No Value of CA's

Page no : 3

shailesh agarwal (professional accountant) (7642 Points)
Replied 05 May 2009

Originally posted by :Vinay

Amit, I think you will not get any job or even if you get it you will not do any value add..... unless & untill you change your attitutde.... it is not only you but many of like you who cleared the CA in recent past of 3-5 yeras..... you know what ..... just before many of CA's including me were very hard to get a salary of Rs 8-10 K pm just before 5-6 years & now freshers are not talking of any job if they dont get more than 6 Lac, Do you think that just by clearing one exam you have all skill set to be worth of Rs 6 LAc, I am sorry, but I am not saying you can't, only thing is change your attitude.

..... This is not the time you should think of salary but to gain the knowledge & expertise in your subjects ...... Dont ever think that Rs 15K is a small amount.... if you think so, you will be the big time looser...Take it as it comes or think what is that you can improve..... get into any job then you will realise "nothing is free & easy in this world "

ONE more very important thing from me is ..... our country will not grow unless we think of Self employment.... why do you wait somebody to recongise you, when you say that you have knowledge in all fields....added to that very important CA qualification..... Please all of you, remove the mask of employment & see the world with new eyes

My dear friend, I am not discouraging you, please have patience, wait for the right moment, and improve your skill set by that time.... whatever you do give full efforts leave rest to God.... " Karmanye vadhikaraste........... "

i like it

our country will not grow unless we think of Self employment.... why do you wait somebody to recongise you, when you say that you have knowledge in all fields....added to that very important CA qualification..... Please all of you, remove the mask of employment & see the world with new eyes

CA. Amit Daga (Finance Controller CA. CS. CFA. CIFRS. M.COM. ) (9017 Points)
Replied 05 May 2009

Hey Amit, I want to say one line .. Instead of searching the problems in others try to search your problem and solve it..

I am sure u will be get huge success.

But if you blame to others like this. you will never get a success

Now choice is urs

Amit

aakanksha saxena (employee) (41 Points)
Replied 05 May 2009

Hi ameet

Its really de-motivating to read all this and that too when our exams are round the corner.Even i think our institute hypes salary figures and placements whereas many good poeple with good skills are without jobs.

even for campus placements only 10% students get placed.i think the only thing you can do is that accept any job u get right now.not everyone is lucky to get 10 lakh package to start with. plz accept a job even if you find salary to be lower.atleast that would erase this 'fresh" and "no experience tag from your profile" and then you command a much higher price

aakanksha

CA CS CIMA Prakash Somani (Landmark Group) (23502 Points)
Replied 05 May 2009

First of all "If you wont have faith in ICAI then you wont have write just "CA" in your about me column" Right !!!

Keep faith in ICAI, it will give you output which may come sometimes with little delay. CA is one of the best and prominent degree in the finance, accounting and audit field.

What do you think that any other degree is paying very good in recent scenario, no not at all !! "Recession takes something from everything". So not only CA but also IIMs, IITs etc are also suffering with same backdrop.

All you can do is to try at your best, remember "koi marne ke dar se jeena nahi chod deta"

All the best !!

Max Payne (employed) (2569 Points)
Replied 05 May 2009

Dear Ameet,

Please dont lose heart. everything will take its time yaar. You join for ACCA or CPA or CS or CWA and pls work a the big 4 even if pay is low. U r talented. Make a reputation and puff up your resume. By 2011-12 the recession should be over and people like you will be in great demand.

Yes CA is not basically an industry course like MBA or ACCA. But please remeber that in the industry it is competence and not qualification that matters. and "first attempt" tag is created by coaching centers and not by the ICAI. everybody gets the same COP when they apply for membership friends. it does not say marks or attempt.

Ameet (L) (1678 Points)
Replied 05 May 2009

To Vinay,

Sorry, I did not agree that i m not giving any value to Rs. 15000/-. I also worked at Rs. 800/- at shop as salesman while i was just 14 year old. and now what i m expecting is as per what i have knowledge. So, before give the word "Amit, I think you will not get any job or even if you get it you will not do any value add..... unless & untill you change your attitutde". So Please think. U might not known to other fully or u can not understand the other person so easily Boss.

CA Mauparna Ghosh (Senior Audit Assistant) (75 Points)
Replied 05 May 2009

The market is really bad and not only you thousands of people are in need of job..At this stage if you keep blaming the institute and continue your arguments..that wont help You...So its better atleast accept a job irrespective of the monetary terms where you can learn something...That will add value to your professional degree and then you will be in demand whn the market resumes..Accept the reality else you will always keep complaining...and at the end of the day you will get nothing...If you are sitting idle now or going for sum other degree it wont help you, I am also pursuing my CA. i will appear for my first grp next month.i have already cleared my second grp.After passing out considering the market situation i am going to join my Firm in which i have completed my articleship.We are a specialist in Indirect Tax and ill prepare my self for future. Do you know the difference between a Learned and a Qualifies?? DO you know the menaing of patience? and do you have beleive in God?? If you did know all thes and had beleive in God you would not have blamed your institute so badly..Even we have grievances...I have done articleship and the stipend we get compared to the effort we put is not justified but thn I guess Our future will Pay us..Just beleive in yourself...And instead of cursing CA, respect your degree, you will get the return else you will always complain...

Aakash (Articled Assistant) (26 Points)
Replied 31 October 2012

The only 1 thing dat matters is your talent, except that no course in the world is worthy either its CA or any other.

So, its not the Value of the Course rather its the value of the peoples joining it. And Mr. AMIT for you specially if you are pursuing CA, we should never pee in our courtyard & if not then stop finding drawbacks of others & mind your own.