MEDICAL EXPENSES OUTSIDE INDIA

333 views 3 replies
Mrs.R,wife of R who is employed in G LTD went for bypass surgery in England alongwith her husband.Expenscs on medical treatment of wife and stay outside India of wife and R amounted
.to 7,00,000 as against 6,50,000 permitted by RBI Guidelines.The travel expenses amounted to 1,50,000.All expenses were reimbursed 'by the employer.Assume the gross salary and
income from other sources of the employee are 1,40,000 and 40,000 respectively.The taxable perquisite in this case shall be:
(A)Nil
(B)50,000
(C)2,00,000
(D) 1,50,000
Replies (3)

1. According to sec 17(2)(vi), perquisite does not include if the medical expenses incurred abroad for family members if the same was reimbursed by the employee.  
2. However, the above provision is subject to two conditions,
i)  Expenditure on Medical treatment and stay abroad to the extent allowed by RBI and 
ii) Expenditure on travel shall be excluded if the employee's Gross total Income without including the above perquisite does not exceed Rs. 2,00,000.  
3. From the above provision we can easily conclude that his Gross Total Income (Rs. 1,40,000 +  40,000= 1,80,000) does not exceed Rs. 2,00,000, so his travel expenses should not form part of perquisite. 
4. With respect to Medical Expenditure to the extent allowed by RBI will not form part of Perquisite. So, out of Rs. 7,00,000, Rs. 6,50,000 will not form part of perquisite and the balance Rs. 50,000 will be taxable as perquisites.
5. Solution for the above question would be Rs. 50,000. 
Please correct me if the above solution has an alternative view. 

Yes, you are absolutely correct but this question I picked from practical approach to Income tax 37th edition and its answer Is (c) 2,00,000. I don't know how it come from. If you have another application please guide me. And thanks for your answer.

I don’t see any other interpretation for the above question. But they could have included Travel expenditure of Rs. 150,000 as not allowed by RBI. Possible for this view also. Even though clearly travel expenditure should not form part of perquisite, but if they have added that to Rs. 7,00,000+1,50,000 = 8,50,000 less RBI allowed amount of Rs. 6,50,000 which gives us Rs. 2,00,000. This could be one view. But this makes the second condition irrelevant. 


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  

Related Threads
Loading