Payment of GST Penalty "Under Protest" for release of goods - Mandatory Requirement of Speaking Order under Section 129(3)


Quick Summary
The Punjab and Haryana High Court has ruled that simply paying a GST penalty "under protest" does not automatically end proceedings. The Proper Officer must still issue a reasoned "speaking order" after considering the assessee's objections. This decision ensures that taxpayers are given a fair hearing and that decisions are not made prematurely, even when goods are released upon payment.

Court :
Punjab & Haryana High Court

Brief :
The Hon'ble Punjab and Haryana High Court in the case of M/s Deutsche Cars Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Haryana and Others [CWP-21628 of 2025, order dated January 31, 2026] held that mere payment of penalty under protest does not conclude proceedings under Section 129(5) of the GST Act, and the Proper Officer is mandatorily required to pass a reasoned order after considering the reply of the assessee.

Citation :
CWP-21628 of 2025, order dated January 31, 2026

Daily Limit Reached

You have reached your daily limit of 2 Free Judgements

Subscribe to CCI PRO for unlimited access

Why Upgrade to CCI PRO?
  • No Ads
  • WhatsApp Community
  • Daily E-Newsletter
  • Unlimited Judgements Access
  • Profile Visitors
  • Link Social Profiles
  • Featured Job Posts
  • Pro Badge
  • Expert GST Guidance
  • Unlimited Forum Replies
  • Download Content in PDF
1 Year PLAN
1999
(Excl. of GST ₹359)

2 Years PLAN
3499
(Excl. of GST ₹629)

BEST VALUE
3 Years PLAN
4999
(Excl. of GST ₹899)

View all CCI PRO benefits

Already a PRO member? Login here for an ad-free experience. 07941056694

 



Judgement posted by

Service

FCA, FCS LLB with21 Yrs of Experience inTaxation Indirect and Direct: Education Qualification: B.Com (Hons) Chartered Accountants Company Secretary LLB Qualified SAP FI/CO Consultants Professional Membership: Chairmanof Indirect Tax Committee of PHD Chamber of Commerce Member of Indirec ... Read more

Comments




CCI Pro



Company
ARTICLESHIP 14 November 2026
Article Assistant

Jitendra Agarwal & Associates

Bengaluru

CA Inter

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 23 October 2026
Articled Trainee

J Y & CO

Hyderabad

CA Inter

View Details
Company
Featured 07 November 2026
Chartered Accountant

DPV & Associates

Chennai

CA

View Details
Company
10 November 2026
FP&A Executive

Gujarat Guardian

Ankleshwar

CA Final

View Details
Company
23 October 2026
Sr. Accountant

SANKARAN & KRISHNAN

New Delhi

B.Com

View Details
Company
31 October 2026
Accountants

sankaran and krishnan

New Delhi

B.Com

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 25 October 2026
Article Intern (CA Articleship)

Arpan Bohra & Co

Hyderabad

CA Inter

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 16 November 2026
Audit Executives

Loonker Godawat And Company

Bengaluru

B.Com

View Details