Insurance loss assessment

For the claim lodged in insusance for flood damage, their surveyor assessed the machinery damage as per below. Plz advise whether its right.

1) For calculation of under insurance value, he has taken purchase value of machinery and  applied inflation index to that value without considering the depreciation.

2) For calculation of loss, for the new spare part of machinery, he has deducted depriciation of 5% per year fom the year of puchase for the entire machinery.

3) For calculation of under insurance for 5 machcineries he has taken total value of all 25 machineries in factory and discounted total under insurance value of machinery on the loss of 5 machineries.

please advise on the correcttness of this damage assessment.

Replies (3)
Quick Summary
This discussion addresses potential inaccuracies in an insurance surveyor's assessment of flood damage to machinery. The surveyor's methods for calculating under-insurance value and depreciation on spare parts have been questioned. Specifically, the assessment incorrectly applied inflation without considering depreciation for under-insurance, deducted depreciation from the entire machinery instead of just the spare part, and incorrectly calculated under-insurance for a subset of machines by using the total factory value. Recommendations are provided for a more accurate calculation based on current market value and individual machine assessments.

I'll break down each point to help you understand the correctness of the surveyor's assessment:

 1. Under Insurance Value Calculation: - The surveyor calculated the under-insurance value by taking the purchase value of the machinery and applying the inflation index without considering depreciation. -

*Correctness*: Incorrect. The correct approach is to calculate the under-insurance value based on the current market value of the machinery, considering depreciation. 

2. Loss Calculation for New Spare Part: - The surveyor deducted depreciation of 5% per year from the year of purchase for the entire machinery. - *Correctness*: Partially correct. The depreciation deduction is correct, but it should be applied only to the specific spare part being replaced, not the entire machinery. 

3. Under Insurance Calculation for 5 Machineries: - The surveyor took the total value of all 25 machineries in the factory and discounted the total under-insurance value of the machinery for the loss of 5 machineries. - 

*Correctness*: Incorrect. The under-insurance value should be calculated separately for the 5 damaged machineries, considering their individual values and depreciation. 

Recommendations:

1. *Re-calculate Under Insurance Value*: Calculate the under-insurance value based on the current market value of the machinery, considering depreciation. 

2. *Correct Depreciation Deduction*: Apply depreciation deduction only to the specific spare part being replaced.

 3. *Separate Under Insurance Calculation*: Calculate the under-insurance value separately for the 5 damaged machineries. It's essential to discuss these points with the surveyor and your insurance provider to ensure a fair and accurate assessment of the damage.

Sir, Thank you very much for your response.Thanks a lot, sir. 

These calculations depend on the policy wording and the basis of cover—for example, reinstatement value or market/indemnity value, and any average clause. The surveyor’s method should be checked against those terms; there is no single depreciation or valuation method applicable to every machinery claim.

  • Underinsurance value: Applying an inflation index to the original purchase price without depreciation may be reasonable only if the policy’s insured-value basis calls for a current replacement/reinstatement value. For an indemnity or market-value basis, age, condition and depreciation are generally relevant. The index, valuation date and treatment of improvements should also be supportable.
  • Loss to machinery/spares: Depreciation should ordinarily reflect the damaged item’s age and condition, not automatically the age of the entire machine. A new spare part may not warrant the same depreciation as an old component, but the policy’s reinstatement provisions and any deductions for betterment or wear and tear matter.
  • Average for five damaged machines: If the policy insures all 25 machines under one sum insured and applies an average clause, the shortfall is generally measured against the value of the entire property covered by that sum insured; the resulting proportionate reduction may then apply to the loss on the five damaged machines. If machines have separate sums insured, or the policy has different item/location limits, the calculation may differ.

Ask the surveyor to provide the policy clause relied on, the valuation basis and date, machine-wise values and depreciation, and the average-clause calculation. Reconcile these with the schedule, asset register, purchase/replacement evidence and the insurer’s settlement workings before accepting the assessment.

Reviewing the valuation basis, depreciation and average-clause workings is a useful part of managing an insurance claim file. Manual claim checks can be time-consuming, and automation can reduce repetitive comparisons while leaving policy interpretation and professional judgment in your control. At Jir AI we provide 2,000+ AI agents and 650+ integrations to streamline your practice’s day-to-day workload. For a quick WhatsApp conversation about your workflow, message us here: https://wa.me/message/3HVOZ7HIY4ESC1

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  

Company
14 November 2026
Manager - Indirect Tax (GST)

Westbridge Consulting LLP

New Delhi

CA

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 16 November 2026
Audit Executives

Loonker Godawat And Company

Bengaluru

B.Com

View Details
Company
10 November 2026
FP&A Executive

Gujarat Guardian

Ankleshwar

CA Final

View Details
Company
Featured ARTICLESHIP 17 November 2026
Associate/ Article Trainee

M/s. A V C & Co.

New Delhi

CA Inter

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 23 October 2026
CA Articleship / Article Assistant

M N Rao & Associates LLP

Vijayawada

CA Inter

View Details
Company
16 November 2026
Assistant Article

ZAK & Co. Chartered Accountants

Bengaluru

CA Inter

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 14 November 2026
Article Assistant

Jitendra Agarwal & Associates

Bengaluru

CA Inter

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 25 October 2026
Article Intern (CA Articleship)

Arpan Bohra & Co

Hyderabad

CA Inter

View Details