Ca final certified copies

Final 1292 views 14 replies
I got my certified copies of ca final accounts paper may 2014. They have given me only 8 marks out of 16 for sum of consolidation because i have solved it by direct method. The suggested answers have solved it by indirect method. Otherwise my whole sum is correct. What should i do? And i need only 7 marks to clear 1st group. Plz reply
Replies (14)
Same situation bro but i have not recieved my certified copy yet....when you apply for certified copy?
Same case here bro same marks same result
I applied on 11th august
And let me know what marks u got in consolidation sum when u get ur copies
Ok bro...i applied on 12th

WHEN DID U APPLIED FOR CERTIFIED COPIES I.E. AT WHICH TIME & HOW MANY SUBJECTS DID U APPLIED.

Hey can u tell us the checking criteria after seeing the fr copy....or can you show us the copy?copies are in soft or hard copy is provided by institute?....i need the help
I compared it with suggested answers. And its quite clear they have cut marks because figures of cost of control and minority interest are not the same as suggested answer because i have solved it by direct method.
I compared it with suggested answers. And its quite clear they have cut marks because figures of cost of control and minority interest are not the same as suggested answer because i have solved it by direct method. And i have received soft copies and sorry i cant show u.
Got full marks in it :)
Originally posted by : a_naik
I compared it with suggested answers. And its quite clear they have cut marks because figures of cost of control and minority interest are not the same as suggested answer because i have solved it by direct method. And i have received soft copies and sorry i cant show u.

Well I had done some research on it which I am sharing now

at page 5.35 of financial reporting module it is clearly mentioned that there are two methods, direct or indirect...and it has now where mentioned in module where to use direct/indirect so wat I feel is at we have to use it as per our discretion

In may 2014 financial repoting paper, question of holding not demanding for solving it by indirect method

The writer of  suggested answer arbritrally choosed indirect method

I also checked the RTP for nov 2014 the question of holding has solved by using direct method

I mailed BOS, that which method is to be used and when, waiting for their reply

Wat I would suggest you to file writ petition because ICAI is also not cleared about this matter

 

Hey piyush what is your marks in fr?and when u applied for certified copy?

@ a_naik: Nothing you can do bro... paper can not be re-evaluated as per ICAI regulations. Hard Luck... 

Aman i jus scored 42 in it.....but the holding question saved me..gt thru wid da group.just applied n da 1st day.


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register