CST: Rajasthan rule allowing cancellation of validly issued Form C declarations is ultra vires - Supreme Court


Quick Summary
The Supreme Court has ruled that a specific rule in Rajasthan allowing the cancellation of validly issued Form C declarations is invalid. The Court found that the State of Rajasthan exceeded its rule-making powers under the Central Sales Tax Act. Consequently, the cancellation of these declarations, even in cases of suspected misrepresentation or fraud, is not permissible under the existing legal framework.

Court :
Supreme Court of India

Brief :
A dealer made inter-State sales against Form C declarations in 2017-18. When inspection found the buyers were not functioning at their places of business, the authorities sought to cancel the Form C declarations under Rule 17(20) of the Rajasthan CST Rules. The High Court held that the State had no power to frame a rule for cancelling validly issued declarations. The Supreme Court agreed: matters about declarations fall under rules framed by the Central Government under Section 13(1)(d) of the Central Sales Tax Act, and State rules cannot be inconsistent with them. Rule 17(20) was inconsistent with the Central Registration Rules, so the High Court's view was upheld and the State's appeal dismissed.

Citation :
Civil Appeal No. 1208/2025 dated April 16, 2025

2025 INSC 496Civil Appeal No.1208 of 2025

Reportable

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO. 1208 OF 2025

STATE OF RAJASTHAN & ORS. … APPELLANT(S)

versus

COMBINED TRADERS … RESPONDENT(S)

J U D G M E N T

ABHAY S. OKA, J.

1. The first appellant is the State of Rajasthan. A writ petition was filed before the High Court of Judicature for

Rajasthan by the respondent-Combined Traders invoking jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 226 of the

Constitution of India for challenging the validity of sub-rule (20) of rule 17 of the Central Sales Tax (Rajasthan)

Rules, 1957 (for short, ‘the Rajasthan Rules’). Sub-rule

(20) of Rule 17 was incorporated by way of an amendment with effect from 14th July 2014. Sub-rule (20) of Rule 17 provided that where any dealer had generated declaration forms or certificates by misrepresentation of fact or by fraud or in contravention of the provisions of the Central

Sales Tax Act, 1956 (for short, ‘the CST Act’) and rules

Civil Appeal No.1208 of 2025 made thereunder, the assessing authority or any other authority authorised by the Commissioner after affording such dealer an opportunity of being heard, is empowered to cancel such declaration forms or certificates. By the impugned judgment, the High Court held that the first appellant-State had no rule-making power to frame a rule providing for the cancellation of validly issued declarations/forms. The High Court held that sub-rule

(20) of Rule 17 of the Rajasthan Rules was ultra vires

Sections 8(4), 13(1)(d), 13(3) and 13(4)(e) of the CST Act.

2. During 2017-18, the respondent sold certain goods to M/s. H.G. International and M/s. Saraswati Enterprises

(originally respondent Nos.2 and 3, whose names were deleted from the array of parties) against Form C amounting to Rs. 4.89 crores and Rs. 7.20 crores respectively. Goods were sold in the first quarter of the year 2017-18.

3. The revenue authorities inspected the places of business of M/s. H.G. International and M/s. Saraswati

Enterprises. On inspection, it was revealed that no business activity was carried out at the places and registration of M/s. H.G. International and M/s. Saraswati

Enterprises was completely bogus. Notices were issued to the respondent for the cancellation of Form C. To claim reduced rates of taxes as per Section 8(1) of the CST Act,

Civil Appeal No.1208 of 2025 the respondent had furnished Form C as required by

Section 8(4) of the CST Act. A single Form C is required to be submitted for a quarter as provided in the second proviso to sub-rule (1) of Rule 12 of the Central Sales Tax

(Registration and Turnover) Rules, 1957 (for short, ‘the

Central Registration Rules’).

4. M/s. H.G. International and M/s. Saraswati

Enterprises obtained Form C online on 6th July 2017. The respondent claimed a refund in the return filed on 11th

July 2017 for the first quarter of 2017-2018 under the

Delhi Value Added Tax Act, 2004 (for short, ‘the Delhi VAT

Act’). The refund was not given within two months of the return filing date. Therefore, the respondent filed a writ petition before the Delhi High Court. By the order dated

18th September 2017, the Delhi High Court directed the authorities in Delhi to refund the amount along with due interest.

