Chartered Accountant
207 Points
Joined March 2007
As regards the implementation of IAS 16 is concerned, it poses significant challenge for the companies who will be adopting the IFRS for the first time.
IFRS 1 lays down the guidelines/principles for first time adopters of IFRS. Generally, all the standards are to be applied with retrospective effect. But IFRS 1 grants limited exemptions from certain requirements in specified areas where the cost of complying with them would be likely to exceed the benefits to users of financial statements.
The IFRS also prohibits retrospective application of IFRSs in some areas, particularly where retrospective application would require judgments by management about past conditions after the outcome of a particular transaction is already known.
Accordingly para 13 of IFRS lists down certain areas for which first time adopters are given exemptions for application of some standards.
Unfortunately the list of exemption does not include the exemption from application of IAS 16. The application of IAS 16 will also require high levels of judgements by management about the past conditions because machineries would already be in use or in some cases may be approaching the end of their useful lives. To apply retroactively IAS 16 in such cases will create practical difficulty for the companies. It is going to be huge time consuming process for the capital intensive companies to do the component accounting as per IAS 16 with retrospective effect.
Therefore, it is recommended to apply the IFRS 1 with certain modifications so that India Inc does not face much difficulty in its convergence process to IFRS.