Fear of losing an audit of a company

Others 484 views 2 replies

This just struck to me while doing Audit, Pls give your opinions.

Suppose Mr A is an auditor of a Pvt Co. which is generally promoter driven and major stakeholder are the promoters itself.

Mr A receives a pretty high  Amount as Audit fees as the turnover of Co. is also high.

Now while performing audit Mr A finds out misstatement due to fraud which is very much material. Now as per Auditing standards and ethics Mr A enquired with the management (Promoter and other directors) and the management was of the opinion that such fraud should not be reported and they would continue with such and if reported Mr A would not be reappointed.

Mr A wanted to include this in his report, but the fear of losing the audit appointment, as it received pretty high amount of audit fees from this audit struck him.

What should Mr A do? Do you have any suggestion where by "Saap bhi mar jaaye aur laathi bhi na tutte" can be applied i.e he can report it and can even get reappointed?

Replies (2)

Not disclosing the material facts during Audit by the Auditors is very common in Indian Industries.

This a common issue faced by many an auditor of a closely held company.

on the fcaeof your query, the auditor is bound to report the same in his report The relevant questions to ask here would be

1. Who is committing a fraud on whom?

2. Who gains from the fraud.

3. Is it really fraud or just creative accounting.

This also raises a really relevant question for the CA profession which is

Are you an auditor who signs and collects fees just because there is a statutory requirement to do so, or are you adding value to your client??. If you add even a little value to your client, he wouldnt dare to threaten you with non reappointment.

 


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register