Customs: High Court must call for statement from Tribunal before deciding application under Section 130A - SC


Quick Summary
The Supreme Court has clarified that under Section 130A of the Customs Act, a High Court is not automatically required to call for a statement from the Customs Tribunal before deciding an application for a reference. The Court found that the wording of Section 130A(4), beginning with 'if', indicates that the High Court has discretion in each case whether to request a statement. Consequently, a previous judgment suggesting a mandatory requirement was overruled.

Court :
Supreme Court of India

Brief :
The question referred to a three-judge bench concerned the procedure under Section 130A of the Customs Act, as it then stood, for applications to the High Court seeking a direction to the Appellate Tribunal to refer a question of law. The Supreme Court held that the provision first mandatorily obliges the High Court to call for a statement of the case from the Tribunal before deciding any such application, and the High Court cannot decide the question of law directly without doing so. An earlier decision in Commissioner of Customs, Bangalore taking a contrary view was held to be incorrect and was overruled. The question was answered accordingly and the appeals disposed of.

Citation :
Civil Appeal No. 6021/2009 dated February 11, 2020

1

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO. 6021 OF 2009

COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE, GOA Appellant(s)

VERSUS

M/S ADANI EXPORTS LTD. Respondent(s)

WITH

C.A. Nos. 6072-6073/2009

J U D G M E N T

R.F. Nariman, J.

1) Having heard Mr. K. Radhakrishnan, learned Senior

Counsel appearing on behalf of the Revenue for sometime and after perusing the reference order to a larger Bench dated

14.03.2018, it is first necessary to set out Section 130A(1)

& (4) of the Customs Act.

“130A. Application to High Court.- (1) The

Commissioner of Customs or the other party may, within one hundred and eighty days of the date upon which he is served with notice of an order under section 129B passed before the 1st day of July, 2003

(not being an order relating, among other things, to the determination of any question having a relation to the rate of duty of customs or to the value of goods for purposes of assessment), by application in the prescribed form, accompanied, where the application is made by the other party, by a fee of two hundred rupees, apply to the High

Court to direct the Appellate Tribunal to refer to the High Court any question of law arising from such order of the Tribunal.”

(4) If, on an application made under sub-Section

(1), the High Court directs the Appellate Tribunal

2 to refer the question of law raised in the application, the Appellate Tribunal shall, within one hundred and twenty days of the receipt of such direction, draw up a statement of the case and refer it to the High Court.”

2) Mr. K. Radhakrishnan referred to an order of 2 learned

Judges of this Court in Commissioner of Customs, Bangalore v. Central Manufacturing Tech. Institute reported in 2002

(146) ELT 27 which reads as under:

“1. Leave granted. The High Court rejected an application for reference of the question of law arising from the order of CEGAT and the High Court agreed with the view taken by the Tribunal and disposed of the matter stating that the question of law does not arise from the order of CEGAT. That was not the stage at which the High Court could have expressed its views on merits of the matter and the appropriate course for the High Court was to call for a statement and then decide the matter in an appropriate manner as provided under the law.

2. In that view of the matter, we set aside the order made by the High Court and remit the matter to the High Court for fresh examination. The appeal is allowed accordingly.”

We do not find anything in the text of Section 130A which implies that the High Court is mandatorily required to call for a statement from the Tribunal in every case, where a reference is made. We say so because of the language of

Sub-Section 4 which opens with an ‘if’.

3) A reading of Section 130A (1) & (4) would make it clear that if the Commissioner of Customs or other party within the prescribed period of limitation applies in the prescribed form to the High Court to direct the Appellate

Tribunal to refer to the High Court any question of law arising from such order of the Tribunal, the High Court may

3 do so. What is clear on a reading of sub-section (4) is that the High Court has a discretion on the facts of each case either to do so or not to do so. This becomes absolutely plain from the first word in sub-section (4), namely, “if”. We find nothing in the language of Section

130A which first mandatorily obliges the High Court to call for a statement from the Tribunal before deciding any such application. The judgment in Commissioner of Customs,

Bangalore (supra) being incorrect is therefore overruled.

4) The question is answered accordingly and the appeals stand disposed of.

.......................... J.

(ROHINTON FALI NARIMAN)

.......................... J.

(S. RAVINDRA BHAT)

.......................... J.

(V. RAMASUBRAMANIAN)

New Delhi;

February 11, 2020.

FAQ :

Section 130A of the Customs Act deals with applications made to the High Court to direct the Appellate Tribunal to refer a question of law arising from the Tribunal's order to the High Court.

No, the Supreme Court has ruled that the High Court is not mandatorily required to call for a statement from the Tribunal before deciding an application under Section 130A. The Court has discretion in this matter.

The Supreme Court highlighted that the word 'if' at the beginning of Section 130A(4) signifies that the High Court has discretion on whether to direct the Tribunal to refer a question of law.

A previous judgment had suggested that the High Court was obligated to call for a statement from the Tribunal in every case where a reference application was made. This view has now been overruled.

The Commissioner of Customs or the other party involved in the case can apply to the High Court under Section 130A.

 



Judgement posted by

Guest

Comments




CCI Pro



Company
ARTICLESHIP 14 November 2026
Article Assistant

Jitendra Agarwal & Associates

Bengaluru

CA Inter

View Details
Company
Featured ARTICLESHIP 17 November 2026
Associate/ Article Trainee

M/s. A V C & Co.

New Delhi

CA Inter

View Details
Company
13 November 2026
Chartered Accountant - Fresher

Neeraj Bhagat & Co

New Delhi

CA

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 23 October 2026
CA Articleship / Article Assistant

M N Rao & Associates LLP

Vijayawada

CA Inter

View Details
Company
13 November 2026
Accountant

New Mobile India

Muzaffarpur

B.Com

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 18 November 2026
Articled Assistant

A.Singhi & Co

Kolkata

CA Inter

View Details
Company
Featured ARTICLESHIP 18 November 2026
Articles

Saini Pati Shah & Co LLP, Chartered Accountants

Mumbai

CA Foundation

View Details
Company
19 November 2026
Accounts & Taxation Executive

MCSR and Associates LLP

Hyderabad

CA Inter

View Details