Pranjal (Student CA IPC / IPCC) (531 Points)
07 August 2009I got a mail from S C Ravishankar,Assistant Secretary,Board of Studies,email id scravishankar @ icai.org.I was shocked to get his reply.I'm pasting herewith his reply to decide for yourself how much Rakesh is true.
" Dear Student,
CA CS Amit Borade
(Chief Accountant)
(2828 Points)
Replied 07 August 2009
U r incresing the Tension amoung Students...
Shreyash Sadashiv Pai
(Bcom, CA)
(188 Points)
Replied 07 August 2009
Now look at this guys....
P.E II and IPCC is almost the same. In both cases once you clear you can write finals in 2 years from passing. Over and above that in IPCC once you clear the Ist group you get to start articleship. So in case we don't clear P.E II, IPCC is a better option. Communication & ethics is the only new subject we gotta deal with.
And lets be fair to others aswell... How many attempts should we P.E II s be getting? We were lucky to get those 2 extra attempts earlier. Convert to IPCC and if you have the slighest doubt of passing start studying right away. I have already converted and got the books. The portion is 85% similiar to P.E II portion. So get your books and start studying.!!
Regards
Rakesh
(IPCC Student)
(321 Points)
Replied 07 August 2009
"On this issue I personally study various notification & scheme of Education & training of ICAI and conclude that who had taken admission in CA Inter / PE-2 on basis of Degree or other qualification and till could not passed are NOT ELIGIBLE for article ship since he could not clear any exam of ICAI.PE-2 attempt could not be extended technically because NOV exam notification in Gov Gazette has been published which could not modify and I think also that institute is not going to conduct simultaneously three exam i.e. PE-2 , PCE & IPCE for CA Inter level so don’t expect about extension of PE-2 which is already extended for two attempts. If Institute extend then they are compromising with QUALITY because one side they had changed syllabus & pattern with respect to today Industry challenge & global scenario and other side they are running old syllabus.Institute should strongly oppose about extension of old syllabus this issue and allow this category of student to PCC or IPCC.What is possibility that if institute extend the PE-2 for next 2 or 3 attempts then the entire student who is failure from last many attempts will passed and these category will become empty.I also suggest this category of student to mentally prepare for switched over and Welcome the New syllabus & pattern which is beneficial for profession of CA.Please put your view on this Issue."
ICAI can,t extend PE-2 technically. there is little chance for this category of student to transfer PCC but admission/ transfer had closed on 30-June-2009 but if institue show its mercy with PE-2 students then it will be possible otherwise PE-2 students will lose NOV 2009 attemp and if a students didn't register itself for IPCC before 31-JUL-09 then they will loose MAY 2010 attemp also as per requirment of 9 months gap for IPCE exam.
But Picture abhi baaki hai mere dost.........
Shreyash Sadashiv Pai
(Bcom, CA)
(188 Points)
Replied 07 August 2009
I have come across many P.E II students talking about PCC attempt Nov 09..... Conversion to PCC has been halted from June 30th 09.... and also to remind you guys first IPCC is in Nov 09. The 9 month requirement might be done away with for P.E II students. Convert to IPCC immediately if you have the slighest doubt of passing....
There will be no PCC for P.E II henceforth as I understand
Ashwani Narnoli
(.)
(1843 Points)
Replied 07 August 2009
| Originally posted by :Pranjal | ||
| " | I got a mail from S C Ravishankar,Assistant Secretary,Board of Studies,email id scravishankar @ icai.org.I was shocked to get his reply.I'm pasting herewith his reply to decide for yourself how much Rakesh is true. " Dear Student, PE-II exam will not be extended beyond June, 2009 exam. All students of PE-II now have to convert to IPCC.Please regularly watch for an announcement/ updation in this regard on our web site." |
" |
Well what we can do
Pratik More
(CA FINAL CS ICWAI AMFI IRDA CGM M.COM ALL NCFM CRTFCT CPM CPA.)
(604 Points)
Replied 07 August 2009
toh picture dekho dosto................................
Siddharth
(456)
(27 Points)
Replied 07 August 2009
| Originally posted by :Pranjal | ||
| " | I got a mail from S C Ravishankar,Assistant Secretary,Board of Studies,email id scravishankar @ icai.org.I was shocked to get his reply.I'm pasting herewith his reply to decide for yourself how much Rakesh is true. " Dear Student, PE-II exam will not be extended beyond June, 2009 exam. All students of PE-II now have to convert to IPCC.Please regularly watch for an announcement/ updation in this regard on our web site." |
" |
how 2 score rank in ca final without any regular coaching?
YASH JAIN
(ARTICLE)
(554 Points)
Replied 07 August 2009
HEY SHREYANSH UR RIGHT THERE IS NO PCC ..........MOREOVER PE2 STUDENT WILL GET NEXT IPCC ATTEMP IN NOV 2010 AS FOR MAY O10 31ST JULY WAS LAST DATE.............................
YASH JAIN
(ARTICLE)
(554 Points)
Replied 07 August 2009
RAKESH I FIRST OF ALL LITERALLY ADVISE U TO SEE THE MODULE OF PE2 AND THEN COMPARE WITH IPCC
DOING THIS U WILL GET RID OF WRONG PRESUMPTION THAT IPCC IS TECHNICALLY MORE ADVANCED
MOREOVER IPCC IS LOT SIMPLER THAN PE2 /.....................AS U ONLY HAVE TO CONCENTRATE ON GROUP I FOR DOING ARTICLES
YASH JAIN
(ARTICLE)
(554 Points)
Replied 08 August 2009
WITH UR CONCERN ABOUT QUALITY............THEN DEAR ALWAYS REMEBER UR REAL QULITY IS TESTED IN FINALS AND NOT IN IPCC/PE2/PCC.............
rahul
(exe)
(40 Points)
Replied 08 August 2009
i received a mail from hyderabad chapter which iam submitting here
Pranjal
(Student CA IPC / IPCC)
(531 Points)
Replied 08 August 2009
From Yash's message it appears that for those students who couldn't clear PE II in June '09 will have to sit for one long year to appear in IPCC,and those who had passed one of the groups in PE II will have to prepare for one group the whole one year.It's useless to say anything about the Institute but I guess it will spare such students who have completed articles to again register for articles training.But still I think we can hope for vsome notification from the Institute as it is evident from the last line of the mail sent by BOS.
GSTR 9 and 9C for FY 23-24 as amended by Notification 12/2024 dated 10th July 2024(with recording)
CAclubindia
