LIVE GST Certification Course by CA Arun Chhajer begins 27th April. Register Now!!

Protest against icai - unite please

(Guest)

I gave first time CA final in November 2013. I got 35% marks. I actually didnt study much. Even didnt gave much inclination to it.

In May 2014 i studied and wrote good content as institute want. Here we come it gave almost same and even worst situation. I got 10 marks in ISCA then how did they give me 38 last tyme just by my story writing. However, i wrote technichal language this time.

Who all are not satisfied with results. Please comment here & lets show some unity. When CSAT students can show that then why not us. Please others who wana kind of be loyal to instittue we dont want your comments. out shoes have shown different world to us. So please humble request to lets us unite and make insitute teach lesson. Thanks!

Please share & we can write to PMO or some other authorities as well. Because unfair checking should be changed.

Reply
Follow
Share

147 Replies

(Guest)

Please share if we guys as students have little dignity in ourselves. Till what time things will go just like hit & trial. Till what time.

Shwetha R (CA ) (377 Points)
Replied 08 August 2014

Bro, I too there with u..

lagnesh (PARTNER) (137 Points)
Replied 08 August 2014

Apply Online for Verification, Inspection Or Certified Copies

WAIT FOR THE COPIES AND CHECK IT UR SELF ...

AND THEN GO AHEAD IF REQUIRED...

(Guest)

Please share your experiences here. I am writing to PMO and will provide this link there.

No offence to people who are there in institute. just about unfair checking. Why it is happening and till what time things will go like this. Students are in CA who are from lower or middle lower background. They cant afford Institute's Hit and Trial Games.

They have to support their familities as well. Than just giving exams. Students are there who can work very well. But just because of quiet a subjective degree. I repeat subjective degree..not geting job or placed their lives. Students are there who are giving 7-8 atttempts with whole dedication - already working at good positions. What kind of policies / checkers they have. What kind of subjective world they are living in. We just need details now. Thats it.

(Guest)

@ Lagnesh that we will apply for sure. But where we will go to get them check fairly. Where is authority to hear us prudently. Are we living in 20s or have we entered 21st century.......

(Guest)

Dont even we have courage to speak. I mean students are so dare of it. It is like some monopoly is going on of institute.

it is 2014 we can ask and speak on matters which we want to....pls get over of sleep. please

naqueeb ekta (article) (24 Points)
Replied 08 August 2014

Totally agree with you bro...Last time I also didn't study well and I got much better marks than this time...and this time I studied day and night..

CA Piyush Jhawar (Chartered Accountant) (545 Points)
Replied 08 August 2014

@ Chandan

Dude I agree with you, there should be some transparency in the system, as well we should also consider that paying 500 Rs. per copy for veiwing our copies is a huge sum and many people including me can't afford such a high amount.A case regarding this is going on in the Delhi High Court and we should move accordingly in this direction and try to get our copies @ Rs.2 per page via RTI.

CA D. Singhal (CA ) (490 Points)
Replied 08 August 2014

@ chandan bhatia: Totally agree with you, even after following suggested answers and rtps for answer writing approach, if students get out of the blue meagre marks, then what should they refer to? Institute should clarify this.

Further if the examinations system is so strengthened as it is said to be, why not upload the answer sheets of toppers so that other students can benchmark their performance and get to know what is working as a good writing approach and what is not. Also 500 per copy is indirect way of telling in one's face that "Ab leke dikhao"

kuldeep mundra (article) (56 Points)
Replied 08 August 2014

I am also wd u frn..same story wd me..no link between my performance and marks

kuldeep mundra (article) (56 Points)
Replied 08 August 2014

Frn I am also wd u....mera experience bi itna he kharab hai...nov 13 attempt m itne tuff papers hone k baad bi I scored better than may 14...n this time 2nd attempt hone k baad bi n mera 200% dene pe I scored lesser marks...feelin like lost..regretin that moment when I chose this profession....dun no what should I do further...bcoz I already gave my 200%...

(Guest)

Please make more comments.

Also, pls let me know why our thread is not appearing in popular discussions.

Share experiences we need to really give a note to them so that at least our voice reach at high command.

akansha (nil) (92 Points)
Replied 08 August 2014

same story here.. i request all such aggrieved students to write to pmo and as well as tweet through twitter account on the prime minister narendra modi profile..i have already done the same...keep writing him until a concern is not sought.