Lessons learned from the girl who owed 11,000 on her tax return

So two years ago I was filing my tax return and was excited to see what my tax refund would be after working at my very first adult job for a whole year. I remember clicking excitedly through TurboTax and then getting to the final page where it said 11,000 OWED. I had never done my own tax return before so I figured I messed something up and had my mom come over and do it by hand. She got the same result and immediately asked to see my paychecks.

Turns out I was only having about 5% of my paychecks withheld for taxes. I hadn’t noticed how little was being withheld because it was my first adult job and I was blissfully ignorant and enjoying the big paychecks. When I had filled out my W4 I remember being confused and the HR guy saying “Don’t worry you can always change it later jus put whatever”. I can’t even remember what I put down on that form but i really fudged it up. Then I just let it slip out of my mind. Big mistake.

So I freaked out for a while, posted on this subreddit, took the advice of /u/these-things-happen , made an initial payment of as much money as I had in my bank account and got myself on a payment plan of $350 per month. Whenever I had any extra money from overtime and sidegigs I made online payments to the IRS. My recent tax retund got taken to finally pay off the remaining amount last week so I AM OFFICIALLY OUT OF DEBT TO THE IRS. I’m so happy to be done with it.

Anyways to help any one from making the same dumb mistakes as me here’s my advice on what I learned. For you advanced PF’ers out there this will seem like common sense but hopefully it helps someone somewhere.

The basics: the lower your withholding rate the more taxes are taken from your paycheck. If you overwithhold (put a lower number on your w4 than you need to) you will get a bigger refund but then are giving the IRS an interest free loan all year when you could be using that money to pay stuff off. If you underwithhold (put a higher number on your w4 withholding than you should have) then you may owe up owing the IRS on your tax return and you may not have been prepared to pay it.

Always use the IRS Withholding Calculator to determine what to put on your W4). Update it through your HR at any time and especially if anything big happens (get married, get a second job, have a kid). Take your withholding very very seriously.

Check your paychecks from time to time to calculate the percentage of how much is being taken out in taxes and know your state/city tax rate to make sure you’re on track

If you do owe on your refund don’t be afraid to call the IRS. They are actually ridiculously nice and helpful when you call them for help - set up an installation agreement right away if you can’t afford to pay what you owe.

Replies (4)
Quick Summary
This discussion shares a personal account of owing £11,000 on a tax return due to under-withholding from a first adult job. The author learned the hard way about the importance of correctly filling out the W4 form and regularly checking tax withholdings. They advise using the IRS Withholding Calculator, updating your W4 with life changes, and not being afraid to contact the IRS for payment plans if you do owe.

Thanks
Thanks....
Originally posted by : Lina
So two years ago I was filing my tax return and was excited to see what my tax refund would be after working at my very first adult job for a whole year. I remember clicking excitedly through TurboTax and then getting to the final page where it said 11,000 OWED. I had never done my own tax return before so I figured I messed something up and had my mom come over and do it by hand. She got the same result and immediately asked to see my paychecks.

Turns out I was only having about 5% of my paychecks withheld for taxes. I hadn’t noticed how little was being withheld because it was my first adult job and I was blissfully ignorant and enjoying the big paychecks. When I had filled out my W4 I remember being confused and the HR guy saying “Don’t worry you can always change it later jus put whatever”. I can’t even remember what I put down on that form but i really fudged it up. Then I just let it slip out of my mind. Big mistake.

So I freaked out for a while, posted on this subreddit, took the advice of /u/these-things-happen , made an initial payment of as much money as I had in my bank account and got myself on a payment plan of $350 per month. Whenever I had any extra money from overtime and sidegigs I made online payments to the IRS. My recent tax retund got taken to finally pay off the remaining amount last week so I AM OFFICIALLY OUT OF DEBT TO THE IRS. I’m so happy to be done with it.

Anyways to help any one from making the same dumb mistakes as me here’s my advice on what I learned. For you advanced PF’ers out there this will seem like common sense but hopefully it helps someone somewhere.

The basics: the lower your withholding rate the more taxes are taken from your paycheck. If you overwithhold (put a https://19216801.onl/ https://routerlogin.uno/ lower number on your w4 than you need to) you will get a bigger refund but then are giving the IRS an interest free loan all year when you could be using that money to pay stuff off. If you underwithhold (put a higher number on your w4 withholding than you should have) then you may owe up owing the IRS on your tax return and you may not have been prepared to pay it.

Always use the IRS Withholding Calculator to determine what to put on your W4). Update it through your HR at any time and especially if anything big happens (get married, get a second job, have a kid). Take your withholding very very seriously.

Check your paychecks from time to time to calculate the percentage of how much is being taken out in taxes and know your state/city tax rate to make sure you’re on track

If you do owe on your refund don’t be afraid to call the IRS. They are actually ridiculously nice and helpful when you call them for help - set up an installation agreement right away if you can’t afford to pay what you owe.

Just wanted to update you I was able to easily apply for the first time abatement of penalties over the phone with IRS and got my check in the mail last week for $180! Thanks again

Thanks

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  

Company
15 October 2026
Senior Accountant

Continental Belting Pvt Ltd

Mumbai

B.Com

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 01 October 2026
Articled Assistant

KPSN & Associates LLP

Chennai

CA Inter

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 18 September 2026
Industrial Trainee

Twenty Point Nine Five Ventures Private Limited

Noida

CA Inter

View Details
Company
Featured 03 October 2026
Accountant

A P Lodha and Associates

Jalna

B.Com

View Details
Company
07 October 2026
Senior Account Manager

Amplio Invest

Mumbai

M.Com

View Details
Company
05 October 2026
Senior Accountant

Vision IT Peripherals Pvt Ltd

Mumbai

B.Com

View Details
Company
Featured ARTICLESHIP 06 October 2026
Semi Qualified

AJAY SINGH AND CO LLP

Thane

CA Final

View Details
Company
14 October 2026
Asst. Manager/Dy Manager (Costing)

manufacturing

Pune

CMA

View Details