Hra-a study

Tax planning 1439 views 18 replies

House Rent Allowance (10(13A) and rule 2A)-

There is a lot of queries about HRA for expert advice, So I tried to club all answers in one place.

When a salaried person gets HRA, it is regulated by rule 2A. The least of following is exempt from tax:-

50% of salary if house is situated at Mumbai, Delhi, Kolkata or Chennai or 40% except these.

HRA received by employee in respect of period during which the rental accommodation is occupied by him

The excess of rent paid over 10% of salary

Salary means Basic salary + DA (when it is part of salary for computing retirement benefits) ITO v Sr. Accounts officer, Pay & Accounts, DHBVNL (2009). It also includes commission based on fixed % of turnover achieved by an employee as per terms of contract of employment.

Many people ask, if they have home in one place and they job at other place where they have taken house on rent then Can they take this exemption? The Answer is “YES”.  There is no restriction in income tax for that. You can take exemption if you are paying rent where you are working.

Some people ask, can they pay rent to their parents or wife also.  The Answer is again “YES”.  But ITO can object on this because you are living in one home and there is no monetary transaction. Best is if they are paying rent to father/Mother/Wife then that person must show this rent income in his/her return and the rent payer must show his landlord PAN in his return. So that department can’t object on this.

A question was raised that if a person is getting 80C and 24(b) on home loan repayment and interest. Then can he claim HRA exemption. The answer is again “YES”. See first query. He can have home at one place but can pay rent where he is working for home. So there is no problem from income tax.

 

Replies (18)

   smiley thanks sir.......you make this very simple ...yesyes

Prashant ji . I have one doubt in it........

 

As u say We can pay rent to Wife also to claim HRA......

 

But as I knw...we can not claim rent paid to Spouse. The relationship

 

between Husband & wife is not Commercial in nature.....

 

A husband & wife supposed to be stay together.....

 

 

We can not claim in dis case......

 

Dear Anamikaa

income tax says employee need to pay rent.

if the rent is paid then there is no objection. Thats why I advised to show this in wife's return as income from house property. then it will be clear that there is a monetary transaction.

But Prashanrt ji .....

 

payment of rent to spouse will not be accepted by I. T Authorities....

 

Kindly give any supporting Case/circular/notification regarding dis.....

Very clear nd easy to understand...

thanku....

keep sharing...

Dear Anamikaa

theory and practical are diff things. in practical most employee pay rent to their father. income tax doesn't have link with PAN that what PAN is of spouse.  moreover

income tax treat every income and exp as income and exp, legal or illegal.

in same way income tax treat income of rent from any person, if that person show it as rent exp and receiving person shows it as income from house property. condition is home must be non later person's name

Dear Anamikaa

please check the attached file circular no 798 dt 30-10-2000 see page 9 and 10, I highlighted that.

in this it is clear that only requirement is rent paid. and home must be not owned by rent payer. So if home is on spouse name other can pay him/her rent.

Very useful..thanx for sharing..yes

Sorry

last time I attached Word 2007 file, which system refused

now you can see the file it is in word 2003 format

Good one.. Clear and precise.. All major doubts are cleared..!!! 

Still not satisfied wid ur attachment , it is not clr dat gvng rent to

 

spouse can be claim or not..... :-(

Dear Anamikaa

you are seeing only with one aspect

in taxation matters, only Act speaks or a judgement speaks.  Act wants only rent payment, this is only condition. so it will be allowed. but condition, home is in name of spouse who is getting rent, no joint name. second he/she should show rent income in his/her return.

VERY VERY USEFUL SHARING....THANKSyes

Originally posted by : CA Prashant Gupta

in taxation matters, only Act speaks or a judgement speaks.  Act wants only rent payment, this is only condition. so it will be allowed. but condition, home is in name of spouse who is getting rent, no joint name. second he/she should show rent income in his/her return.

 

Thanx Prashant ji.....


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register