5. By separate orders dated 7th December 2017, the third appellant cancelled the declaration forms of M/s.

H.G. International and M/s. Saraswati Enterprises on the ground that they were not found functioning at their respective business premises. The declaration forms were cancelled, exercising power under sub-rule (20) of Rule 17 of the Rajasthan Rules read with Sections 48 and 16(4) of the Rajasthan Value Added Tax Act, 2003. Even the

Civil Appeal No.1208 of 2025 registration certificates of the said firms were cancelled.

Before the said order, the third appellant issued letters dated 20th and 30th November 2017 to VATO Ward-17, New

Delhi, informing about the cancellation of Form C of the two entities. The respondent filed a writ petition before the High Court of Rajasthan, Bench at Jaipur. As stated earlier, the first prayer was for declaring sub-rule (20) of Rule 17 of the Rajasthan Rules as ultra vires Sections 8(4), 13(1)(d), 13(3) and 13(4)(e) of the CST Act. Consequential prayers were made for challenging the order dated 7th

December 2017 and the communications of 20th and 30th

November 2017. Other consequential reliefs were also prayed for.

SUBMISSIONS

6. The learned senior counsel appearing for the appellants has taken us through the relevant provisions of the CST Act and the Rajasthan Rules. The learned senior counsel invited our attention to the rule-making power conferred by Section 13 (3) of the CST Act. He pointed out that the general rule-making power has been conferred on the State Government to make rules which are not inconsistent with the provisions of the CST Act and the rules made by the Central Government under Section

13(1) thereof. He submitted that sub-rule (20) of Rule 17 of the Rajasthan Rules is not inconsistent with the

Civil Appeal No.1208 of 2025 provisions of the CST Act. He submitted that sub-rule (20)

of Rule 17 has been enacted to prevent fraud and contravention of the provisions of the CST Act and rules made thereunder. He submitted that sub-section (3) of

Section 13 of the CST Act confers a power on the State

Government to make rules to carry out the purposes of the

CST Act. Rule-making power can be exercised under sub-section (3) of Section 13 to check evasion. He submitted that the activity of preventing evasion is for carrying out the purposes of the CST Act.

7. The learned counsel invited our attention to the separate orders dated 7th December 2017 passed by the

Commercial Tax Officer of the first appellant-State

Government, by which Forms C issued to M/s. H.G.

International and M/s. Saraswati Enterprises were cancelled and consequently, their registration certificates were also cancelled. He pointed out that a finding was recorded that on inspection of the premises of M/s. H.G.

International and M/s. Saraswati Enterprises, it was found that no commercial activity or business was being carried out. Therefore, it was observed that the commercial activity of M/s. H.G. International and M/s.

Saraswati Enterprises was doubtful. M/s. H.G.

International and M/s. Saraswati Enterprises did not appear notwithstanding service of notice. Therefore, on the ground of pleading false facts, the declaration forms

Civil Appeal No.1208 of 2025

(Form C) were ordered to be cancelled. He submitted that there is no inconsistency between sub-rule (20) of Rule 17 of the Rajasthan Rules and any of the provisions of the

CST Act or the rules framed thereunder by the Central

Government.

8. The learned counsel appearing for the respondent invited our attention to Section 13 of the CST Act. He pointed out that the rule-making power under clause (d) of sub-section (1) of Section 13 has been conferred on the

Central Government, providing for prescribing a form setting out all the particulars to be contained in any declaration or certificate to be given under the CST Act.

He submitted that clause (d) does not confer any power on the Central Government to make rules to cancel any declaration or certificate under the CST Act. In any event, no such rules have been framed by the Central

Government. Inviting our attention to sub-section (4) of

Section 13, he submitted that none of the clauses (a) to (g)

confer any power on the State Government to frame rules, providing for cancellation of declarations and certificates under the CST Act. He invited our attention to Section 8

(1) of the CST Act, which provides for a dealer selling the goods, furnishing to the prescribed authority, a declaration duly filled and signed by a registered dealer to whom the goods are sold. He submitted that Section 8 does not provide for cancellation of the declaration. He

Civil Appeal No.1208 of 2025 invited our attention to Section 7 of the CST Act, which provides for registration of dealers. He pointed out that sub-section (5) of Section 7 specifically confers a power on the authority to cancel the registration certificate. Such provision is absent in Section 8 of the CST Act.

