Partner in Dhadda anc Company - Jaipur
22 Points
Joined October 2009
Saurabh Ji
I am replying to the post which is an year old. However it is trending in this Diwali as well and I think I should update my views which go as under: -
I guess the definition of goods has been misinterpreted. The Definition goes as under: -
“goods” means every kind of movable property other than money and securities but includes actionable claim, growing crops, grass and things attached to or forming part of the land which are agreed to be severed before supply or under a contract of supply;
It is severed and not served - severed means cut - The word has been used in connection with growing crops, grass and things attached to earth.
These are treated to goods even when they are not movable until they are cut before supply or cut under a contract.
and therefore the word severed is not connected with supplying the goods to be classified as goods.
Thus when diwali gifts are purchased they are goods and will remain goods even if we supply it further or not. As far as ITC is concerned it will remain blocked under 17(5)(h) since the goods per se are disposed of as gifts.
Any other views are most welcome.
Thanks
CA Devendra Kataria
Kota (Rajasthan)