Live Course on Drafting of Appeal and Reply of Penalty Notice by CA Sachin Sinha. Register Now!!

No theory question ?

ankit gindoria (http://ankitthewriter.blogspot.com/) (206 Points)

02 October 2009

new announcment just say that all questions are compulsory .....i heard the rumour regarding this a week before that all questions are going to be compulsory but with that there was good news that in practical theories there will be no theories like in costing, mafa and accts no thoery question were going to asked .....it seems insitute has decided to corner us and shoot us ......it really impossible to believe that there will be no option .......

does institute reply to mailes ? had anybody try to send them mail

Reply
Follow
Share

20 Replies

ankit gindoria (http://ankitthewriter.blogspot.com/) (206 Points)
Replied 02 October 2009

other impt thng i notice is that impression president was imposing on practical part of CA ...so i believe new pattern will be somethng like that ...no option+no theory question .....it will make me happy

CA Dhiraj Ramchandani (CA, M. com) (10823 Points)
Replied 02 October 2009

yes, as per notification it seems so... that is income tax, coxting, etc will have practical Qs,... and audit and law too will have practical cases...

And yes, its goin to benefit us all a lot... Coz our articleship tenure is so long, that v get various practical aspects to learn, and v cn impose them overthere....

AND YES INSTITUTE REPLIES TO UR MAILS.... I'VE MAILED FEW TIMES...

MEHUL SHAH (Auditing Taxation XBRL Training ) (440 Points)
Replied 02 October 2009

On what email id should we ask our queries to institute and is it for sure that no theories for COsting and MAFA.. I think Institute should come up with more clear notification.. As does it mean totally elimination of thery question or does it mean that they shall ask Practical type theory questions ??

CA Dhiraj Ramchandani (CA, M. com) (10823 Points)
Replied 02 October 2009

Originally posted by :MEHUL SHAH
"	On what email id should we ask our queries to institute and is it for sure that no theories for COsting and MAFA.. I think Institute should come up with more clear notification.. As does it mean totally elimination of thery question or does it mean that they shall ask Practical type theory questions ??	"

Hi mehul, it shd b on mss @ icai.org

(Guest)

i think the notification is applicable to theory subjects like audit, law etc. so instead of asking purely theoretical questions there, we will be asked the practical aspects of the various sections. but as for cost or mafa or accounts, i don't think they are going to scrap theory.

but that's what i think. if anyone finds out anything let the rest of us know.

ankit gindoria (http://ankitthewriter.blogspot.com/) (206 Points)
Replied 02 October 2009

i have mailed the institute ....hopefully they do reply with some positive news..

hi,

i have query regarding latest announcement issued by insitute on 30/09/09 ...i am CA final student old course ...in latest announcement it was mention that all questions are going to be compulsory and institute is going to focus on practical questions ....so my querry is whether we are going to get theory part in mafa, accounts and costing ? is it means we will get more practical case laws in audit and law and lessen theory questions? it is very important for institute to enlighten us regarding new pattern we are going to get in our exams ...so that we can focus on impt factor instead of studying things which institute dont consider impt ....insitute new announcement have left whole CA students in very confused position and we expect some clear clarification from insitute....it just 1 month to our exams and new announcement has really shook our studies ....i behalf on whole CA student community expect some clear announcement from institute

thanks in advance

CA LOVELY ARORA (C.A. B.Com (H) Graduate) (2151 Points)
Replied 02 October 2009

the notification/announcement is regarding practical aspect of questions that will be asked in exams, not the practical questions only. The Questions would be related to practical training done by C.A. Articles/Students.

ankit gindoria (http://ankitthewriter.blogspot.com/) (206 Points)
Replied 02 October 2009

arent they both the samethng ? what questions on practical training they can ask us ? i have no idea ...every student have obtain different article firm...some dont have audit experience (in short tax field or vice versa) ... i strongly believe they mean practical questions not questions on practical training

Himanshu grover (c.a. final) (375 Points)
Replied 02 October 2009

Originally posted by :Ankita Dev
"	i think the notification is applicable to theory subjects like audit, law etc. so instead of asking purely theoretical questions there, we will be asked the practical aspects of the various sections. but as for cost or mafa or accounts, i don't think they are going to scrap theory. but that's what i think. if anyone finds out anything let the rest of us know.	"

Manmohan ACA, CS (Chartered Accountant ) (14243 Points)
Replied 02 October 2009

Practical question doesnot means practical sums only..
It means practical oriented questions including practical oriented theories

ankit gindoria (http://ankitthewriter.blogspot.com/) (206 Points)
Replied 02 October 2009

but in costing i dont think we get practical oriented related theories ...do we ?

CA Tushar Lakhanpal (CA) (416 Points)
Replied 03 October 2009

yar it is very bad...

i dont have 2 much experience of articleship

i have learned in taxation area only

my ca doesn;t involve any article in audits etc

NOw will it be difficult attempting such questions???

Ankur Begwani (Article Assistant) (25 Points)
Replied 03 October 2009

i think the notification is applicable to theory as well as pratical papers. so instead of asking purely theoretical questions, we will be asked the practical aspects i.e. question like case studies. i don't think they are going to scrap theory. So enjoy papers nd smile always................................