9. The learned counsel submitted that sub-rule (20) of

Rule 17 is a standalone rule which was introduced on 14th

July 2014 after a gap of 57 years from the date on which the CST Act came into force. He submitted that no other

State has made any such rule. He relied upon a decision of the Delhi High Court in the case of Jain Manufacturing

(India) Pvt Ltd v. Commissioner of Value Added Tax &

Anr1. In this case, the Commissioner under the Delhi VAT

Act had cancelled Form C. He pointed out that the counsel appearing for the Commissioner stated that there was no provision in the CST Act for cancellation of Form C. He submitted that the special leave petition preferred against the decision was dismissed on the ground of low tax effect.

10. The learned counsel relied upon a decision of this

Court in the case of Sales Tax Officer, Ponkunnam &

Anr. v. K.I. Abraham2. He also relied upon another decision of this Court in the case of The State of Madras v. R Nand Lal & Co3. He would therefore submit that the

1 (2016) (93) VST (326) (Delhi) : 2016 SCC OnLine Del 3656

2 (1967) (20) STC 367 (SC) : 1967 SCC OnLine SC 157

3 (1967) (20) STC 374 (SC) : 1968 SCC OnLine SC 142

Civil Appeal No.1208 of 2025 view taken by the High Court of Rajasthan in the impugned judgment is correct.

CONSIDERATION OF SUBMISSIONS

11. Firstly, we must advert to Section 8 of the CST Act.

Sub-sections (1) and (4) of Section 8 as it stood at the relevant time, read thus:

“8. Rates of tax on sales in the course of inter-State trade or commerce- (1)

Every dealer, who in the course of inter-State trade or commerce-

(a) sells to the Government any goods; or

(b) sells to a registered dealer other than the Government goods of the description referred to in sub-section

(3), shall be liable to pay tax under this Act, with effect from such date as may be notified by the Central Government in the

Official Gazette for the purpose, which shall be two per cent of this turnover or at the rate applicable to the sale or purchase of such goods inside the appropriate State under the sales tax law of that State, or, as the case may be, under any enactment of that State imposing value added tax, whichever is lower:

Provided that the rate of tax payable under this sub-section by a dealer shall continue to be four per cent of his turnover, until the rate of two per cent, takes effect under this sub-section.”

Civil Appeal No.1208 of 2025

.. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. ..

(4) The provisions of sub-section (1)

shall not apply to any sale in the course of inter-State trade or commerce unless the dealer selling the goods furnishes to the prescribed authority in the prescribed manner-

(a) a declaration duly filled and signed by the registered dealer to whom the goods are sold containing the prescribed particulars in a prescribed form obtained from the prescribed authority; or

(b) if the goods are sold to the

Government, not being a registered dealer, a certificate in the prescribed form duly filled and signed by a duly authorised officer of the Government:

Provided that the declaration referred to in clause (a) is furnished within the prescribed time or within such further time as that authority may, for sufficient cause, permit.”

(emphasis added)

11.1. Sub-section (1) of Section 8 provides that, a dealer who in the course of inter-State trade or commerce sells goods of the description provided under sub-section

(3) to a registered dealer, shall be liable to pay tax which shall be 2 % of his turnover or at the rate applicable to the sale and purchase of such goods inside the appropriate

State under the sales tax law of that State, whichever is

Civil Appeal No.1208 of 2025 lower. In view of sub-section (4) of Section 8, the condition precedent for applicability of sub-section (1) is that the dealer selling the goods in the course of inter-State trade or commerce must furnish to the prescribed authority in the prescribed manner a declaration duly filled containing the prescribed particulars in a prescribed form obtained from the prescribed authority and signed by the registered dealer to whom the goods are sold.

12. The word “prescribed” means prescribed by the rules.

Under sub-section (1) of Section 13, the rule making power has been conferred on the Central Government providing for what is set out in clauses (a) to (g) of Section 13(1).

Clause (d) of Section 13(1) thereof is material, which reads thus:

“13. Power to make rules-

(1) The Central Government may, by notification in the Official Gazette, make rules providing for –

.. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. ..

(d) the form in which and the particulars to be contained in any declaration or certificate to be given under this Act the State of origin of such form or certificate and the time within which any such certificate or declaration shall be produced or furnished;”

(emphasis added)

Civil Appeal No.1208 of 2025

12.1. Thus, the Central Government has the rule-making power to prescribe the form of declaration and lay down particulars to be contained in any declaration.

Therefore, the form of declaration under Section 8(4) and the contents thereof are to be provided by the rules framed by the Central Government in accordance with Section

13(1)(d) of the CST Act.

13. Now, we come to sub-sections (3) and (4) of Section

13 of the CST Act, which read thus:

“13. Power to make rules-

.. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .

