Eienstein (Student CA IPC / IPCC) (24 Points)
28 April 2013
Vaneet Bansal
(learning new things)
(106 Points)
Replied 28 April 2013
look ..............commerce and science is a different field. both have their respective image in the minds of people. as you asked for logic in the commerce so i want to tell you that it is not necceasry that you find logic behind everythings. commerce is abt business and in business there is no logic.
Second you asked abt scinece student can pass CA but CA Student Cannot stand nearby it is tottaly wrongs because you have just pass CPT with 152 Marks and for ur kind information CPT is only a A-B-C of CA Journey. It is good that u have confidence to clear IPC in first attempt but that does not mean that CA is easier than science.Only The CA exams is in the India who have such a low pass percentage Even if u able to clear the entrance exams of CA it does not mean that u have passed the final exams easily. In india if a person is able to clear the medical or engineer entrance test than he can surely endup as engineer or doctor but is not a same situation for CA Students. and once u pass the exams u will find that what a respect a CA would recive from the general public.
So my view is just take intt. in CA and afterwards u will enjoy to being a part of dignifiable profession of India
Best of Luck
mohit kumar
(student)
(126 Points)
Replied 28 April 2013
Einstein Ji,
Arey bhaiya aapko to khush hona chahiye ki aapko itni saari baato ka gyan h........... Kuch log apni puri zindagi isi gyan ko praapt karne mein nikaal dete h............ Cheer up man, You have got an interesting surprise package with both the fields...... Then why to feel low about one.............. Aap maane ya na maane lekin gyan to sab jagah hai.......... Nazariya to bas apni apni soch ka hai............
Stay happy.......... Stay blessed............. 
Go green
(ICAI)
(666 Points)
Replied 28 April 2013
You're Einstein! So hence science.
Jokes apart! And I would say it's your interest that matters the most. What is your passion? Your interest and passion should be the only driving factors for deciding your profession! And your interest seems to be towards science. So you've to go with science. Also I don't want to debate with you regarding the logic thing you're talking about. And whatever the profession you may choose, GOOD LUCK!
Aseem Watts
(CA Final)
(289 Points)
Replied 29 April 2013
Now i m a ca student, i m from science bckgrou(+1,+2). I m very much intersted in science. I cracked aieee got engineering seat @ nit jalandhar. But my parents forced me to go gor ca. Cleared cpt with 129 marks only after studying for 1 month. And i guess i had scored 50/50 in quantative. Sometimes i get bore after reading these logic less subjects. But now i have decided to complete ca , there are many fields where u can show ur talent. U can go for CAT full of quantative aptitude , u can become entrepreneur,IAS exam full of science and math in prelims and a lot of fields, dont quit complete ur studies first. quitters never win winners never quit.
Vinod Kumar
(Regd. Tax Practitioner & Accountant)
(21 Points)
Replied 30 April 2013
Come on man... Why are u so much concerned with the logic behind commerce and science subjects ? It all depends on ur interest. If u like science, study science and become a scientist and if u like commerce,study commerce and become a commerce man. Every subject has it's own importance, status and application. There is no such thing as superior and inferior subjects. For ex. your knowledge about atomic numbers, atomic tables, valency etc won't help u when dealing with ur bank transactions and other day to day matters for which u need a little knowledge of commerce and other subjects. Similarly, when it comes to scientific matters, knowledge of science becomes important. We need science, commerce, arts,engineering etc etc. Just imagine a world with only one kind of species ... only scientists or CAs etc etc. How boring it would be?
So, my advice to u ... learn your subject of interest , learn to respect all subjects & professions and to use your mind creatively rather than using it as merely a storehouse of facts most of which are useless.
Good Luck!!
amit
(sddsfd)
(116 Points)
Replied 03 May 2013
Dear all
Einstein is asking, to go for commerce or science. You go nowhere but become scientist
Murugesh
(CA Final, M.Com)
(37 Points)
Replied 05 May 2013
@ Eienstein I understand your frustration with section numbers 
It is because you are yet to get practical knowledge which you will gain in article training. In school, didn't you number your points while answering questions? Section numbers are nothing but numbering the paragraphs in an Act and you are not required to remember all sections to write exams. Section numbers help to study and understand an Act. If there are no section numbers how can you know whether a particular provision is stated in the Act? You can't go through the whole act for everything. Also while arguing a case section numbers are essential to prove the existence of a provision in the Act.
As for logic in commerce, they are only procedures and interpretations of law. They are given for uniformity. It is for the same reason you have to follow uniform rules for debit and credit in accounts. But I accept that you have to remember the provisions but for a person like you who can understand complex science logics it won't be that difficult and I wish you all the best for your exams
Deepanshi Jain
(student)
(16 Points)
Replied 18 November 2016
Hello Dear, if tyou think you are good in Science stream then i suggest you to reseacrh and became a sciientist. Do something for India. Go for the CSIR NET Exam. World best exam for the science aspirants. next CSIR exam will be in month of jan. Read all the CSIR Notification here
Jagjeet Singh
(k)
(4 Points)
Replied 08 January 2021
List of courses after 12th - https://www.thetechlearn.com/courses-after-12th-commerce/
Download commerce video from Facebook - Facebook video download
Jagjeet Singh
(k)
(4 Points)
Replied 27 October 2021
After reading some answers of my fellow quorans,I would like to clear one thing that both science and commerce have ample opportunities and no field is inferior or superior to the other.
GST Live Certification Course (39th Batch) - April 2024 (Weekend Batch) (With Certificate)
"Live class on Python for Financial Analysis: Unlocking Efficiency in Accounting and Finance"
CAclubindia
