Vendor filed all purchase bills from 2017 to 2022 in B2C instead B2B. Wrongly entered my GST number

As my GST wrongly entered instead 15 digit vendor entered 14 digit only. Since 2017 all purchase bills input not taken by me. When I asked vendor regarding input they said that they paid GST in B2C rather in B2B. Now sales tax commissioner asked about the differences, I clearly explained the same to sales tax commissioner in 2022 and they asked to pay 7 lakhs. I paid some amount in DRC-3 for corresponding years. And they gave me clearance in 2022.

Again in 2023 october another DCTO serverd notices regarding same input difference. I explained DCTO what exactly happened. Now DCTO IS saying that they won't accept B2C input paid. Again asking me to pay all 2017-2022 input tax, interest, penalty. They are going against my properties. Please suggest sir what is exact justice. Shall I pay for the mistake which I didn't do. Or as once paid shall I pay again sir?

Kindly suggest me sir

 

Replies (7)
Quick Summary
A vendor mistakenly filed all purchase bills from 2017-2022 as B2C instead of B2B, incorrectly entering your GST number. Although you settled a similar issue with the sales tax commissioner in 2022, a new notice demands payment for the entire input tax, interest, and penalties, even blocking your bank accounts and targeting personal property. This situation requires a detailed response to the current tax officer, supported by all previous documentation and potentially legal counsel, to resolve the discrepancy and prevent unfair penalties.

Understanding the Situation You faced an issue with GST input due to a wrongly entered vendor GSTIN, which resulted in a mismatch.

Despite explaining the situation to the sales tax commissioner in 2022 and paying some amount in DRC-3, you're now facing another notice from the DCTO for the same issue.

Key Points to Consider - *Previous Settlement*: You had already settled the issue with the sales tax commissioner in 2022 and received clearance. -

 *Current Notice*: The DCTO is now asking you to pay the entire amount again, despite your explanation. - *B2C vs. B2B*:

The vendor claimed to have paid GST in B2C instead of B2B, which might be a crucial point in your favor.

 Possible Course of Action 1.

*File a Detailed Response*: Submit a comprehensive response to the DCTO, explaining the entire situation, including the previous settlement and the vendor's claim about paying GST in B2C.

 2. *Provide Supporting Documents*: Attach all relevant documents, including the previous clearance certificate, DRC-3 payment details, and any communication with the vendor. 3.

 *Seek Professional Help*: Consider consulting a tax professional or advocate to help you navigate this situation and ensure you're taking the right steps.

 4. *Protect Your Rights*: If the DCTO continues to pursue action against you, you may need to explore options like filing an appeal or seeking protection from the higher authorities

Justice and Fairness It's essential to ensure that you're not unfairly penalized for a mistake that wasn't entirely yours.

 If you've already paid some amount and received clearance, it's reasonable to expect that the matter would be considered settled.

You may want to emphasize this point in your response to the DCTO and seek a fair resolution .

Understanding the Situation You faced an issue with GST input due to a wrongly entered vendor GSTIN, which resulted in a mismatch.

Despite explaining the situation to the sales tax commissioner in 2022 and paying some amount in DRC-3, you're now facing another notice from the DCTO for the same issue.

Key Points to Consider - *Previous Settlement*: You had already settled the issue with the sales tax commissioner in 2022 and received clearance. -

 *Current Notice*: The DCTO is now asking you to pay the entire amount again, despite your explanation. - *B2C vs. B2B*:

The vendor claimed to have paid GST in B2C instead of B2B, which might be a crucial point in your favor.

 Possible Course of Action 1.

*File a Detailed Response*: Submit a comprehensive response to the DCTO, explaining the entire situation, including the previous settlement and the vendor's claim about paying GST in B2C.

 2. *Provide Supporting Documents*: Attach all relevant documents, including the previous clearance certificate, DRC-3 payment details, and any communication with the vendor. 3.

 *Seek Professional Help*: Consider consulting a tax professional or advocate to help you navigate this situation and ensure you're taking the right steps.