(3) The State Government may make rules, not inconsistent with the provisions of this Act and the rules made under sub-section (1), to carry out the purpose of this Act.

(4) In particular and without prejudice to the powers conferred by sub-section (3), the State Government may make rules for all or any of the following purposes, namely:-

(a) the publication of lists of registered dealers, of the amendments made in such lists from time to time, and the particulars to be contained in such lists;

(aa) the manner in which security may be furnished under sub-section (2A) or sub-section (3A) or sub-section (3C) of section 7 and the manner in which and the time within which any deficiency may be made up under sub-section (3E) of that section;

Civil Appeal No.1208 of 2025

(b) the form and manner in which accounts relating to sales in the course of inter-State trade or commerce shall be kept by registered dealers;

(c) the furnishing of any information relating to the stocks of goods of purchases, sales and deliveries of books by, any dealer or any other information relating to his business as may be necessary for the purposes of this Act;

(d) the inspection of any books, accounts or documents required to be kept under this Act, the entry into any premises at all reasonable times for the purposes of searching for any such books, accounts or documents kept or suspected to be kept in such premises and the seizure of such books, accounts or documents;

(e) the authority from whom, the conditions subject to which and fees subject to payment of which any form of certificate prescribed under clause (a) of the first proviso to sub-section (2) of section 6 or of declaration prescribed under sub-section (1) of section 6A or subsection (4) of section 8 may be obtained, the manner in which such forms shall be kept in custody and records relating thereto maintained and the manner in which any such form may be used and any such certificate or declaration may be furnished;

(ee) the form and manner in which, and the authority to whom, an appeal may be preferred under sub-section (3H) of section 7, the procedure to be followed in

Civil Appeal No.1208 of 2025 hearing such appeals and the fees payable in respect of such appeals;

(f) in the case of an Undivided Hindu

Family, association, club, society, firm or company or in the case of a person who carries on business as a guardian or trustee or otherwise on behalf of another person, the furnishing of a declaration stating the name of the person who shall be deemed to be the manager in relation to the business of the dealer in the State and the form in which such declaration may be given;

(g) the time within which, the manner in which and the authorities to whom any change in the ownership of any business or in the name, place or nature of any business carried on by any dealer shall be furnished.”

(emphasis added)

13.1. On the face of it, none of the clauses (a) to (j) of sub-section (4) empower the State Government to frame rules providing for cancellation of declarations or forms furnished as per the rules framed by the Central

Government in accordance with clause (d) of sub-section

(1) of Section 13 of the CST Act.

14. In exercise of the rule-making power under clause (d)

of sub-section (1) of Section 13, the Central Registration

Rules have been framed. Rule 12(1) provides that the declaration referred to in sub-section (4) of Section 8 of the CST Act shall be in Form C prescribed thereunder.

Civil Appeal No.1208 of 2025

Therefore, the Central Registration Rules have laid down the form of declaration referred to in Section 8(4). A perusal of the Central Registration Rules shows that no power is conferred on any authority to cancel the declaration in Form C. Thus, the rules which prescribe the form of declaration in terms of Section 8(4), do not provide for cancellation of the declaration on the ground that commercial activities were not found at the address mentioned in the declaration. There is no provision in the

Central Registration Rules to cancel the declaration in

Form C. In contrast, the Central Registration Rules provide for cancellation of the certificate of registration for giving effect to sub-section (5) of Section 7 of the CST Act.

15. Now, coming back to sub-sections (3) and (4) of

Section 13, the rule-making power conferred on the State

Government under sub-section (4) is for any or all of the specific purposes laid down in clauses (a) to (j). As stated earlier, none of these clauses provide for making a rule to enable the authorities to cancel a declaration in Form C. It is true that under sub-section (3) of Section 13, the State

Government has power to frame rules to carry out purposes of the CST Act. However, power of sub-section

(3) is circumscribed by its first part which provides that the rules made to carry out the purposes of the CST Act should not be inconsistent with the provisions of the CST

Civil Appeal No.1208 of 2025

Act and the rules made by the Central Government in exercise of powers under Section 13(1) of the CST Act.

16. A specific rule-making power under clause (d) of sub-section (1) of Section 13 has been exercised by the Central Government by framing the Central Registration Rules laying down the form of declaration (Form C) required to be furnished in terms of sub-section (4) of Section 8. As stated earlier, the Central Registration Rules do not vest power in any authority to cancel the declaration in Form

C. Therefore, if the State Government exercises the rule-making power under sub-section (3) of Section 13 by making rules providing for cancellation of a declaration in

Form C as provided in Central Registration Rules, the

State Rules will be inconsistent with the Central

Registration Rules framed by the Central Government in exercise of power under Section 13(1)(d) of the CST Act.

