast but much interesting. Currently many CA's are doing expertise in Direct Tax , it is not a new bcoz every one like DT. But in IDT u can get more scope to learn than DT. I m working with medium size firm. it's does't matter that where r u working. but the more important is that , what u learn from this.I m learn MVAT audit, tax audit, service tax audit, bank audit and must more which are help me to do my own practise in future.There is big shortage of good IDT expert in india.

You must do ur own analyses, that where r u interesting? what is ur future plan, whether u do job or start ur own practise?

Do the market study that where i get good opportunity after completion of articleship?

Best of luck & congrats for clearing 1st group.