Job in TCS

CA 4508 views 10 replies

Friends I had gone through a post about TCS ( /forum/ban-tcs-from-icai-campus-89049.asp )  . I dont know why that guy is so harsh on TCS .Is there is anything true about the same . According to my belief it is one amongst the best companies to work in . Is there any problem in joining with the company? I need to select 5 companies for attending campus interview ...thats why I am asking ...

                        And one more question ....As far as CAs are concerned, which company is best to work with, a manufacturing company or IT company ? Please reply ...

Replies (10)
Originally posted by : Merina

Friends I had gone through a post about TCS ( /forum/ban-tcs-from-icai-campus-89049.asp )  . I dont know why that guy is so harsh on TCS .Is there is anything true about the same . According to my belief it is one amongst the best companies to work in . Is there any problem in joining with the company? I need to select 5 companies for attending campus interview ...thats why I am asking ...

                        And one more question ....As far as CAs are concerned, which company is best to work with, a manufacturing company or IT company ? Please reply ...

 

 

 

For A CA, In My Opinion a Manufacturing Co. is Always better in Compare to IT Co.............

In a Manufacturing Co. a CA can get a Job Satisfaction along with Money Satisfaction and on the Other hand in a IT Co. a CA may get Money but they have no Job Satisfaction…………….

 I would not like to Comment on any particular Company like TCS...etc.

Miss Marina, go for ur Passion.. Go for ur Dream.. If ur Long term target is to be a Financial Sector good to Select companies who are in that field like Irevana, Reliance Capital, IIFL.. If ur dream is it IT then go for TCS,Infy, Wipro.. if ur goal is to be in Mutual Funds go for Sundaram.. Much depends on ur Goals.. So good to ask this question to urself than on others opinion..
Ask urself in which field u dream to be in..?

Thanks Suresh Thanks LKR

Originally posted by : Suresh_Smiter




Originally posted by : Merina






Friends I had gone through a post about TCS ( /forum/ban-tcs-from-icai-campus-89049.asp )  . I dont know why that guy is so harsh on TCS .Is there is anything true about the same . According to my belief it is one amongst the best companies to work in . Is there any problem in joining with the company? I need to select 5 companies for attending campus interview ...thats why I am asking ...

                        And one more question ....As far as CAs are concerned, which company is best to work with, a manufacturing company or IT company ? Please reply ...






 

 

 

For A CA, In My Opinion a Manufacturing Co. is Always better in Compare to IT Co.............

In a Manufacturing Co. a CA can get a Job Satisfaction along with Money Satisfaction and on the Other hand in a IT Co. a CA may get Money but they have no Job Satisfaction…………….

 I would not like to Comment on any particular Company like TCS...etc.

Dear Suresh, even I too dont want to mention any company like TCS, rather I like that company very much being one among the companies which is giving a lot of jobs in India and have made a lot of achievments. I just got a doubt when I had found a post against that company. And I feel that it was too harsh against such a reputed comany ( /forum/ban-tcs-from-icai-campus-89049.asp ) . So I just asked  CCI's opinions ....thats all :-)

I work in TCS and I agree with the post....

No more comments!

Originally posted by : LKR ~ A CA in Making!!

Miss Marina, go for ur Passion.. Go for ur Dream.. If ur Long term target is to be a Financial Sector good to Select companies who are in that field like Irevana, Reliance Capital, IIFL.. If ur dream is it IT then go for TCS,Infy, Wipro.. if ur goal is to be in Mutual Funds go for Sundaram.. Much depends on ur Goals.. So good to ask this question to urself than on others opinion..
Ask urself in which field u dream to be in..?

Dear LKR , my dream is just to give justice to what I have learned and be happy. My articleship is just over and I am new to all these industries. So just asked CCI's opinion...thats all... :-)

Originally posted by : Sheli Sehrawat

I work in TCS and I agree with the post....

No more comments!

Thanks Sheli.

I am working in TCS, i agree wid the post. He is not harsh............

This is 100% correct that TCS lure not only freshers and humiliate them but they are now luring experienced CA personnel also in experienced CA's Campus interviews.

My experience with TCS :-

1) I was attending the ICAI Campus interview for experienced CA's at Kolkata on Jan 2011 where TCS was also one of the recruiters. First of all they shortlisted every one without knowing their credentials. To add some fun, they had shortlisted the participitants who were still working with TCS and applied for ICAI campus.

The result was that everybody was shortlisted by TCS and was present on the day of TCS interview. Shockingly TCS HR told ICAI personnel that interview could not be conducted as some TCS HR personnel were having some work. Then We , the TCS shortlisted candidates pressurised too much on ICAI people to conduct the interview or reimburse the Airfare to us.

Our pressure on ICAI works and anyhow TCS ready for conducting interview. It was like MACHI MARKET and they were humiliating CA's like a hell. The conducting TCS HR was totally inexperienced and was asking silly questions.

CA's were waiting for only one reason that ICAI had taken deposit of Rs.5000 and CA's were to compulsorily attend the TCS interview to claim the refund of deposit otherwise 90% CA's would have left. No body was in a mood to give TCS interview. Anyhow they selected one of my friend at meagre salary. Now my friend has recd the offer letter and they have offered the position of ASSITANT ENGINEER TO A CA. HOW SILLY YOU CAN THINK OF TCS.

 

2) One of my friend selected in a Campus interview at TCS in July 2010. They have tortured her like anything. First torturing in giving offer letter. Then calling for training without telling actual place of posting. It was for a month training and decided transfer was delhi. One very fine day before completion of one month, notice came from TCS that you have to shift to Kolkata and vacant the room. Anyhow she did but more torturing continues to her................

3) I met CA's at campus who working with TCS and want to left TCS as soon as possible.

 

This is my personal opinion and experience and it may vary with other persol.

The above article is disclaimed.

CA.Rakesh Kumar

Dear sister,

TCS is a software gaint and it has transactions all over the world.. hence u can be sure for a challenging career for a CA... i mean it covers all ur CA cirriculam.. DTAA's, international taxation, audit, IFRS etc... so if u can work for a considerable time and then come back to practise u can be a good CA practitioner... on the other hand if u wish to continue ... within no time u will be a part of the higher management team of the comapany.... 

This was advised to me by a Chartered Accountant working in a software company...

hope it is useful for u...

all the best..


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register