The State Government cannot frame rules in exercise of power under Section 13(3) which will be inconsistent with the rules framed by the Central Government in exercise of powers under Section 13(1) of the CST Act.

17. The respondent relied upon the decision of this Court in the case of R. Nand Lal & Co3. In the facts of this case, the assessing authority declined to assess the turnover as prescribed by sub-section (1) of Section 8 of the CST Act on the ground that the declaration in Form C covered two

Civil Appeal No.1208 of 2025 or three transactions contrary to the first proviso to Rule

10(1) of the Rules framed by the State Government under the CST Act. This Court, in the said decision, while dealing with the rule-making power of the State under Section 13, held thus:

“.. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. ..

We are constrained to observe that the rule-making authorities have failed to appreciate the scheme of Section 13 of the

Central Sales Tax Act. We are of the opinion that it was not within the competence of the State authorities under Section 13(3) and (4) of the

Central Sales Tax Act to provide that a single declaration covering more than one transaction shall not be made.

Authority to prescribe such an injunction cannot have its source in

Section 13(3) or Section 13(4)(e); it can only be in the authority conferred by clause (d) of Section 13(1) by the

Central Government. The Central

Government has, in exercise of the power under Section 13(1)(d) prescribed that form of declaration and the particulars to be contained in the declaration. A direction that there shall be a separate declaration in respect of each individual transaction may appropriately be made in exercise of the power conferred under Section

13(1)(d). The State Government is undoubtedly empowered to make under sub-section (3) and (4) of Section 13;

but the rules made by the State

Government must not be inconsistent

Civil Appeal No.1208 of 2025 with the provisions of the Act and the

Rules made under sub-section (1) of

Section 13 to carry out the purposes of the Act. If the authority to make a Rule prescribing that the declaration shall not contain more than one transaction can be made only under Section 13(1)(d), the

State Government cannot exercise that authority.

.. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. ..”

(emphasis added)

18. Therefore, for the reasons set out above, it is not possible to find fault with the view taken by the High Court that sub-rule (20) of Rule 17 of the Rajasthan Rules is inconsistent with the Central Registration Rules framed in exercise of power under clause (d) of sub-section (1) of

Section 13 of the CST Act.

19. Hence, the appeal must fail and the same is dismissed with no order regarding costs.

.…......………………….J.

(Abhay S Oka)

.…....…………………...J.

(Ujjal Bhuyan)

New Delhi;

April 16, 2025.

FAQ :

The case concerned the validity of sub-rule (20) of Rule 17 of the Central Sales Tax (Rajasthan) Rules, 1957, which allowed authorities to cancel validly issued Form C declarations.

The Supreme Court declared sub-rule (20) of Rule 17 of the Rajasthan Rules to be ultra vires, meaning it was beyond the powers granted by the Central Sales Tax Act.

The Court found that the State of Rajasthan did not have the legal authority under the Central Sales Tax Act to frame a rule permitting the cancellation of validly issued Form C declarations.

A Form C declaration is a document used in inter-State sales to claim lower tax rates under Section 8(1) of the Central Sales Tax Act, provided certain conditions are met.

Based on this judgment, authorities cannot cancel validly issued Form C declarations under the Rajasthan rule in question, as the rule itself has been found to be invalid.

 



Judgement posted by

Guest

Comments




CCI Pro



Company
Featured 07 November 2026
Chartered Accountant

DPV & Associates

Chennai

CA

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 29 October 2026
Article Assistant (CA Inter / CMA Inter) - Thrissur

Varma Raja & Associates

Thrissur

CA Inter

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 17 November 2026
Vacancy for Articleship

Promptitude Accounting Services Private limited

Bengaluru

B.Com

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 07 November 2026
Article Assisstant

DPV & Associates

Chennai

CA Inter

View Details
Company
30 October 2026
Asst Manager Accounts

Goodwin Pumps India Pvt Ltd

Chengalpattu

CA Inter

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 16 November 2026
Audit Executives

Loonker Godawat And Company

Bengaluru

B.Com

View Details
Company
16 November 2026
Indirect Tax Associate

Sekhri Kanodia & Associates

Mumbai

B.Com

View Details
Company
13 November 2026
Chartered Accountant - Fresher

Neeraj Bhagat & Co

New Delhi

CA

View Details