Goods are imported by XYZ, India from foreign buyer PQR . After receiving the goods, it is found that the goods are deficient in terms of its quality. Therefore, XYZ had performed some re – work / repair on it before putting it in to use. The re – work / repair charges were recovered from the foreign supplier PQR by issuing a Debit Note. Is XYZ required to pay GST on it? Sir, in my view, it will fall under Section 13(3)(a) of IGST Act i.e. services supplied in respect of goods which are required to be made physically available by the recipient of services to the supplier of services and accordingly since the repairs is performed in India, XYZ will be liable to pay GST. Please confirm.
Menu
Place of supply - performance based service
Replies (5)
Quick Summary
Yes GST is required to pay on such receipt.
As per my opinion, since there is a deficient in supply, customer debits the supplier for the same. There is no further supply of services/goods in this case. Then there is no question of GST applicability.
You are correct but it is also considered as supply of another services for which you received consideration
As per my opinion, there is no supply made by the XYZ to PQR. XYZ merely issues debit note for the deficiency of supply already made. On the other hand, XYZ either get the goods repaired by a third party in local, in this case GST may be paid or if they did it themselves, there is no question of supply. This is my personal opinion.
Here we assume that the PQR is domestic supplier, then what ever Debit Note raised, we have to pay GST and has to collect from PQR.
In my view, reimbursement of re-work or repairing charges has to be along with GST, and has to collect from PQR and has to pay to Government.
In my view, reimbursement of re-work or repairing charges has to be along with GST, and has to collect from PQR and has to pay to Government.
Recent Topics :
- Itr 4 problem
- Capital Gains Mismatch Due to Sale Agreement in FY
- REGARDING NRO INVESTMENT IN SHARES OF DOMESTIC COM
- DTAA benefits
- SUPPLEMENTARY AGREEMENT FOR ADDING A PARTER IN TN
- Part availmement of ITC in case of rejection of su
- Due date for itr 5 no audit with loss for fy 25 26
- Capital Gains Mismatch AIS
- Inward E-way bill from Tally Prime 7.1
- Query regarding exemption under Section 10(10AA) &
Related Topics :
CAclubindia
