I am in Deep Confusion .............

IPCC 2198 views 16 replies
User Avatar

CA Student.
1407 Points Joined February 2009

 

To all CCI Members,

Please Solve My Confusion,;(

Recently a Clause Introduced that

-

Registration of PCC is Valid For 4 years 

and

The Students Who want to appear in Nov 2011 Exam WAnt to Revalidate if Their Registartion

If they are Registered

On Or Before 31.Oct.2007......



And i m in PCC

And My date Of Registration Is 05.November.2007 (Just 4 days After Cut off date)



And i want to Appear in November 2011 Exam 



So,

Acording to clause,

There is No Need To Revalidate It

 

I Call To Kanpur Branch as Well as Vishwas nagar Delhi Office They both told me That - no need to Rvalidate 

I Asked same thing From E-Sahayta - they replied to Revalidate it.............

Then my Confusion arises - what to do ? Revalidate or Not.........



But my opinion , :)

the result of November exam will declare on February 2012,

Till that date (February 2012)

My Registration is Not Valid (Because it will expire on 5.November.2011.



Conlusion that - 

According to Branch Offices - No need to revalidate

According to Clause - No need to Revalidate

According to E-Sahayta - Need to Revalidate



What i do ?

Tell me Please ................................

Reply Share Follow
On 22 July 2011 at 11:11 Report
Replies (16)
User Avatar

CA Student
6149 Points Joined March 2009

I adivse you that you should REVALIDATE considering the cut-off dates clearly mentioned as per the Notification and also as per the views expressed by E-Sahaayata.

1 Reply
On 22 July 2011 at 11:16
User Avatar

Country Analyst
505 Points Joined October 2008

Just call at 011-30210600,302106001,302106002,302106003,302106004,302106005,302106006

                       This is the helpline numbers for students.

You may call there and ask for the exact solution of the problem.      

                             

 

1 Reply
On 22 July 2011 at 11:35
User Avatar

Company Secretary
13867 Points Joined May 2011

As per my understanding there is no need to re-validate bcoz logically relevant date for re-registration purpose should be the date of Examination.

 

However it is an interpretation based clause which involves inherent risk to your fair attempt.

There is no need tc panic...as u hv ample time to figure out the right way. So keep trying other means or visit your nearest branch for clarification.

 

My best wishes

1 Reply
On 22 July 2011 at 11:51
User Avatar

CA IN PRACTICE
16719 Points Joined May 2011
Originally posted by : Krishna

I adivse you that you should REVALIDATE considering the cut-off dates clearly mentioned as per the Notification and also as per the views expressed by E-Sahaayata.
1 Reply
On 22 July 2011 at 14:51
User Avatar

CCI STUDENT....
44687 Points Joined January 2009

They have cleared mention on r before oct 31, that means you can write this nov and after this attempt you need to revalidate your PCC...If your still in dilema just contact your chpater and get details...

 

Best of luck

1 Reply
On 22 July 2011 at 15:48
User Avatar

One life one Dream
3525 Points Joined May 2010
Originally posted by : BALU A HELPING HAND...

They have cleared mention on r before oct 31, that means you can write this nov and after this attempt you need to revalidate your PCC...If your still in dilema just contact your chpater and get details...

 

Best of luck
1 Reply
On 22 July 2011 at 15:55
User Avatar

CCI STUDENT.....
773 Points Joined September 2010
Originally posted by : BALU A HELPING HAND...

They have cleared mention on r before oct 31, that means you can write this nov and after this attempt you need to revalidate your PCC...If your still in dilema just contact your chpater and get details...

 

Best of luck
1 Reply
On 22 July 2011 at 16:46
User Avatar

accounts
131 Points Joined July 2011
Originally posted by : TaRaN

YOU are registered after 31.oct.2007


according to provisions of ICAI you are valid till 4.NOV.2011(5.NOV.2007 - 4.NOV.2011) regarded as 4 years


i recommend you to revalidate with a fee of 400/- for avoiding any risk..

agreed                                                                        

1 Reply
On 22 July 2011 at 20:19
User Avatar

Assisstant manager - Accounts in a UK Ba
189 Points Joined January 2008

Oh My God these Indtitute ppl have made CA course very complicated... Poor students... They shld rather simplify it...

1 Reply
On 22 July 2011 at 20:41
User Avatar

CA IN PRACTICE
16719 Points Joined May 2011
Originally posted by : TaRaN

YOU are registered after 31.oct.2007


according to provisions of ICAI you are valid till 4.NOV.2011(5.NOV.2007 - 4.NOV.2011) regarded as 4 years


i recommend you to revalidate with a fee of 400/- for avoiding any risk..

TOTALLY AGREED 

1 Reply
On 22 July 2011 at 21:24
Guest

You are eligible to appear in "November 2011" examinations without "revalidation".


Reply
On 22 July 2011 at 22:02
User Avatar

CA
8316 Points Joined June 2009

as per my thinking not necessary........................

1 Reply
On 22 July 2011 at 22:22
User Avatar

CA Student.
1407 Points Joined February 2009

Thanks To all CCi Members For Your Valuable Sugestion 

Reply
On 23 July 2011 at 11:46
User Avatar

CA
1677 Points Joined October 2008

revalidation is needed in my opinion manjul

Reply
On 23 July 2011 at 16:48


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Post Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  

Recent Threads

More recent discussions | Post

Related Threads
Loading