Every body has a right to speak and express , so does i .........

other views are also welcomed ...

Sorry to say Amit......It is IDOL not IDLE.......

Meaning will change.....

hi amit,

can u be specific of what you are saying. what made you to make such a comment. any practical instances........?

I agree to an extent..........

you can see the quality of forum messages are dropping day by day.

Originally posted by : Rock
	Sorry to say Amit......It is IDOL not IDLE....... Meaning will change.....

 Ok

Thanks !!!!

i have made changes now .

You can also express your view about the concept of indian idol !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I were new & beginner to CACLUB INDIA.COM....

I have to experience some more days to comment on this..

But according to me, many things are outside the topic & views.

SEE.... MY VIEW IS TOTALLY DIFFERENT, THE AMOUNT OF HELP YOUR SENIORS CAN GIVE YOU, NOBODY ELSE CAN.....

A CA WHO COMPLETED THE COURSE 5 YEARS AGO MIGHT HAVE LOST THE TOUCH BUT A STUDENT WHO CLEARED THE LAST ATTEMPT MIGHT GUIDE MORE EFFICIENTLY TO A NEWCOMER....

BUT

FOR ADVANCED MATTERS LIKE IMPLICATIONS OF IFRS, AMMENDMENTS IN TAX, CHANGE IN CREDIT POLICY, CHANGES DUE TO ECONOMIC DOWNFALL ETC, REQUIRES PERSONS WHO ARE PRACTISING AS CA OR CS.ALSO PEOPLE WHO ARE IN JOB PROVIDE A GREAT HELPING HAND TO OTHERS......

CONCLUSION

It is an alarming concern  but only for people who already are pursuing the last leg of their academic CAREERS.

Those who have 4 years to go, might feel Okay with it!!!!

Hi Amit... U R RIGHT...

this should be CAstudentsCLUBINDIA..... :) cos i ain't qualified to be in the CAclub......

Members leaving is not bad sign really, it means that they have less free time now.

I don't agree with the issue raised by you. 

Because of open forum allowed in caclubindia; you can write whatever you want. Due to one of this reason it is popular. Otherwise the moment you wrote; it could be easily deleted. But moderators are generous enough that they don't delete  it till they decide that it is abusing someone personally.

Do you know for whom you are asking ? How one can compare the work of Indian Idol Team with Caclubindia Team ? I know how Anu Malik comments. He doesn't care the respect of the person who is standing before him. Have you heard any abuse from the moderators like this?  

Almost every type of material is available at the site which is useful for the students and members.

If someone visits only at forums; then it means he likes it. What is wrong in that? If one don't wish to refer humour section; why one should comment on humour that it is not required? The "system" is such in the site that you can easily ignore it.  

Still I am in favour of upgradation of the material published in caclubindia. But what I think that "theme" is important than only "language."  To the best of my knowledge; the moderators take care of theme only and not the language. If they were more cautious about language; very few persons would be able to interact.

Please  don't compare caclub with others. It is altogether different.

One cannot compare a TV show with CACLUBINDIA.

In Indian Idol; judges are paid whereas in caclubindia; many come here just to share their knowledge or problems - absolutely free.

What more one can expect when whatever is available is free altogether ?