Learner
4016 Points
Joined December 2009
Dear Rahul,
God one bhai........!
First lets remind ourselves that what is taxable under House Property is "Annual Value" which is computed after comparing actual rent with Fair market value n all....
So ur above decision to treat maintenance as separate Income may also back fire if FMV exceeds Rs. 1 Lac...becos House Property will be taxed at FMV + u have to show Rs. 50 k as additional income.
Secondly, for me it is a question of fact i mean if this thing is done just to claim expenses against those 50k then I dnt think that u have any chance to be listened by anyone
otherwise if both agreements r genuinehaving regard to FMV OF RENT then "YES" maintenance contract will be treated as separate income.