How was indirect tax paper of ca final?

https://www.icai.org/app_forms/student_feedback.html

Finally the exam's over.......hope it went well......may u  get what u deserve........
utilize these holidays effectively........& give ur valuable feedbacks in the above mentioned link.......wud b helpfull for ICAI to set ques paper for future examinations.......

dats realy realy true ........ a very scorin pap ........ hopin 4 exemption ........ 

so easy paper, doesnot seem to be ca final level, what icai is doing, degrading the value of courses, 

Feeling free!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 

almost paper is from from RTP and amendment . Lenghty but not typical!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

very easy paper and most of the caes laws were covered.

Well said Namit Bhai !
ICAI has gone mad.....I think ! Day by day recruitments for CA is droppin down........Dunno wats gonna happen in future....

when institute wants to help students we say, standards are falling down. when it is tough we say, institute its not students friends.

all the best for every one

Well before giving a overall review abt 2nd group papers  .. dis is for those people who say insti is lowering its stds by setting easy papers and there are no jobs ... phps students over here do not knw wat dey want .. if insti sets a tough paper dey make a fuss,,,on the contrary if a ok paper den also dey r creating a hype... i suggest people shud take it at face value whatever comes and as far as the jobs are concerned post qualification ..it depends on how smart enuf u r and ur dynamicity to be in the corporate world...coz on job wat matters is ur personality and way to handle stress or work with ur peers and above all the manner of marketing urself with a CA degree or nt a CA degree.. real talent is alwez recognised....As far as  my review goes it was by no means a very easy second group considering the time management the level of thinking required  the checking standards of our institute and finally the level of professional answers expected at this level.... ,alongwith all case laws and sections... so lets all hope for the best and kip r fingers crossed,,,without qustioning on the institute stds .. coz had dat been the case we all shud have thot it much b4 joining da course rather dan gettin in the course and den cursing it.....these comments are jus on wat i read on dis forum and nuthin specific to any1 or any body's post...all da bst to all...

a very easy paper i never seen...most of question from RTP and case law questions from Institute supplementary material

Originally posted by : Dhananjay Reddy
	a very easy paper i never seen...most of question from RTP and case law questions from Institute supplementary material

hi.........mr reddy ...i think u have not seen or analysed past  3 or 4 papers  ..all the case study questions were from supplementry study mat and there was significant coverage of  rtp in question papers....

if u carefully campare past 2 IDT papers with may 2012 paper ...u would find.... past 2 papers were much more easy  and manageable in 3 hours...

what is your view about nov 2010 IDT paper ...there was 45 marks problem and all the case studies were as easy as u like......

Hi Asit,

I had written IDT paper for the first time and i had seen only Nov-11 Q. paper but not analysed with Nov-11 RTP......and i told IDT as easy by comparing with other papers and not with previous year Q.papers....k