CA examinees can see answersheet’

Others 1615 views 16 replies

CIC TO RESCUE

Mumbai: This news is bound to cheer all the chartered accountancy students who have been wanting to get a copy of their answersheets after they appeared for the exams.
    The Central Information Commission, (CIC), in a landmark order, has directed The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) to provide a copy of the evaluated answersheet to Vikita V Soni, a candidate who had appeared for the final CA examination. In its order, the commission said that an examinee had the right to access the evaluated answersheets for “self-assessing her performance’’. The case came up for hearing before the com
mission after Soni, a Khetwadi resident, filed an RTI query in March seeking a copy of her evaluated answersheet. Soni said she was expecting her name in the toppers’ list, she was shocked to know that she had failed.
    Soni then approached Tarun Mitral Mandal, an

NGO, to assist her in filing an RTI query. “She approached us and we helped her in filing the query,’’ said NGO convener Rajen Dharod. Though the query was filed in January, the public information officer of ICAI rejected the query stating, “According to institute rules, this query doesn’t come under RTI ambit.”

 
 
Replies (16)

Very good ... Now dudh ka dudh our pani ka pani najar ayega... No one can blaim ICAI or Examiner....

Very good ... Now dudh ka dudh our pani ka pani najar ayega... No one can blaim ICAI or Examiner....

hi, i would I would like to ask whether this is case to case basis i.e. we have to follow the procedure all the time or the benefit is now available to all the student, as like in many landmark judgment happens.  Means they become the law from that time.

 

Wht abt the decision passed by High Court

 

I think it is case to case basis.... Its not practical for giving answer sheet copies to all the students. Even the State Boards and CBSE don't do that.  I was wondering what is the system in US and UK for papers of CPA & ACCA.

They could perhaps just tell us marks given per question on email or something. That would suffice too i believe!!

 

 i think that it is not pratical for the institute to veiw the answer sheet to all students. 

and it is not in good pratice for students also becoz now then institute becoz more tight regarding their rules. 

pahele hi kam musibat hai ke aur apne upar le rahe ho. sirf students ka hi nuksaan hoga

It's seems be difficult. But, I think ICAI have easiest way for show the answer sheet to examine, well wait for another notification about on same. I read this article in newspaper (Times of India) so, I share it here.

so we can see the answers sheets after the exams....could clarify of this one pls

Thanks for ur information can you please let me know the date when this case is decided on CIC website no such case is there, and wat about Highcourt ruling

This news comes from Times of India - Page No : 7. I am depicting the link for ur convenience.

https://epaper.timesofindia.com/Default/Client.asp?showST=true&login=default&Enter=true&Skin=TOINEW&GZ=T&Daily=CAP&AW=1247907285484

 

wow..what a case.....

i think we should wait for some more time to get much more information or clarification.

ICAI should bring in transparency in its evaluation process on its own. Judgement is welcome.

is this the final verdict of icai?????????????

 


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register