Nov 11 - indirect tax paper review

Final 5289 views 36 replies

 

Congratulations to all of you!!

Finally after days of extremely hard work we have our breath back.

I think the closing ceremony exam must have been really nice for everyone. Looking at the paper I was sure that people who have studied are gonna do wonders today. Sadly I don’t come in that category.

Paper was not difficult (that’s what most of the people were saying) and it was not lengthy. Questions were direct, and numericals marginally above average. Case studies of 30 marks and numericals of 25 makes it a bit difficult to score poorly in this subject. But things don’t come so easy in life, so avoid expecting too much.

Ratings:

Difficulty : 3/5

Length : 3/5

How was your all paper??? Please share.

 

And with this, we move ahead of our restricted life with books and study materials (worst case scenario : For two months).

Before going to exam all I wanted to do after the paper was sleeping but now there is zero interest in it.

Anyways… Best-est of luck to all of you for the results.

Hope we get more that what we expect.

Enjoy and party hard.

 

Sincere Best Wishes

Pranjal

Replies (36)

Yeah yaar last paper is quite goood but dont rate is 2.5 yar actually it ws not that much easy bhai

well ma papers ws quite gud 

satisfied with the three papers but costing may be a horror scene this time for mecrying

 

hope to get the most valueable thing from icai this time

well we cant do anymore, we have done our job its the time of icai to do their...

 

Enjoy life for some days now

nd ya as you said ZERO INTEREST IN SLEEPING NOW

paper was mixtype , simple medium hard all types q r thr

35 mark caselaw 30+2+3

It was a quite expected paper 

30-35 case laws

25 practial

20-25 amendments

Originally posted by : aNkuR jAin....................
Yeah yaar last paper is quite goood but dont rate is 2.5 yar actually it ws not that much easy bhai
well ma papers ws quite gud 
satisfied with the three papers but costing may be a horror scene this time for me
 
hope to get the most valueable thing from icai this time
well we cant do anymore, we have done our job its the time of icai to do their...
 
Enjoy life for some days now
nd ya as you said ZERO INTEREST IN SLEEPING NOW

True... I thought it was because every one was so happy for it. For me toh it was hard as i didn't study the way i should have... 

Anyways have made the rating 3 now.... ;-)

Enjoyyyyy

All caselaw frm icai may-nov case law material

Paper was good. ICAI ne kush kar diya. Ab ICAI ki puja suru. 

yr in Q 1a 

120Lacs of removal of other assessee......

need not to be considered na????

I think the last 2 papers DT and IDT were not upto the mark of CA Final...

Instiute shall bring in some transperancy in copy checking process but shall not downgrade the standard of papers...The level of these CA Final papers was level of CA IPCC papers...

After all clearng CA Final Exams entitles you the membership of Institute and you are part of the profession then, you should have expertise knowdlege about these subjects...

 

 

 

 

120 LAC IN Q1 a NEEDS TO BE ADDED
CASE LAW AND SOME SMALL QUESTIONS WERE DIRECTLY FROM RTP NOV 11
PAPET WAS QUIT GOOD FOR ME! LOTS OF AMEMENDMENTS AND CASE LAWS FROM CA VISHAL BHATTED AND DIPPAK GUPTA SIRS' MATERIAL! THANK GOD THAT I HAD ATTENDED THE AMENDMENT BATCH OF VISHAL BHATTAD SIR AT PUNE

The paper was damn easy i was disappointed with the difficulty level. It was too easy i expected a bit tougher paper than this

as expected ICAi has changed paper patern fater the dark days of Uttam Prakash Agarwal

good to c our concept being tested now

Paper was on similar pattern of May11

but hope checking is alo as per expectation

 


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register