 4. *Protect Your Rights*: If the DCTO continues to pursue action against you, you may need to explore options like filing an appeal or seeking protection from the higher authorities

Justice and Fairness It's essential to ensure that you're not unfairly penalized for a mistake that wasn't entirely yours.

 If you've already paid some amount and received clearance, it's reasonable to expect that the matter would be considered settled.

You may want to emphasize this point in your response to the DCTO and seek a fair resolution .

Thank you sir for your support. Here DCTO not at all considering about previous orders, he just saying it is not my order and I won't consider it.

He asking to pay all amount of 20 lakh or go to Appeal. The person who gave clearance to me in 2022 he is now CTO for our division. DCTO under CTO itself doing all this sir. 

They blocked my Bank accounts and they are now going against my personal properties house and shop. They are trying to give notice to House sir

 it seems like you're facing a challenging situation with the Deputy Commissioner of Trade Tax (DCTO) not considering previous orders and demanding payment of ₹20 lakh or appealing. Let's break down the key points:

Previous Orders -

*Non-consideration*: The DCTO is not considering the previous orders, which might have implications for your case. -

*Change in Officer's Stance*: The person who gave clearance in 2022 is now the Commissioner of Trade Tax (CTO), but the DCTO under the same CTO is taking a different stance.

Current Situation - *Blocked Bank Accounts*: Your bank accounts have been blocked, and the DCTO is proceeding against your personal properties, including your house and shop.

- *Notice to House*: The DCTO is attempting to issue a notice to your house.

Next Steps - *Seek Legal Counsel*: Consult with a lawyer or tax professional who can help you navigate this situation and provide guidance on the best course of action. -

*Appeal*: Consider filing an appeal against the DCTO's order, as suggested by the officer. -

*Representation*: Ensure that your lawyer represents you in all interactions with the tax authorities. Importance of Documentation - 

*Maintain Records*: Keep detailed records of all correspondence, orders, and notices received from the tax authorities. - 

*Evidence*: Gather evidence to support your case, including documentation of previous orders and clearance.

 By taking a strategic approach and seeking professional guidance, you can address the DCTO's demands and work towards resolving the issue .

Practical position: most of this ITC is likely lost, but some remedies exist:

• Sec 16(4) time limits for FY 2017-18 to 2021-22 have passed (latest: 30 November 2022 for FY 2021-22). GSTR-1 amendments for those years are also closed. The vendor can no longer re-report the invoices as B2B to your GSTIN.

• Sec 16(5) (Finance Act 2024) relaxed 16(4) for FY 2017-18 to 2020-21, but only where ITC was claimed in returns filed up to 30 November 2021. It doesn't help if you never claimed it.

• Judicial relief: several High Courts have directed authorities to allow ITC, or let the supplier amend GSTIN errors, where the supplier made a clerical GSTIN error and the tax was actually paid. Examples: Madras HC in Sun Dye Chem (2020), and Kerala and Orissa HC rulings permitting rectification for bona fide errors. Courts sometimes direct the GSTN to open the portal for correction. This needs a writ, so weigh the amount at stake.

• Commercial recovery: ask the vendor to compensate. Their reporting error caused the loss. The tax they paid is "B2C output", but they gain nothing; you lost the credit.

• Going forward: reconcile GSTR-2B monthly. Missing invoices should be chased within the same year.

Do not pay the same demand twice without first reconciling the earlier order and payment. A vendor’s B2C reporting generally does not place the supply in your GSTR-2A/2B as an invoice to you, so input tax credit cannot be established merely by showing that the vendor paid tax. The 14-digit GSTIN entry may also have prevented the invoice from being matched to your registration. Whether credit can nevertheless be defended depends on the invoices, proof of receipt and payment, the vendor’s returns/payment records, and the law applicable to each tax period.

