Save Rs 499. Go Ad-Free with CAclubindia Pro for 2 Full Years. Subscribe Now!

TN Manoharan sir or VG sir?

CA Final 654 views 11 replies

Anu Sharma

333 Points Posted on 10 August 2018

Started off with VG sir's for the first time - all the module set. But feeling that it is not going too good and fast and I may not complete in time. I also have G1 to do.
Some say TNM sir 's will be easy. Though I have read his book for ipcc, I havent seen his book for final. Pl help me decide. Should I buy TNM Sir' s?

Replies (11)

Prakash Gehani

Consultant & Teacher(Whatsapp 8718057907

1306 Points Posted on 10 August 2018

why cant you refer summary module of VG sir.

Anu Sharma

333 Points Posted on 10 August 2018

I don't think it will be enough. I'm not sure should I say to refer just a summary module.

akash7004229805@gmail.com

105 Points Posted on 10 August 2018

Always consider ICAI study material as base material for preparation ....In fact TN sir modules are more broader than V G sir books ....So opt for V G sir book specially if you are taking V G sir classes ....but T N sir book is made especially for self study

Anu Sharma

333 Points Posted on 10 August 2018

@ akash I ain't taking any classes. And it is not my first attempt too. The thing is I had not used any full book in Prev attempts. Just summaries. I feel a good full book is something I need for proper scoring esp for explanation part in qns and some difficult chapters. So only I bought VG sir's.

akash7004229805@gmail.com

105 Points Posted on 10 August 2018

V G sir book is more beneficial for those who have taken classes from him ....not best for self study

Anu Sharma

333 Points Posted on 10 August 2018

Oh.. Ok thanks I'll see what to do.

Vaishnavi Ganesh

Chartered Accountant

861 Points Posted on 10 August 2018

Go with TNM book, It is suitable for quick and detailed. It doesn't consume time reading it.. TNM also has the summary book. Both are good.

Vaishnavi Ganesh

Chartered Accountant

861 Points Posted on 10 August 2018

Go with TNM book, It is suitable for quick and detailed. It doesn't consume time reading it.. TNM also has the summary book. Both are good.

study full books or summary ,but make own notes and solve vg sir's scanner .without solving scanner it wil be very difficult to get even 40 regardless how how many times you studies the concept book.