Idt bangar or vineet sodhani

For first time reading and understanding , go with bangur, complete syllabus is covered in 600 pages, make notes side by side , case laws prescribed by ICAI only are to be done,avoid irrelevant numerous cases given in bangur book.

if you have a problem with preparing own notes, then buy a revision book by yashwant mangal,book can be revised easily 1 day before exam.

dear Raj i dont no much more about tayal sir notes, if they are really helpful then plzz provide

Dear onis thanxx for ur valuable suggestion

I read last time from bangar sir book, bt it seems too comprehensive and lenghty , no summary are given , presentation is not much better, 

some views said that vineet sir book is much better in presentation and understanding point of view

thats the reason why i m confusd between the two

For revision , self prepared notes are best  

I hav'nt gone through vineet sodhani's modules but they are lengthy as compared to bangur and bungur, since you have once read the subject, buy yashwant mangals book ,  following link is a sample on service tax by mangal sir

/forum/service-tax-notes-by-ca-yashvant-mangal-267843.asp#.Uzu9E_kSbB0

thanxx for sharing the link , i will go through it

I got bangur 15 days back... started reading, seems fine, easy reading,  btw my attempt is in May15