In a recent legal victory, renowned actor D. Sivakarthikeyan has successfully secured a refund of ₹12.60 lakh from the Income Tax department. The resolution comes after a writ petition filed by the actor in 2022 was disposed of by the Madras High Court, which recorded the Income Tax Department's submission that the disputed amount had been duly deposited in the actor's bank account.
Background and Legal Proceedings
- Written Agreement with Aadnah Arts: Sivakarthikeyan's affidavit detailed a written agreement made with Aadnah Arts, represented by sole proprietor K.E. Gnanavelraja, on July 6, 2018. The agreement stipulated a total consideration of ₹15 crore for the actor's performance in the male lead role in a movie, inclusive of Goods and Services Tax (GST).
- Remuneration Structure: According to the agreement, Sivakarthikeyan's remuneration was structured as follows: ₹2 crore before signing, ₹1 crore before shooting commencement, ₹7 crore during 70 days of the call sheet at ₹1 crore every 10 days of shooting, ₹2 crore before completion of dubbing, ₹2 crore before audio release, and the final ₹1 crore before theatrical release. The producer agreed to pay GST and remit TDS to the Income Tax Department.
- TDS Mismatch and Recovery: In the assessment years 2019-20 and 2020-21, TDS mismatches of ₹65.50 lakh and ₹1.11 lakh, respectively, were identified due to the producer's failure to remit the TDS. This led to the Income Tax Department recovering ₹91.16 lakh from Sivakarthikeyan's bank account in February 2022.
- Legal Intervention and Resolution: Seeking a refund, Sivakarthikeyan filed a writ petition, alleging non-remittance by the producer. However, the issue was resolved amicably between the parties before the case reached adjudication, with the producer remitting all necessary payments.
- Court's Decision and Refund: The case came before Justice Krishnan Ramasamy in December 2023, where it was reported that the Income Tax Department agreed to refund ₹12.60 lakh with interest. Subsequently, the said amount was deposited into Sivakarthikeyan's bank account.
Conclusion
D. Sivakarthikeyan's legal triumph not only highlights the intricacies involved in financial agreements within the entertainment industry but also underscores the actor's commitment to seeking justice. The resolution of the TDS discrepancy and the subsequent refund from the Income Tax Department mark a favorable conclusion to this chapter, further emphasizing the importance of adherence to financial obligations in the realm of show business.
CAclubindia
