TaXpert
12483 Points
Posted on 09 October 2007
There is a same answer for both type of assessees that assessee can raise his capital by the amount of additions made by the AO
Chartered Accountant
4609 Points
Posted on 09 October 2007
If you make the additon to capital .........it would tantamount to accepting concealment .........resulting into penalty or prosecution
TaXpert
12483 Points
Posted on 10 October 2007
Mr. Jain,
The assessee has been deposited the demand and does not went to appeal, isn't this tantamount to accepting concealment?
2371 Points
Posted on 13 October 2007
When You all R in practice,give Free Hand to client and You manage/plan your presentations in the framework of laws,You all R confused By Laws and adding confusions of each other,It's an estimated allowances,How come when one Pay Tax on such dis allowances and not credit to capital accounts?Rest thing based on your presentation planning.
Program Manager
10026 Points
Posted on 13 October 2007
Hi Prakash,
I agree with you comment for the confusion, but would request you to further clarify the point raised by Rucika
2371 Points
Posted on 13 October 2007
Estimated dis allowances, By AO without Acceptance by Client is arbitrarily added by AO,Tax Payments/adjusted for such additions being Tax Paid Capital,As Grounds for Estimations Is further Planning points to contest addition. but as AO once recovered tax Client Got full right to credit in to capital accounts.
Program Manager
10026 Points
Posted on 13 October 2007
Thanks Mr Prakash, I Agree with you fully, hope team also agrees on the same
Chartered Accountant
4609 Points
Posted on 13 October 2007
ON : 10/13/2007 6:56:40 PM
Explanation 2 to section 271(1)(c) reads as follows:
Explanation 2.—Where the source of any receipt, deposit, outgoing or investment in any assessment year is claimed by any person to be an amount which had been added in computing the income or deducted in computing the loss in the assessment of such person for any earlier assessment year or years but in respect of which no penalty under clause (iii) of this sub-section had been levied, that part of the amount so added or deducted in such earlier assessment year immediately preceding the year in which the receipt, deposit, outgoing or investment appears (such earlier assessment year hereafter in this Explanation referred to as the first preceding year) which is sufficient to cover the amount represented by such receipt, deposit or outgoing or value of such investment (such amount or value hereafter in this Explanation referred to as the utilised amount) shall be treated as the income of the assessee, particulars of which had been concealed or inaccurate particulars of which had been furnished for the first preceding year; and where the amount so added or deducted in the first preceding year is not sufficient to cover the utilised amount, that part of the amount so added or deducted in the year immediately preceding the first preceding year which is sufficient to cover such part of the utilised amount as is not so covered shall be treated to be the income of the assessee, particulars of which had been concealed or inaccurate particulars of which had been furnished for the year immediately preceding the first preceding year and so on, until the entire utilised amount is covered by the amounts so added or deducted in such earlier assessment years.
AS SUCH IF THE ASSESEE TRIES TO EXPLAIN ANY INVESTMENT IN SUBSEQUENT ASST YEARS THROUGH ADDITIONS MADE IN EARLIER YEAR EXPLANATION 2 TO SECTION 271(1)(C) MAY BE INVOKED BY A.O .BETTER NOT TO TAKE THIS RISK.
Chartered Accountant
4609 Points
Posted on 13 October 2007
PLEASE NOTE THAT WHEN ONE CREDITS THE ADDITIONS IN EARLIER YEAR TO CAPITAL ACCOUNT , THE CAPITAL IS RAISED , TO EXPLAIN SOME ASSET.
2371 Points
Posted on 14 October 2007
Mr SJ thanks for reproducing Explanation 2 to section 271(1)(c),as per my view is not applicable to Estimated Dis allowances,Which R arbitrary in nature.
Chartered Accountant
101 Points
Posted on 14 October 2007
Dear friends, The IT department has "Disallowed the expenses" and not resorted to finding concealed income.
Hence It is only a matter of additional demand by the IT dept on some pretext and not because of any "income" concealed or not concealed.
The assessee has only accepted the demand to avoid any legal non-complaiance or any other disputes probably to maintain good relationship with IT department.
1) Hence In such a situaton
a) the assesse cannot add the amount of disallowances to the credit of capital account since there is no "income" in real terms
b) The additional demand by the IT depat, for having been paid out of the bank account, should be deducted from the capital account in the year in which the demand is paid.
Trust this clarifies
Ravisankar
2371 Points
Posted on 15 October 2007
Questions of Maintenance of Relationship does not arise in legal Parlance,As far as Tax is paid You have Every Right to get credit In capital accounts,If it's otherwise it's like You provide alimony to your wife and not enjoy your rights............................LOL
Chartered Accountant
4609 Points
Posted on 15 October 2007
If you go through the judicial pronouncements on estimated additon and penalty for concealments ........you will find that penalty was deleted on the ground that addtion was on estimated bais and it was not proved that the income was actiually earned . If the income is not established , where is the question of concealment of income .
But the situation will be different when assesee himself utises the additon for explaining investment/assets or reducitin of liabilities . In such case he is not disputing the factum of income being there . Then in my opnion the judicial pronuncements on estimated addtion and penalty will not be applicable.
Explanation 2 nowhere excludes estimataed addtion from its purview.
2371 Points
Posted on 15 October 2007
We have enough argument on this topic and clear essence of the matters to th queries t ruchika more
,Now let her to decide about course of actions she has to initiate for her clients,Because of Conflicting view prevails.