Wasn't the may16-law paper unfair? hope d results are not!!

Final 4955 views 69 replies

Dear Shubham Maheshwari, i have written the answer to Q.2b with reference to the provisions of Sec.408 of Companies Act,1956

However, i did not give section reference in the answer (as the question had asked to write w.r.t. Companies Act,2013)

Replies (69)

Dear Shubham Maheshwari, i have written the answer to Q.2b with reference to the provisions of Sec.408 of Companies Act,1956

However, i did not give section reference in the answer (as the question had asked to write w.r.t. Companies Act,2013)

And i could not write Q.4c relating to tariff & Advisory properly.

Frankly speaking i could mange to write only worth 84 marks as i found that the time given was insufficent to write proper answers as per their expectations.

maithili...attempting 84 marks is not a joke.why do u bother abt law?u will get above60
really srujan?? even i have attempted 84..
but answers should be accurate yar.guess answers should be ignored from counting

84 marks... Wow well done !!!

Here i hardly managed 2 cross 70 marks.

in such a difficult paper it will get count
srujan.. my own experience
k.then fine saurabh.u need not bother abt law score
friends just 5 more days to go for the results.
be cool n calm..
ur hard work will pay..
dont think too much.
u did d hard work
results r not in ur hand n its beyond ur control..
stay cool.. hope for d best..
BEST OF LUCK

ICAI HAVE UPLOADED SUGGESTIVE ANSWERS

Does anyone seen the length of answers in theoretical subjects... especially in law and audit in suggested answers

https://resource.cdn.icai.org/42669bos32452d.pdf

Originally posted by : srujankumar
maithili...attempting 84 marks is not a joke.why do u bother abt law?u will get above60

 

Dear srujankumar,

I too sincerely hope for an exemption and genuinely believe that i deserve it after putting in so much efforts for the past 6 attempts

However, based on my past experience , that possibility seems quite bleak

That is the main purpose for writing this article

Originally posted by : Shubham Maheshwari
Does anyone seen the length of answers in theoretical subjects... especially in law and audit in suggested answers

Dear Shubham , ideally the length of our answers must not matter much if we have gien proper reference  of the section, correlation of the question with the relevant section and logical conclusion.

However, based on past experience i feel that even length of answers matters for scoring good, atleast 1.5 sides are a must

They just give random marks

i don't think  they even read our answers fully..

All we get for our hours of hardwork is a 2/4

Strongly feel that Law & Audit correction has been very poor & unfair


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register