  • Obtain the 2022 order/closure or payment record, DRC-03 challans and the 2023 notice and order, if any. Check whether the earlier matter covered the same periods, invoices and tax amounts; a mere “clearance” may not bar a later proceeding unless supported by a formal order or other closure record.
  • File a written reply with an invoice-wise reconciliation, proof of goods/services received and payment, vendor confirmation and tax-payment evidence. Ask the officer to give credit for amounts already paid and to identify the legal basis and computation for any remaining demand. Do not rely only on the vendor’s statement that tax was paid under B2C.
  • If an adverse order or recovery action has been issued, note the service date and promptly consider the statutory appeal and any available stay/pre-deposit route. Do not ignore attachment or recovery notices; limitation periods matter. The applicable remedy depends on whether the 2023 communication is only a show-cause notice or a final order.

This issue calls for a careful invoice-wise GST reconciliation and review of the 2022 and 2023 records before responding to recovery. Manual practice work across years is difficult, and automation can reduce repetitive checks while professional judgment remains in control. At Jir AI, our 2,000+ AI agents and 650+ integrations streamline GST, ITR, TDS, TCS and other compliance workflows, helping reduce manual workload by up to 70%. For a workflow walkthrough, connect with us on WhatsApp: https://wa.me/message/3HVOZ7HIY4ESC1

Sir, Now they are threatening by calling and by sending threatening messages that they are attaching my only one property which is in my name also although the property bought with another person of 200 sq yards only. They are sending mails from their personal mails and ACTO@gmail.com. What shall I do? It's making me think of leaving the place where I born and bought for 40 years. These GST sales tax people are harassing me since feb 2021. In 2022 October I paid 7 lakhs some amount through DRC-03 and some amount to CTO. Again DCTO who came as incharge he again asked to pay Amount which is having difference. I paid 3 lakh to that DCTO and I closed my firm in October 2023. All this happened because since 2017 to 2023 a vendor whom I purchased for 7 years he didn't give me input as he wrongly entered my GST number instead of 15 numbers he skipped one number and entered my account with 14 numbers. So the sales tax people gave me notices in 2021. We verified all accounts and found that the mistake is happened by my vendor. Nearly I purchased 1.4 cr of stock of pharma at 12% and 18% products. Especially we didn't have 2B or 2A options till 2020. So I filed returns according to my purchases. All this i explained to all sales tax people from 2021 to till date. In October newly appointed DCTO called me and forced me to come if not you will be jailed, almost 3 years later they restarted my case again. I went to new officer and explained the same what happened from 2021 to 2023-24. I gave all notices and Paid DRC-03 reports to him and explained about my vendor mistake and provided them the letter which the vendor gave me stating that he paid tax to government by B2C instead of My B2B. Earlier CTO and DCTO convinced with that letter and left me I said to new present DCTO and showed that I closed my firm itself in 2023 October. All after listening my reply they sent mail from other DCTO who is other area DCTO where my property belongs that too it's not government official website m, they sent through personal Gmail ( ______areaDCTO@gmail.com) through this mail they informing me that my property will be attached if not paid full 16 lakh. They are all threatening me like that. Please do kindly suggest me what should I do. I left my business which I ran for 13 years and working as a medical salesman for a company.

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  

Company
Featured ARTICLESHIP 17 November 2026
Associate/ Article Trainee

M/s. A V C & Co.

New Delhi

CA Inter

View Details
Company
24 October 2026
CA Industrial Trainee

Fytomax Nutrition Private Limited

Aurangabad

CA Inter

View Details
Company
28 October 2026
Assistant Director/ Associate Director-Finance & Accounting

Krea University

Chennai

CA

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 07 November 2026
Article Assisstant

DPV & Associates

Chennai

CA Inter

View Details
Company
30 October 2026
Asst Manager Accounts

Goodwin Pumps India Pvt Ltd

Chengalpattu

CA Inter

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 17 November 2026
Vacancy for Articleship

Promptitude Accounting Services Private limited

Bengaluru

B.Com

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 23 October 2026
CA Articleship / Article Assistant

M N Rao & Associates LLP

Vijayawada

CA Inter

View Details
Company
Featured 07 November 2026
Paid Assisstant

DPV & Associates

Chennai

CA Inter

View Details