Personal comments

In a case where repeated replies are received to a query which has been resolved and the answer is correct then the expert can ask the expert to not reply on resolved query.

If this is not the case then there is no right to the experts to comment on anyone on this site leave away the experts section or experts.

On this site Do not reply to threads with messages like I agree thanks, etc etc. Instead use the thank user icon just below the profile detail of the user in each post.Try to add value with your each post. This should be the funda.

I request all to please add value through your each reply. Now it is upto individual to decide whether he is adding some value through his reply. Please do not make any personnel comments and do not post unnecessary reply.

For me you can always share your good, bad, soft or hard comment...openly or through PM.

It will help me to improve quality of my answers along with my overall improvement here in caclub...

However my personal practice is to avoid making personal comments on others.

Best Regards

hello

please read my reply 

i replied on there part of problem

and Mr.  Aditya I watch some of your  replies Which  you  repeated. 

firstly tell me , are u giving only open problems?

and i give reply of problem for a specific point not for whole problem so a i added some addition.

and who are you to tell me that'' why u are u repeated after 8 days'' 

all expert are free to give there reply which is open or resolved so you are not only one expert ok.

yes mr. ankur you are right

i am welcome if i am wrong on any topic and you give corrective comment on it.

but if some one  personally comment on me than i am not tolerating  this and if that person  like that i am not Qualified  to be a expert than he can complaint to administrator of this site.

i am  not there for earning points to this site and i am also a professionally qualified person.

Regards

CA. ANOOP GADIA , ACA, MBA, B.Com., PGDFM, D-Phamacy

and pursuing CFA (US) , DISA, DIRM 

and in practicing ca from 1 year.  

Yes

my problem on following line

However my personal practice is to avoid making personal comments on others.

so if u are professional than why some one commenting personally.