Salaries - doubt

Tax queries 2191 views 8 replies

 

Can somebody plz help me with this question. It's from the chapter Salaries:

 

Q} Mr Arvind is working in Indian Railways and apart frm basic salary, he is paid the following allowances:

 

Entertainment  allowance: Rs 1200 p.m

 

Uniform allowance Rs 800 p.m. Actual amount spent Rs 500 p.m.

 

Conveyance allowance Rs 2000 p.m. Spent for office purposes Rs 1200 p.m.

 

Special allowance to meet personal expenses while on duty Rs 5000 p.m.

 

Education and hostel expenditure allowance Rs 500 p.m. He has 2 children studying in school by staying in hostel.

 

Determine the taxable amount of the above allowances.

 

Answer given is Rs 40600. what i want to know is mainly the edu allowance part. u/s 10(14) it is given that education allowance would be exempt upto Rs100 per child per month for a max of 2 children and hostel allowance exemptwill be upto Rs 300 pm per child upto a max of 2 children. so it should be

 

EDu allowance recd: 500 x 2 children x 12 m = 12000

 

less: exempt u/s 10(14): (100 + 300) x 2 x 12 = (9600)

 

                                                                             2400

 

But they have taken the entire 12000 as exempt otherwise the answer doesn't come to 40600. plz tell me if i m going wrong somewhere or is there some error in the final answer given. the entire soln that i got is:

 

Ent allowance 1200 x 12 :             14400

 

(-) exempt (least of):

 

1) Rs 5000

 

2) 1/5 of sal (not given)

 

3) Actual amt recd                          (5000)                        9400

 

Uniform allowance – 800 x 12 :     9600

 

(-) exempt to the extent spent =    (6000)                          3600

 

Conveyance 2000 x 12 :               24000     

 

- exempt 1200 x 12:                      (14400)                         9600

 

Special allowance 5000 x 12 =      60000

 

(-) least of 60000 x 70% = 42000

 

Or

 

 6000 x 12 = 72000                         (42000)                        18000

 

Edu n hostel allowance 500 x 2 x 12 = 12000

 

(-) exempt: 400 x 2 x 12                        (9600)                       2400

 

                                                                                                         43000

Replies (8)

Maybe education allowance is fully exempt for children of Govt Employees.

I don't recall reading any such thing..

 

this question was not asked by you but still there is a mistake therefore correcting the same.

Special allowance to meet personal expenses while on duty Rs. 5000 p.m.

Exemption Limit in respect of Above Allowance:-

From 01.09.2008- Any Allowance granted to an employeeworking in any transport system for meeting his personal expenditure during his duty performed in the course of running of such transport from one placeto another place, provided that such employee is not in receipt of daily allowance – up to 70% of allowance, maximum of Rs. 10,000 p.m.

Up to 31.08.2008 – Any Allowance granted to an employeeworking in any transport system for meeting his personal expenditure during his duty performed in the course of running of such transport from one place to another place, provided that such employee is not in receipt of daily allowance – up to 70% of allowance, maximum of Rs. 6,000 p.m.

 

 

your query

You have solved it correctly, Rs, 2,400 shall be taxable.

https://taxbykk.blogspot.com/

 

https://www.facebook.com/pages/Indias-No-1-book-of-Taxation/279130225436358

Thank you so much Sir for pointing out the transport allowance part. I wasn't aware of it.

Well Your answer to the given question is not correct on two counts:

1. Firstly, conveyance or transport allowance granted to an employee to meet his expenditure for the purpose of commuting between the place of his residence and the place of his duty is exempted to the extent of Rs. 800 p.m. irrespective of actual expenditure incurred. Here, it may be noted that the nature of transaction should be looked into and the nomenclature is not that important. Since the amount is in the form of allowance it is to be treated like TRANSPORT allowance and to be exempted accordingly.

Thus the treatment would be:

Conveyance Allowance : Rs. 1200 x 12= 14,400

Less: Exempted u/s 10(14) , Rule 2BB

                                            @ Rs. 800 x 12= 9600

                                                                            4800

2. Secondly , if am not mistaken, the question donot mention children education allowance of Rs. 500 permonth per child. It simply mentions Rs. 500 per month

So, total allowance comes to Rs. 500 X12=6000 only (not 500x2x12 as calculated by you) 

The exemption comes to Rs. 300 X 2X12=7200 but limited to Rs. 6000 only ( actual allowance)

Thus the answer, of Rs. 40600 is correct in my view.

Think it over!

 

Your answer is correct. it may be wrong answer given

 

 

Entertainment Allowance        
Least from below:        
1. Actual Received   14400    
2. 20% of Salary   -    
3. Maximum   5000    
      9400  
Special Allowance   60000    
         
1. Maximum Amount   6000   120000    
2. 70% of salary   42000 18000  
         
Uniform Allowance     3600  
(800-500)*12        
         
Conveyence Allowance     9600  
(2000-1200)*12        
         
Education & Hostel     2400  
(500-400)*2*12        
         
         
      43000  

i agree with sunil on 2nd point and not on 1st point.

Education and hostal allowance is in total 6000 which was fully exempted (eligible up to 9600)

Total of rest all will be 40600/-


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register